Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 16 by 321iamtheone 321iamtheone

Who does she pick?

Marla

"Marla", Lydia says, her hand playing with Johns hair, "Truth or dare."
Marla smiles. "Finally...I´ll pick dare."
Lydia thinks for a moment. "I´ve seen all of the present with lesser to no clothes already, except for Athena. Marla, why dont you help Athena get rid of two pieces of her clothes."
Marla stands up. "Happily"
A couple of moments later, Athena is stripped down to underwear. Marla made her get rid of her pants and top, and all she wears now is her dark pink lingerie, pushing up her pretty large breastts and hiding just enough of her pussy.
For a couple of seconds all of you, except John, his head still buried between his girlfriends legs, take in Athena. "Wow", Marla says, "I´m a bit jealous."
"What are you talking about? You´re gorgeous!" Athena says, shaking her head.
Then she sits back down next to you. "Alright...your turn Marla."

The next couple of rounds nothing extraordinary happens. Marla looses her shirt, Hailey, to no ones surprise, admits she likes to be submissive, and Emily is **** to give a long explanation of each and everyone of her sex toys she hides in the box under her bed. Haileys bodycount is 2, Marlas 12 and Lydias 15, although You decide to count every interaction between two people with the intend of at least one of them having an orgasm, as a body, and not just sex.

Its around 3 am when Marla says: "I´m hungry. You think we can order some food? Pizza or something?"
"Sure", Lydia says, and shortly after, You order a big pizza. Then Marla, whos turn it is, turns towards you. "Truth or dare?"
"Dare", you say, confident. What else can you loose now.
"Alright. I dare you to tease Emilys pussy..without taking off her pants."
Surprised you agree, and make your way over to Emily, who looks kind of...nervous?
She wears a white shirt and blue jeans shorts.
You sit down nex to her, and begin your work. Your hands glide up and down her thighs, sometimes around herperky breasts. her nipples, which show through her shirt, get some attention from you as well. Your hand rubs against the fabric of Emilys trousers right above her pussy and she bites her lips. The others enjoy the show and Marla smiles satisfied, which Emily noices. "Fuck you Marla", she says, although its more of a moan. Then she sets her eyes on Hailey.
"Truth or dare?"
Hailey smiles. "I´m feeling brave again. Dare"
Emily laughs. "Alright, if you´re so brave, how about you...flash the delivery man when the pizza arrives.
Hailey blushes. "Wait, I-". Then she seems to change her mind. "Alright, why not, I got this."

During all this, John never stopped his work and Lydia finally seems to come close to her orgasm. "Fuck...keep going." She says to John and Athena surpresses a smile. "Fuck off Athena" Lydia says, and Athna blows her a kiss. Then Lydia closes her eyes. "Oh god...yes..took you long enough...keep going...yes...I.."
And right before she cums, she locks eyes with you. Your hand is still on Emilys trousers, but you keep eye contact with Lydia. And although she cums through John work, her legs cramped around his head, you have the feeling shes really cumming for you.

For a brief moment, all of you just sit there, watching the two, and the scene you just witnessed. Then Lydia pushes John away with her feet, and adresses the group while putting her panties back on. "Shows over, I hope you enjoyed."
Then the door rings.
Hailey blushes, but under all of your eye, she gets up, and leaves the living room. For a second you hesitate, then the whole group follows her into the hallway. From this point of view you could see Hailey, but whoever was standing on the other side of the door isnt able to see you.

Hailey looks over to all of you, flips you off, and gets rid of her shirt, under which, she is naked. You cant see her tits from our point of you, they are barely covered through perspective.
Then Hailey opens the door.
"Hey, yeah, sorry, I just left the shower."
You cant hear what the other person is saying, but you know that it cant seem credible at 3 am, after having ordered an extra large pizza.

Hailey quickly settles business, you can hear her say."Thank you, have a nice evening as well." Then she closes the door. She takes her time, taking her shirt, and putting it back on, but you see her hands shaking from exitement. then she turns towards you. As she comes closer, you see her nipples through her shirt, she clearly liked the experience.

"And?", Emily asks, as you make your way back to the living room. "How was it?"
"Actually kind of hot. I got so wet when I opened the door. The guy was about our age, and I guess average looking, but my god did he stare. Asked if i needed anything else." She giggles, blushing. "It was so humiliating, but it felt better then I thought."
She looks around. "What?"
You think to yourself how cute Hailey acts when slightly embaressd, but you just say: "Nothing. Lets eat."

What happens next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)