Kim

Maria beats Kim, Terry has the highest male hand.

"You left me hanging, Terry!" Kim said as she unsteadily walked over to Terry and almost fell on him. Her tits landed in Terry's hands and he took full advantage squeezing them as he helped her into his lap. "Now, you need to finish what you started!" She was so horny, she just needed him inside her NOW! She grabbed his hard cock and impaled herself on it. The sharp pain of her hymen being torn caused her to gasp. Also, his cock felt like it was tearing her in half!

Terry couldn't believe that Kim did that. He was balls deep in this tight, wet, virgin pussy and in felt amazing! If he hadn't cum recently he would have unloaded in her right away.

It took Terry a few moments to realize Kim was in pain. When he did, he held her close and stroked her hair. "It's okay. Just relax," Terry said reassuringly. She looked down at him and gave him a surprising kiss. As he kissed her back, his hands started to explore her body. From her back to her ass and then finally onto her large tits. This caused her to gasp and break off the kiss. He then started sucking on her nipples making her moan in pleasure.

"Hey you two," Jen said impatiently. "You're supposed to be fucking, not making out."

"Oh, right," Kim said as she blushed. Terry put his hands on her hips to steady her and she slowly started to move up and down on his cock while keeping her breasts in his face. "Oh God, this feels really good. Your big cock is deep inside me and I love it!" As much as Terry wanted to thrust up inside her, he let her control things. Kim started to move faster and before long she was bouncing on Terry's cock. "Oh fuck! Oh fuck! I'm gonna cum!"

"Cum on my cock, Kim!" Then, she took him balls deep once more, arched her back, and came loudly.

"That...was...amazing!"

"Oh, we're not done yet. Get up and bend over the arm of the couch." Kim unsteadily stood up and did as she was told. Terry got behind her and couldn't help but check out her ass. Having experienced anal sex with Tonya, he really wanted to give it a try with Kim. On the other hand, he knew this dare was for her pussy and she might not appreciate it if he took her ass without permission. He could always fuck her ass later if he wins.

Terry slid his cock balls deep inside of Kim's tight pussy. "Oooh yes, fuck me some more!" Terry didn't hold back as he fucked her from behind fast and hard. He knew he wouldn't last much longer and suspected this might be his last loud of the night so he wanted to get his money's worth.

As for Kim, she was loving the rough fucking Terry was giving her. She even loved when Terry squeezed her tits. And she felt another orgasm approaching.

"Kim! I'm gonna cum inside you!"

"Yes! I'm cumming!" Terry thrust balls deep and shot his loud as Kim had a powerful orgasm of her own. This was different than cumming inside of Tonya's ass. It felt like Kim's pussy was literally sucking the cum out of his cock.

When Terry pulled his now soft cock out of Kim's pussy, Kim just laid there on the arm of the couch with Terry's cum dripping out of her. Her lust sated, she could finally consider what she had done. She had willingly given her virginity away not to her crush Josh but to Terry. Terry who had comforted her when she foolishly took his big cock in one go and had let her set the pace until she was used to it. Then, he fucked the shit out of her and she loved it. If she won, she might pick him after all.