May the b(igg)est man win!

Jack grinned as his thumb stroked along the curve of Candy's shoulder. "I did have an idea that might work," he said with a small shrug, "and it could be a contest and it might you feel better too, Candy."

"Really? How?" Candy turned more toward Jack now, enjoying the feel of his thumb stroking her skin.

"I know you were a little embarrassed after you hinted at how big Mister Hart was, and we both promise not to tell anyone about that, but... I thought it might help you feel better if you knew something secret about each of us!" Jack's hand slipped from Candy's shoulder to her upper back, still lightly rubbing her smooth skin. "Do you think that would help?" He glanced across to Mike and saw the confused and annoyed look on his face, but then looked to Candy and saw her slowly nodding her head.

"I think it would make me feel better. At least a little bit," she replied as his stroking hand made her feel even more relaxed. "What kind of secret did you want to tell me?"

"Something equal to what you told us, of course, but it's not the sort of thing we could tell you. I would have to be more of something we would show you." Jack's free hand was beneath the bubbling water and now, he did take a moment to adjust his straining cock in his briefs. "Since your secret was about Mister Hart and we know you wouldn't lie about it, I think it's only fair if you got to find out how big the two of us are." He glanced over to Mike again and saw that his friend was wide-eyed in disbelief at what Jack was suggesting. He continued, "And to make sure that we're all being honest, we'd have to show you instead of just telling you."

"You-- you want to show your.. penises?" Candy's eyes darted about in confusion, trying to make sure that understood the boy right.

"No," Jack quickly answered, trying to make sure that he hadn't scared the drunken blonde off. "We'll just take them out under the water, and you can feel our sizes for yourself. You don't even have to see them at all! And then you can decide who's bigger and the winner gets to pick where he sleeps for the night!" He slipped his hand hand up her back and gave her shoulder a light squeeze again, before giving her a solemn look and adding, "We really need you to be the judge, Candy."

The feel of Jack's caressing hand and his soothing words were making Candy feel even more relaxed and nibbling her lip, she gave a little nod. "All right.. If you keep them under the water and it's just a quick touch to see how big they are, I suppose that's all right."

The soccer player gave her a wide grin and then his asked his friend, "Does that sound fair to you, Mikey? If Candy's hands decide who the winner is?" Even if Mike knew he was going to lose, Jack was pretty sure that he wouldn't pass up a chance to get felt up underwater by the gorgeous MILF.

Predictably, after a nervous swallow, Mike nodded. "Yeah. That sounds okay."

"Then we all agree!" Jack slipped his hand off of Candy's shoulder and dipped it underwater to the waistband of his briefs. "I guess we'd better take them out!" Lifting his hips underwater, Jack pulled down his briefs and let his eight-inch cock spring free, relieved to be free of the tight underwear. He knew that he was above the average length and every girlfriend he'd been with had been more than satisfied with it. Across the tub, he saw Mike did the same, yanking down his underwear to free his own erection, probably for the first time in front of anyone other than himself.

Both boys sat in the bubbling steamy water and looked expectantly to Candy, waiting for her soft hands to find them under the water and then give her judgement.

************************************************

Reader's Choice!

Looks like Mike and a Tie tied for first, leaving poor Jack a distant third. I'll pick one of the winners and post the next chapter soon!