Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 12 by Thisisabadidea Thisisabadidea

The last present

Katie and some pictures

You sleep deep and long Saturday morning. You were exhausted after the amazing events of Friday night and Saturday morning. You wake up in your bed, on your back, wearing only your boxer shorts. You’ve somehow got a massive morning erection, despite recent events. Katie is nowhere to be seen, but you hear her in the kitchen, clattering plates muttering softly to herself. Your phone buzzes with a notification, you roll to check it. You see many text notifications from numbers you don’t recognize, mostly just wishing you a happy birthday, one notification from Katie and one from Nikki. You grin thinking about last nights events with Nikki and open your phone. You open Katie’s message first.

It’s a picture of Katie in nothing but her kitchen apron with the message attached, “I’m making you breakfast in bed, don’t check your other messages yet.”

You smile, taking in the picture of Katie’s athletic body and side boob in the apron. You move to put your phone down when a second message from Nikki pops up. You open it.

“Got home safe!” the message reads, “Can’t quite sit down from what you did to me. Cleaned up a bit though.” You scroll Nikki’s messages. There’s a picture of her face before she cleaned up. Her makeup is streaked and you can see remnants of your cum on her cheeks and nose. Then there’s an after shot of her naked from the waist up, her makeup and cum streaks have been washed up, she’s pointing to where the mess was while flexing her small arm. You shift a little uncomfortably thinking about her knowing your weird fetish. There’s one last message from her. “Flexing for you baby. Remember what happened.” It’s a picture of just her thin arm, flexing as hard as she can, her tiny muscles bulging and showing her tattoos.

“I hate that you know my secret. Keep it to yourself.” You text her back. “:P” is her reply.

You put your phone down and stretch, trying to tame your morning wood. Nothing is helping, least of all Nikki messing with you. Katie comes into your room carrying the breakfast tray and sets it down over your lap.

“Good morning baby!” Katie laughs, slowly twirling in the apron, showing her naked ass and back. “I made your favorite. Dig in.”

You dig into the bacon, eggs and pancakes your beautiful, newly wild girlfriend made for you. She pulls the string on her apron and slides into bed with you, completely naked, her soft small hand teasing your morning wood.

“I watched you last night.” Katie says, keeping firm eye contact with you, “when Nikki was jerking you off. You have a fetish don’t you?”

You know she’s caught you. “Maybe a little.” You admit. You keep eating and have nearly polished it all off you were so hungry.

“More than a little.” Katie laughs, giving your shaft a squeeze, “it’s okay, I have a few too. I just wonder if you like mine too. But your last present is similar. It’s in two parts. Open your phone.”

Katie hands you your phone. You open it, and notice an album on your home screen. You look at Katie and she nods. You tap the album and it opens. You see almost a hundred pictures, from the night before. Nikki’s back as she’s riding your cock, obviously take by Katie while she rimmed you out. Nikki from behind as Katie pounded her ass. Nikki looking up while eating out Katie, you don’t remember this happening. Katie giggles.

“Some you’ll remember, some were from when you were asleep.” Katie laughs.

You keep scrolling the pics. Nikki looking up between Katie’s legs while licking her ass. The same pic of Katie licking Nikki. Katie’s fingers white while squeezing Nikki’s nipples. You keep scrolling, it’s a hot play by play of everything that happened.

“So we can use them later.” Katie says with a wink, lazily stroking your hard cock. “There’s quite a few from the hand job. So you won’t forget.”

You scroll into the handjob pics. Staring at your hard cock in Nikki’s small hands stroking your thick dick. Her tiny tits caught mid bounce. If you scroll fast enough it’s almost animated. Nikki’s arm tensed and relaxed as she made full length strokes. You scroll quickly to the end of the handjob and watch as streaks of cum appear on the Nikki in the pictures.

“This is amazing Katie.” you smile at her, “best birthday ever!”

Katie grins and kisses you passionately, still lasting stroking you. “There’s just a little bit more.” she says, her voice still smoky.

“How can there be more? You’ve done too much.” You say, smiling at your amazing girlfriend.

“This morning I signed up for lots of upper body classes at my gym.” Katie says with a wink, “So that’ll be a slow present for you. You can watch my arms grow. For your fetish.”

“You don’t have to do that.” you begin, “it’s weird.”

“But you like it. And it’s for my health.” Katie adds, laughing slightly. She’s still lazily jerking your morning wood. “Nikki signed up too.”

“Fuck.” you sigh, “it’s my personal private thing.”

“Not personal anymore.” Katie laughs, “The last thing is I texted all my gym friends last night. Asked them to flex and show off a bit.”

You swallow. “What?” you ask quietly.

“I asked them to flex, and send the pictures to you. Show off their fitness for your fit fetish. I asked a few different types, I didn’t know what fitness was your favorite.” Katie finishes, swallowing hard, “You can scroll the pictures and message with them if you want, while I give you the slowest teasing hand job of your life.”

You take a second to process this. “When did you decide this? Why did you decide this?!”

Katie smiles, “This morning. I’m a wild woman now. But still a good dutiful girlfriend. This way the best orgasm of your weekend comes from me and things that I did. Not Nikki.”

“But the pictures?” you start to protest, Katie cuts you off by squeezing your dick.

“They took the pictures because I asked them to. This is all for you, from me.” Katie giggles and leans in and lightly kisses your tip before resuming lazily jerking you. “Check some of the pics baby. You can text dirty with them and ask them for more if you want too.”

You realize you’ve lost this fight, not even sure why you were fighting so hard to begin with. Katie is slowly and lightly jerking you, hardly touching you. You open your phone and look at your messages. There are at 5 from numbers your don’t recognize. You shake your head, this can’t be real. You send a message to Nikki, “Did Katie text you?” Nikki’s response is almost instant, a pic of her flexing both her arms from the back, her tattoos showing in screaming color, “No. :p”

“Is this really happening?” you ask Katie.

“Sure is. Enjoy it.” she says, slowly tracing her fingers down the underside of your shaft, “Remember who did it for you.”

Katie kisses you gently and then nods toward your phone. You open the first message from a number you don’t know. “Hi. I’m Lora. I’m a gym bunny. Look at my shredded body.” The picture is a skinny, tanned, brunette with the sides of her head shaved, looking over her shoulder at the camera, flexing her triceps and grinning. Every muscle in her skinny body is well defined. Katie jerks you slowly. You message Lora, “fuck those are nice. Love to see more.” The next pic is quick to arrive. Lora has taken off her sports bra and is kneeling in front of the mirror, her arms and back are flexed hard. “If Katie ever offers another threesome.” You text Lora. “I hope so.” She responds, the picture of her arm in front of her naked chest, “I’ll slurp your fucking ass.” Is her message.

Katie smiles and looks at your screen, “I figured you’d like Lora.” She kisses you again, still teasing your dick with slow strokes. “I think Karuna is next.”

You open the next message. “Hi. I’m Karuna! And this is naughty!” The picture is a smiling Indian American woman wearing impossibly short shorts and a sports bra. Her thighs are thick and muscular, her stomach a flat 6 pack, and her arms defined and flexed at the camera. “I have a fantasy about super fit girls like you.” you send. “Oh what’s that?” Karuna quickly responds, Katie must have told them to be ready. “Finishing onto a six pack. ;)” you admit to Karuna. The next pic arrives seconds later; Karuna is on her back, camera held up in the air, her six pack flexed and her arm mimicking jerking movements over her flat muscular tummy. “Like this?” she asks. “Yes! Fuck.” You send. Karuna sends a smiley face and another shot of her flexed abs and arm. “Anytime you want!” she sends.

“I figured you’d like Karuna. But not her abs so much.” Katie giggles, “I’m gonna have to hit the gym.”

“Katie! Nothing like that!” You protest

“No. Enjoy your fantasy baby. But focus on my hand.” she giggles while picking up her stroking pace a bit. “Keep going. Text dirty with my friends while I stroke your hard cock baby.”

You open the third message. “I’m Jillian, I do lots of yoga.” Says the message, accompanying a picture of a blonde with angular features and a smile on her face. She’s incredibly thin, completely naked and very flexible. In the photo her ankles are clearly behind her head, and her arms are stretched up as well. “So you’re good at positions? ;)” you send Jillian. “There is no position I can’t do.” she texts back. In the next picture she’s in the same position but her whole body is visible, her skinny legs are on the floor, her ankles above her head, her long thin arms are stretched above her head, her nonexistent tits have incredibly hard nipples. “I love it!” You send her. “I’m also a filthy flexi slut. If Katie ever offers, I’ll show you how flexible I really am. I swallow too.” Jillian responds. Her next pic is of her open mouth with her tongue sticking out. You groan and wiggle as Katie picks up a little speed and tightens her grip a bit.

“Jillian? she asks, “she’s filthy. She loves bending into those poses and getting fucked.”

“She offered to swallow.” you tell Katie, laughing.

“Filthy slut.” Katie laughs as well. “Don’t pick your favorite yet.”

You open the next message. “Hi. I’m Lauren. Im strong, but have a submissive streak.” says the message. Attached is a picture of a thick freckled redhead, covered in tattoos, even more than Nikki. She’s posing, showing off her thick thighs in her short shorts, and her flat stomach, large tits and thickly muscled arms in her tight white tank top. “I like submissive. :p” you message her. The next pic is the muscular redhead hands behind her head, her mouth filled with a big red ball gag, her eyes open wide and pleading. “One of the best ways to shut me up. ;)” is her message. “I’ve got a better one.” you respond. Her next pic arrives quickly, she’s topless, her huge freckled, tattooed tits resting heavily on her chest, one of her hands wrapped around her neck, “Don’t fucking tease me daddy. Own me. ;)” says her message.

“That slut.” Katie laughs, picking up the pace, and tickling under your balls, “There’s still one more baby.”

You moan and open the last message. Katie has been slowly teasing you and driving you insane. You read the message “Hi. I’m Bianca. I’m small and I like it rough! Really rough.” the photo attached is a short Asian woman, very short, very fit, her solidly muscled body completely naked, her heart shaped ass in full view. “I like rough too. You’re built for it.” You respond to her. Katie ups her speed a little as you wait for more from Bianca. “I bet you do. :p Break me!” she texts. The second pic is Bianca on her knees, face down and toned ass up, solidly muscled thighs holding that toned ass in the air. “Fuck what I’d do to you.” you send her. “You can do anything. **** me. Slap me. Punch me. The rougher the better. Don’t be gentle.” Bianca writes. Her next pic arrives and it’s of her naked front, her face in an O position and her hand open, having clearly slapped herself in the face.

“Fuck.” you moan as Katie picks up her speed and tightness even more.

“Roughness too?” she asks giggling, “I didn’t see that coming either. Bianca loves get slapped and choked. Wanna use her baby? Beat her up a bit and use her fit little body?” Katie punctuates her question by squeezing your dick and pumping a few times.

“Or do you want to **** Lauren while she cums? Watch her heavy freckled tits bounce? Shoot your load on her face?” Katie slows down and pumps firmly now, “Or bend Jillian into a pretzel and pound her sloppy slit? Maybe tie her up in a contortionist position and rail her, make her drink your load?”

You groan and wiggle, trying to get Katie to keep jerking you. She slows almost to a stop now.

“Or, do you want to shoot that thick load on Karuna’s sexy abs? Fully realize your fitness fetish baby. Paint her mocha skin white?” Katie slowly says, her wild woman voice in full power, “Or do you want shredded Lora to jerk you off with her ripped arm? Or what was it she said? ‘Slurp your asshole’?”

“Because,” Katie begins her words painfully slow as she jerks your tortured cock just as slowly, “and this is my last present baby, they’re all downstairs. Waiting and ready. Pick your favorite. I’ll get your big fucking dick ready for whatever she offered. It’s my last present, the one I give you. Not your sultry cousin.”

You can’t think. There’s no way this can be real. But seeing Katie turn into this wild woman, you’re not sure she wouldn’t.

“Yes. I’m serious.” Katie says slowly, “you’re almost ready. Which of my hot friends do you want baby? Shredded Lora? Karuna with the abs? Filthy flexible Jillian? Strong submissive Lauren? Or rough bunny Bianca?”

“I want...” you begin.

Who do you want to fulfill your fitness fetish?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)