Let her fuck someone else.

You don’t know whether it’s the confusing excitement from the last 12 hours, or the overwhelming sensation of your ass being stretched open, but for some reason, Olivia’s logic is making sense.

“Okay.” You say. The words slip out of your mouth so easily, it surprises you a bit.

“Really?” Olivia asks excitedly. It’s clear you’re not the only one surprised.

“Yeah sure, I guess. But can we do something about this thing in my ass?” You say, squirming your body in order to find a position that doesn’t drive you insane.

“Oh! Yeah.” Olivia exclaims. She fights the excitement from your easy acceptance long enough to place her hand under your ass, pressing a button on the base of the plug. You hear a hiss as air escapes the plug, a feeling of relief soon follows.

“I thought it was going to take more to convince you.” She says as she slowly removes the plug.

You let out a sigh of relief as the object leaves your ass, though you’re now left feeling stretched, sore, and empty.

“I guess you must really like your new toys.” Olivia says as she takes the plug into the bathroom. She’s back out only a moment later, holding a tube of some kind of ointment. She is soon next to you again.

“Head down ass up!” She says, patting the bed. You hesitate, not feeling ready to have something else shoved up your ass. “Don’t worry.” She says, sensing your hesitation. “This is just to help with the soreness.”

Though you're still a bit unsure, you do as you're told, moving slowly onto your front. You raise your ass up towards her. You hear the loud squirting as she pours some of the ointment onto her hand. You soon feel a cold sensation as she begins to rub it around the entrance of your asshole.

Suddenly you hear a buzzing sound. You tense up, fearing it’s another one of your toys, but you soon realize it’s Olivia’s phone. She answers it with one hand while continuing to apply the ointment.

“Hey you!” She says into the phone. She sounds excited and flirty, a voice you only heard during your early stages of dating.

“I was just about to call you.” She inserts two of her fingers into you, rubbing the ointment around. it’s cool and numbing. You’d feel more relaxed if you weren’t also trying to focus on her conversation.

“We got the green light!” Her fingers move in deeper.

“I know, right!? He’s fine with it.” This is the point where the second thoughts kick in, but those thoughts are quickly distracted as she inserts another finger.

“How about tonight?” She begins sliding her fingers in and out, the numbness causes you to almost miss her sliding another finger in.

“I can’t wait.” her increased pace makes you think she’s trying to do more than apply ointment.

“I’m going to wear something sexy for you, but don’t worry, it’ll be easy to remove.” You’re about to say something when you suddenly feel her whole hand go into you.

“I hope you’re not too big for me.” she pushes her hand deeper inside of you. Your concern over her phone call is surpassed by the concern over the fact that her hand slid in with ease, but with the numbness limiting the pain, you find yourself enjoying being filled again.

“Well we’ll find out, wont we?” Her hand begins moving more rhythmically now. Before you know it your letting out a moan. Olivia’s hand suddenly pauses.

“Well, I have to go, I’ll see you tonight.” She hangs up the phone and gently removes her hand.

“Sorry.” She says to you. “I got a little excited.” She lightly pats you on the ass. “Tonight’s going to be so much fun.”

You begin to stretch out, bringing your ass down as you fully flop onto the bed. You once again feel empty, you’re beginning to not like that feeling.

“Well, I should probably get ready.” Olivia says standing back up. “You might want to get ready too.”