Mary

I barely lasted fifty seconds after removing my cock from Katie’s mouth, making a full circuit before returning to Mary and spewing jets of my sticky cum across her face. She held her mouth open wide, her green eyes wide with shock as her face grew slick of white streams of semen.

“Very nice, Mary,” I grinned, snapping a photo of the cum-covered girl. This would make excellent **** material. The girl had been a prude since she had transferred to my old high school during my senior year.

The brunette whimpered as her friends crowded close, licking the ejaculate from her face, leaving her cheeks and lips slick with saliva as they finished.

“Now, who would you like to spank?” I rewarded her with the prize.

“Katie,” the green-eyed girl crowed vehemently, pointing at the tallest of the four. “She dragged me along. I didn’t want to come.”

“Okay, Katie,” I looked down into her round, hazel eyes, her lower lip trembling. “I really should let Mary spank you and keep my promise, but I am awfully tempted to give you a second chance.”

“What?” she glanced at her friend nervously.

“Get my cock all nice and hard again,” I offered the dark-haired girl, “And I’ll fuck Mary up the ass.”

“No!” the young woman cried out. “Please, not my ass! You’ll hurt my with that fat dick of yours!”

“Thank you,” I glared at her, reducing her to defiance to whimpers, and returned my attention to Katie. “Now, I was saying, if you get my cock hard again, I’ll fuck Mary up the ass. However, you would have thirty seconds to do so. If I’m not hard in that time, your nice friend is going to spank you and then I’m going to fuck you up the ass.”

The green-eyed girl grinned triumphantly.

“So what’s it going to be, Katie?”