Naturally

He couldn’t resist. Seeing the world shift around him so that Sarah McCormick could be his girlfriend had sparked a thirst within him that couldn’t be quenched. Already, her sister, a girl he’d never even met until now, seemed intimately familiar with him. At least, to the point where she could joke about the fact that he was boning her sister.

Not only did he now want to transform the younger McCormick sister into his girlfriend, he wanted to see the potential ramifications it would have on reality itself.

“Hey, Hannah!” He began, bringing the girl’s attention back to him, “You’re my bisexual girlfriend.”

At his words, the younger girl’s smirk widened. While her posture didn’t immediately change, the hunger that suddenly appeared in her eyes was proof enough that it had worked. Kicking the door closed behind her, she leaned up on her toes and kiss him deeply. Worried that Sarah would say something, Joe opened an eye and felt relieved to see that while the older sister was still flushed, she beamed happily at the pair of them.

“What kind of girlfriend would I be if I didn’t greet my man properly?” She whispered as the kiss broke. Hannah then turned to her sister, smiling like a lovestruck teenager. “You didn’t tell me he was coming over! I wouldn’t have invited Mel!”

Sarah blushed, embarrassed. “I, ahh… didn’t. He just showed up.”

“I missed my two favorite girls.” Joe lied as he pulled the younger McCormick sister closer into him, his cock poking her. She giggled as she reached down, grasping it in her hands. “Besides, I heard your parents were out.”

“I should’ve thought to take advantage of that.” His newest girlfriend admitted, pulling away from him. She seemed **** to let go of his crotch.

“They’ll be gone all day Hannah.” Sarah said as she rejoined the conversation, doing her best to uplift her sister. “Plenty of time for the three of us to have fun.”

“Speak for yourself! You’re publicly dating him! You don’t have to sneak around to be with your boyfriend.”

Oh? So his relationship with Sarah was known, but the one with Hannah was a secret? Given the fact that he was now dating two sisters who, by the wording of his wish, now supposedly loved each other as much as they loved him, it made sense they’d be hiding the incestuous aspect of their coupling.

“Don’t worry Hannah, you’re as much my girlfriend as Sarah is, secret or not. There’s enough of me for the both of you.”

That seemed to reassure her. “Still, don’t start without me!” the younger McCormick sibling said, pouting slightly. “Mel’s here, but she’ll leave within an hour or two. We should totally have a threesome when she’s gone.”

Next to him, Sarah walked over and clung to his arm, grinning mischievously at her sister. “I was thinking the same thing. Although,” she reached over and grabbed his cock, still solid as ever. “I might end up keeping this all to myself.”

“You wouldn’t dare!” Hannah called back, the hint of a challenge growing in her eyes. “If you tire him out, you’ll have to satisfy me all on your own, sis!”

While the girls bickered, a voice echoed through the closed door behind Hannah. While Joe didn’t recognize the voice, he figured it was Hannah’s friend Mel’s.

“You coming back Hannah? We really need to finish this assignment!”

As the two redheads playfought over him, Joe pondered what to do next.