Marc gives up Mindy, sort of.

"Oh my god... oh my god..." Marc muttered as he became intoxicated by the view of the slender swimmer hovering naked over his aching cock. His face was red and his breathing was erratic. He was completely lost in Amber's allure. "Alright... alright! It was your mom! She told me where to find you and what you were up to! Shit Amber, just put it in... I'm ready to explode!"

Amber's face lit up, then crinkled into a seething rage. "Alice..." she said conspiratorially. "Of course she'd want to get me into trouble..." The girl dropped back into the pool and turned to the others. "We need to think of a way to get payback..."

Mindy stood dumbfounded. She was sure Marc was going to rat her out after the performance Amber was giving him, but he had the wherewithal to point the blame elsewhere. Or did he? Mindy tried to remember her encounter with him earlier when he was delivering the pizza. She hadn't mentioned her own name and he must have assumed since she answered the door, she must have lived there... He must have mistaken her for Amber's mom!

"Hey... wait! You said you'd fuck me!" Marc protested as the other girls left him to float.

"I lied," Amber scoffed. Then she rubbed her chin, "But we DO need to punish you for peeping on us..."

"Come on... my balls are turning blue... someone just suck me off..." Marc complained.

"Oh," Jessi exclaimed as her eyes brightened, "I just had an idea!"

The girls looked to the platinum blond, she looked back at them with a mischievous grin, "Pin the tail on the donkey?"

"Oh yeah..." Amber murmured with the same naughty tone.

They retrieved the boy from the water and as he continued to complain, Kaitlyn duct taped his mouth shut. They later secured him to the pool house wall.

"Hey, maid," Amber called out to Mindy, "Come help us with this."

Mindy approached the group and Marc immediately recognized her. Mindy was thankful he was now gagged. She tried to play it cool and ignore his agitation toward her presence.

"What's the matter, Marc? Don't like the company?" Amber sneered, "I don't blame you, she's just hired help, not like us glamour girls."

Mindy knew well enough to keep quiet and let the birthday girl do all the talking. Anything she said would either raise suspicion or anger Marc further.

"Anyways, the object for OUR version of 'pin the tail on the donkey' is to hang one of these rings on this guy's cock," Amber explains, holding a weighted ring that is used to practice swimming to the bottom of a pool and retrieving. She hangs it on Marc's straight cock and it pulls down to Marc's chagrin. "Your job is to keep that thing stiff."

So Mindy ended up with fluffer duty as the girls went to get blindfolds for the game.