Lisa wants it in her ass

"John, I want you to fuck my ass." You remember from your game of "I Never" that Lisa has never had anal sex.

"Wow, are you sure, Lisa? I mean, I'm definitely up for it, but I know you've never done it before, and you know I haven't either, so I don't know if I'll be doing it right..." You're still slowly pumping in and out of Lisa's pussy.

"Yes. Amy says it's awesome, and there's nobody I'd rather do it with for my first time."

Amy slides out from underneath Lisa and says, "Wait, you guys are going to want to be lubed up some." Before you can say you have some vasoline in the bathroom, Amy hops off the bed, pushes you away from Lisa, and devours your cock, covering it with her saliva. She uses one hand to play with your balls, and the other alternates between her wet mouth and Lisa's ass.

"Wow, Amy, you're so helpful." You finger Lisa's pussy with one hand, and grab Amy's head with the other, not so much forcing her to bob her head, but simply enjoying the softness of her hair on your hand.

Finally, Amy stops sucking and pulls your cock to Lisa's now wet asshole. She puts the head of your cock against the hole, and you slowly start to penetrate Lisa. Amy stands up and gets behind you, then pushes you hard, forcing you deep into Lisa, who squeals. You stop moving and say, "Shit, sorry, it was Amy," but Lisa reaches back and grabs your waist, pulling you all the way in.

"Oh my fucking God, John. Oh my fucking God, fuck, fuck me, that's so good." You take the hint and begin to fuck her, still slowly, and she lets go of your waist and braces herself against the wall, arching her back in an amazingly sexy way. Amy moves from behind you and gets back on the bed, once again sliding underneath Lisa, but this time leaning her back against the wall. They kiss quickly, then Lisa backs up and runs her tongue down Amy's tummy to her shaved pussy. She plunges her tongue into Amy's cunt, and Amy's body tenses up as a wave of ecstasy flows over her face, and she sighs loudly.

You start to pump faster into Lisa's ass, and you hear a muffled voice from her mouth (obscured by Amy's pussy) say, "Grab my tits." You do as commanded, squeezing her breasts as they bounce heavily with your thrusts. Amy grabs one of Lisa's hands and pulls it to her own breast, and Lisa softly massages Amy's tit while eating her out. Amy grabs Lisa's head and pulls it deep into her crotch, moaning in delight as Lisa's tongue explores Amy's pussy. Amy's eyes catch yours, and you see a lust in them like you've never seen before. She releases Lisa's head and pushes her nipple to her own mouth, flicking it with her tongue, keeping her seductive eyes locked on you.

Suddenly, you hear Lisa say loudly, "Fuck, I'm gonna cum! Fuck!" You feel her entire body tense up, and then convulse, clenching her already tight ass around your cock. You slide out of her ass quickly and drop to your knees, pushing your mouth against Lisa's shaking cunt. (You love the taste of pussy). You tongue and suck on her cunt as she twitches, licking her oozing juice. "Oh my God, John. I've never cum so hard. I want it again."

Amy speaks up. "Hold on a second, what about me? I'm not getting left out of this."