Let Katy decide

"So I recall someone saying they would pop my anal cherry. Think you can handle it?" Katy says with a childish grin. Your heart begins to beat faster and faster. You manage to spit out "Uhh yeah, of course." She presses her chest against the shower door and turns her head around "Just remember it is my first time so go slow, OK?" Katy turns around, and sticks her gorgeous ass out towards you. Your hands tremble as you grip Katy's hips and begin to guide your cock towards her asshole. "Ok" you sigh "here I come." With that you begin to apply pressure with you dick against her hole. You feel the helmet slowly to squeeze in and think to yourself "God she's tight."

Katy begins to moan audibly "Oh yeah, ugh, that's great keep going". The shaft of your penis begins to slide past her sphincter. You don't think you have ever fucked a hole as tight as this. Finally, your dick is all the way inside Katy and you take a deep breath. You begin to rock your hips and Katy's moans turn to screams of extacy as you begin to fuck her asshole. Katy tits are pressed up against the shower door as you increase your pace. Katy then reachs in between her legs and begins to massage your balls as you fuck her.

"Oh shit, I'm going to cum soon."