Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 194 by Mr Nice Guy Mr Nice Guy

What's next?

My Son, Their Hands, Our Home

Donna closed the front door behind them, the solid click of the lock bringing her back to reality, pulling her from the teenage fantasy playing out in front of her. The entryway light spilled over the two girls already waiting inside, a vision so absurdly theatrical that for a moment she thought she had walked into one of those chaotic parties she used to host in her twenties. Juniper in satin and lace, Serena draped in gauzy harem silks, and Indira with her little overnight bag clutched in her hand, cheeks flushed from an entire car ride of kissing Joey.

She felt overdressed immediately. Too covered. Too severe. Her reflection in the hall mirror confirmed it—navy pencil skirt, crisp white blouse under her fitted blazer, brown hair still in the twin ponytails Joey liked. Makeup holding perfectly from earlier in the night, the smoky eyes and glossy lips that had looked so fitting when she was dolled up in that scandalous restaurant outfit. She looked powerful. She looked polished. But standing here next to her son's parade of lingerie models, she felt like a banker who had wandered into a boudoir.

But maybe that was the point? Donna had enjoyed all day with Joey. Tonight was for them. For Joey to enjoy his girls. Sure, she could watch, guide, help in any way they welcomed her, but tonight wasn't about her. She reminded herself of that as she tore her eyes away from the mirror.

Joey stood at her side, quiet as ever, and in a breath the girls moved.

Juniper was first. Of course she was. Her daughter stepped forward on stockinged feet, the bodysuit Donna herself had once worn, now showing off every curve of the younger woman's body. She slipped one hand up Joey's arm as naturally as a girl reaching for her boyfriend at the movies. Donna's stomach gave a small, traitorous twist. She told herself it was pride. That Juniper had grown up so fast. That she was blossoming into a woman who knew what she wanted. Who knew who she wanted.

Then Serena crossed the space like she was on a catwalk, gold bangles chiming against her wrist. Her harem silks caught the light, the loincloth and top showing so much skin that Donna's throat tightened. Serena's hand went straight to Joey's chest, palm flattening against the fabric of his t-shirt like she had always belonged there. She tilted her head, hair sliding forward, lips parting in a smile too knowing for someone her age.

And then Indira—sweet, modest Indira—set down her bag and joined them, eyes shy but steps firm. Her hand didn't hover or ask permission; it went directly to Joey's shoulder, squeezing it like a claim. Her other hand found his, lacing their fingers together. Donna’s breath caught at the boldness of it. For a girl raised in such strictness, Indira was learning fast.

Donna stayed frozen where she was, her polished heels sinking slightly into the welcome mat. She desperately wanted to be part of this, to join in with the fun, but it wasn't her time. That was something a mother had to understand, that sometimes you had to let the kids have space. A mother's role wasn’t just to feed and clothe, it was to step back at the right moment, to give her children freedom to explore, to love, to stumble, to rise. What kind of mother would she be if she smothered Joey with her own presence, if she crowded him when he was clearly flourishing? No, the good mother gave her children to the world, stood back and admired, and let them take what they needed. It was a part of growing up—for them, and for her. Besides, four women might be too much for Joey. But with three he didn't look overwhelmed. He looked steady, calm, radiant even, as three different bodies pressed closer to him.

Donna couldn't have been more proud.

Juniper leaned into his side. Serena pressed her chest against his arm. Indira clung to his hand like it was her anchor.

And Donna… watched. Her hands tightened on the strap of her purse. She wished, stupidly, that she had worn the slit dress again, or even the kittenish thing with the lace-up bodice. Something less severe. Something more playful. Something that would have made Joey's eyes flick toward her the way they did toward the other girls now.

But no. Again, this wasn't about her.

The four of them stood tangled together in the entryway, and Donna felt like a guest in her own home. She saw her reflection again in the mirror, navy and white, pressed and perfect, while the others glowed with bare skin and heat. The mother, the chaperone, the out-of-place observer.

And then Joey finally spoke, his voice cutting through the low hum of their breathing.

"Let’s go upstairs."

All three girls tightened their grip on him in unison, like strings pulled taut.

Donna stayed where she was, heart thudding. Upstairs. Of course.

What's next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)