Nicole

"Your time was a disappointing minute and thirteen seconds," Eric tells Jesse. "Which means," he continues that Nicole is in the lead. So," Eric turns to Nicole, "You will get to choose what test is next."

Eric drops the vibrator and stopwatch into the bin and pulls out a buttplug in one hand and a dildo in the other. "Which is it?" he asks.

Nicole looks from Eric to the dildo to the buttplug to Jesse and then back to the two toys in Eric's hands. "Who will be tested first, sir?"

Eric considers it for a moment. "I hadn't even thought of that," he says. "but I guess it's only fair that the winner chooses the order as well."

A smirk creeps across Nicole's face. "The buttplug then, sir. And Jesse goes first."

Jesse gasps. "You bitch!"

Eric smacks Jesse's tit and twists her nipple. Jesse's face scrunches up with pain. "I will not have you two calling each other names. Now apologize."

"Yes, sir," Jesse says demurely. "I'm sorry, Nicole."

Eric pulls a small key from his pocket and moves over to Nicole. "Plugs it is. And for the plug test, we're going to need you two in a different position." Eric unlocks the cuffs that hole Nicole's hands behind her back.

Nicole looks up at Eric's face. "I thought Jesse was going first, sir."

Eric rubs Nicole's ass soothingly as he repositions her arms. "She is. But you both need to be in the right position." Eric bodily turns Nicole so that her back is to Jesse . Then he reaches between her spread legs and pulls her arms through. Nicole's face is **** into the padded floor as Eric recuffs her wrists around the spreader bar that prevents her from moving her ankles. Eric gently lifts Nicole's ass into the air. "Stay," he commands.

Eric watches Nicole for a moment to make sure she stays in her uncomfortable position before turning to Jesse. He turns her shoulders so she is facing away from Nicole. Then Eric cuffs her hands between her ankles and lifts her ass up.

Eric kneels on the floor between the two women and pulls the bin to him. He reaches in and pulls out a bottle of lube and a full 10-piece set of different sized buttplugs all lined up on a little display piece. "For this competition," Eric announces, "I am going to stick a plug into your ass. The sister who can take the largest plug wins. I'll let you each choose which plug you start with."

Eric places the set of plugs on the floor and slides it into Jesse's line of sight. "Which one?" he asks and holds his pointed finger over the first one. Jesse takes a deep breath and shakes her head. Eric moves his finger to the second. Again, Jesse shakes her head. Eric moves to the third and then the fourth before Jesse nods. Eric pulls the plug from the display and drips some lube onto it. He massages the lube onto the whole surface and puts more on before turning his attention to the bare ass before him. Eric rubs a finger up Jesse's crack a few times. Jesse fidgets and tenses each time his finger slides over her hole. Eric drips some lube directly onto Jesse asshole and pushes his finger in. Jesse gasps at the intrusion and takes a deep breath before relaxing. Eric pushes his finger in to the first knuckle and then slides it out. He repeats this a few times and then pushes his finger in all the way. He repeats the process with his whole finger a few times before stopping and readying the plug.

"Are you ready?" he asks.

"Yes, sir," Jesse says.

Eric positions the point of the plug at Jesse's asshole and starts to push. As he pushes, he rotates the plug from side to side. It begins to slide into Jesse's ass. The plug that she had picked has a diameter of an inch and a half at its widest point and is three and a half inches long. It slides slowly into Jesse's ass until it gets past the widest point. Jesse is gritting her teeth and her eyes go wide as the plug suddenly jumps forward with relative ease. "It's in," Eric says, patting Jesse's ass. "Would you like to try the next size up?"

"Yes, sir," Jesse says.

Eric pulls the next plug from the display. This one is two inches wide and four inches long. Eric cover it with lube before pulling the other one from Jesse's ass. It pops out after a minor struggle and Jesse's asshole gapes open for a moment before clenching shut. Eric immediately starts pushing the next plug in. It slides in easily up to a point, but then Eric has to really twist and push it. Jesse is clenching her jaw and has her eyes closed tight. She's trying to control her breathing. The plug finally slips past its widest point and sets itself. "The next one?" Eric asks.

"No, sir," Jesse gasps.

"All right. Now it's Nicole's turn. The plug will stay in until I've decided it's been in long enough," Eric says to Jesse before turning to Nicole's ass. Eric sets the display back into the bin and withdraws another identical one, but this one has all ten clean plugs. Eric slides it into Nicole's line of sight. "Would you like to start with this one?" he asks, holding his finger over the first plug.

"Yes, sir," Nicole says.

Eric prepares the plug and Nicole's ass before sliding the plug in. It's only half an inch wide and slips in easily. "Would you like to try the next one?" he asks.

Nicole nods. Eric prepares the second plug and slides it in with relative ease. Then, with Nicole's consent, he moves up the third plug. Nicole keeps saying to go to the next one until she tells him to stop as he tries to push and twist a plug in.

"It's too much, sir," Nicole says.

Eric nods. He reinserts the previous plug and pats Nicole's ass soothingly. "It looks like we have a winner," he says.