Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 12 by Thisisabadidea Thisisabadidea

Good question. What do you want now?

It’s your birthday

“It’s my birthday.” you laugh, “I’d really like to lay back and let you do all the work.”

Katie giggles, “I have an idea. What about those videos you always watch where three woman use their mouths. You know one licks ass, one sucks balls and the other sucks the dick? Your favorite ones. We happen to have three mouths here!”

“Fortunately.” you laugh and wiggle a bit, Karen slowly pulls away and winks at you again. “The couch might be too crowded. Let’s take our girlfriends to bed Katie.”

“Yes please!” Ali squeaks from beneath Katie. Karen stands up and slowly turns around sticking her beautifully toned fit ass out at you, the red thong disappearing between her firm ass cheeks. She looks back over her shoulder and grins and winks. Her ripped arms bend and she hooks her thumbs in the waist band and shimmies the thong down and off, now everyone is completely naked, Katie having ripped her lingerie off to allow Ali access to her slit.

“Lead the way stud.” Karen giggles as she turns to show you the waxed smooth mound between her legs, her abs are engaged and it makes your cock twitch a bit. You stand and take Karen by the hand, Katie helps Ali up. You lead the group slowly up the stairs, looking back over your shoulder to watch Ali limp and sway on her feet, her big legs struggling to keep her upright. Karen sees this too and bites her lip. She whispers to you as you reach the top of the stairs, “I want you to do that to me some day. Fuck me so hard I can walk.”

“Any time.” you respond.

You and Karen arrive to the bedroom first, you turn on low lights to see the fit milf for the first time. Her messy blonde hair is loose and falls to her shoulders, her stern features make the look of lust on her pretty face even more alluring. Her defined shoulders and arms top her big very well done fake tits, the tits defy gravity, almost alarmingly perky for a 40-something. Her defined six pack leads down to the completely waxed mound, the ridges and contours of the muscles strikingly sexy and in great contrast to chubby little Ali and even athletic Katie. Karen’s sleek smooth thighs are thick with toned muscle and very long, the fit milf is probably 5’10” or so, a little taller than Katie and towering over Ali. Her calves are just as toned and sleek. She does a slow spin to show you her beautiful peach of an ass and defined back before locking eyes with you and biting her lip.

Katie and Ali arrive seconds after Karen’s show finishes. This really is the best birthday imaginable. Katie’s brown hair is tied in a messy ponytail, obviously from part of her romp with Karen. Her cute thin face has a look of pride and lust plastered all over it. Her narrow shoulders hold up her pert B cup breasts and long lean arms. Her small dark nipples are hard and erect. Her fit but soft stomach leads down to her trimmed landing strip above her dripping lips. She stands lightly swaying on her long lean legs. Sleek and smooth like Karen’s but much less bulky and toned. But still incredible. She smiles at you and spins like Karen did, showing off her small bum and smooth back. She winks as she finishes. She and Karen slowly climb on the bed and help you to lay down. Leaving little Ali swaying on her feet at the foot of the bed.

Ali for her part still looks amazing. Her dark hair is falling out of the pony tail she made earlier. Her round cute face has a look of complete bliss on it, but her green eyes shine with lust. Her mind is replaying being held under you and getting pounded, and Katie writhing on top of her. Her rounded shoulders hold up her flushed pale tits. Her ghostly pale nipples are incredibly hard in her aroused state. Her thick chubby arms slowly run up her sides around her soft thick belly, the pale mound heaving as she breathes deeply. Her wide round hips frame her trimmed but not shaped mound and her lips are glistening and practically dripping. Her thick wide thighs tremble as she sways lightly on her feet, her chubby legs leading down to thick calves and strong ankles above her feet. She smiles and starts to slowly and unsteadily spin around. As she spins her big chubby ass into view her big legs jiggle. She reaches her chunky arms behind her to pat and jiggle her ass. Her smooth thick back works as she hefts her big cheeks and drops them, her whole body jiggling. She finishes her show and slowly walks toward the bed and gingerly sits down on the edge.

“Lay back baby and let us go to work.” Katie coos before kissing you firmly, her lips taste like Ali’s delicious chubby pussy. She helps you settle back into the pillows, “Let’s give the birthday boy another present ladies.”

You chuckle at the absurdity of the whole evening. It’s progressed from harmless flirting to this. Two new girlfriends and living out a porn video fantasy. You start to wonder if this is all a dream. If it’s a dream it’s a good one, you think to yourself, and you intend to enjoy it. You’re snapped out of your trance as ripped Karen crawls between your legs and helps you to open them. She kisses the tip of your cock and slides her tongue down the underneath side, swirling it over your balls before lowering herself to ass level, her fit body extending out behind her, her firm ass up in the air. She winks and breathes on your ass.

“Happy birthday stud.” she whispers into your ass, “Enjoy it. I know I will. I submit to your ass! I love licking it!”

The fit milf dives in and stars licking and sucking your ass, not caring how sloppy it makes her face. She’s practically fucking you with her tongue, her fit body swaying as she licks and sucks. You moan and wiggle and your head rolls back. You catch sight of Ali slowly crawling toward you. The chubby pale woman trails her hands up your legs and gently teases your tip with her soft hands. She positions herself off to one side on her hands and knees. Her chubby arms and thick thighs shake as she lowers herself and plants a kiss on your soft hot balls.

“I hope I was a good present.” Ali whispers to your balls, “It was incredible to be used like that. Now I’ll suck these balls like they’re you big dick.”

Ali pulls your balls into her mouth and kneads them with her tongue. Your hot twitching balls disappear into her red lipped mouth and she begins to bob and twist like she’s sucking your dick. The difference being she can get your balls all into her mouth. Her green eyes roll back in her head as she again relives everything you did to her this evening, her thighs rub together as she visualizes you on top of her, holding her down until her came.

“Am I the best girlfriend ever?” Katie asks, snapping you out of a similar replay as Ali.

“You are.” you moan, “this is the best present ever!”

“Not done yet.” she giggles and climbs on top of you, lowering her beautiful trimmed slit into your face. She speaks to your cock like it’s a microphone as she lowers her head toward your cock, “I’m gonna suck you off. Like the girls in the video.”

You grunt as Katie takes your tip into her mouth. She swirls her tongue as she invades her own mouth with your cock, her lips grasping and reaching toward the base. Katie pulls out all her tricks. Sucking and twisting in the way she knows drives you crazy, her elegantly manicured hands stroking you when she’s not completely surrounding you with her mouth. You moan and wiggle, the sensations from all three mouths driving you crazy. Karen slurping and licking and probing with her tongue. Her tongue is as strong and dexterous as the rest of her ripped body, you wonder if she exercises it as well. Ali is licking and sucking your balls like it’s all she ever wanted. The chubby pale woman is rubbing her big thick legs together to stimulate herself as well. Her green eyes rolled back in her head. She’s trying to give you the sensation that will cause you to erupt, but she’s beyond happy to be part of this . Katie is sucking you like she never has before. You’re not sure if this is from her experiments with Karen or if she’s just so wound up. You decide to repay your girlfriend and tentatively reach out with your tongue and graze her dripping slit. Katie wiggles her hips and moans around your cock, the vibrations are yet another pleasant sensation on your overly sensitive member. Katie pulls up with a *pop* and strokes you lazily as you explore her lips with your tongue.

“It’s your birthday and you’re still doing that?” she breathes, “You’re amazing. Ladies, let’s get him off.”

At Katie’s words the other two women seem to get second winds. They each change up their technique and speed. Karen has slowed way down, giving firm long licks all the way to the bottom of your balls. You imagine from her quiet moans one of her fit arms has planted a hand between her muscular thighs to fiddle herself. Your hot twitching balls disappear into Ali’s mouth as she’s tonguing them furiously and sucking hard, the pulling sensation feeling a bit off but nice, especially combined with the jolts of pleasure that spread into your body from Karen’s tongue. Katie herself has pushed you as far into her throat as she can. Her eyes bulging and her neck full. Her breath comes in great gasps around your thick member. Her lips open to draw the breath and then tighten around the base. She’s never been able to do this before. Her gag reflex fires and she slowly slides all the way up before coughing and spitting on your dick so her slender hands can stroke while she catches her breath. You start to use the trick of writing words on her pearl to make it harder for her to catch that breath. You write “best girlfriend ever” on her clit with your tongue. You pay special attention to dotting the I, you know that’s the trigger. As you finish the word she tenses and her slit practically gushes on your face. You hear her gasp cut short by a loud throat gag as she pushes down even further through her climax. You hear and feel Ali start to whine around your balls, you can see one of her chubby arms furiously fingering her slit and she pulls hard on your balls and she too tenses and releases. Karen spears in and you look over Katie’s bobbing head to see her fit body wiggling and go tense in the same way, her gasp as she reaches her release is a cool wind on your ass. All these sensations combine to take you crashing over the edge. You release your second load of the night deep inside Katie’s throat. She coughs and chokes, some of your load spilling out of her mouth, and coming out her nose. Karen slowly pulls out from between your legs and leans up and sucks some of the load off Katie’s face. Ali pulls off your balls with a soft pop and reaches up with her cute face and does the same as Karen, clearing Katie’s face of your load. The chubby woman and the fit one then lean in and make out, sharing your load before their throats pulse and they’ve swallowed it. Katie rolls off you onto her back next to you, her head neat Ali’s big ass.

“You made me cum so easy baby. Words?” she asks breathlessly.

“Yeah. ‘Best girlfriend ever’” you tell her.

“First girlfriend.” Karen jokingly corrects her.

“Best girlfriend for now.” Ali laughs.

“Three girlfriends.” you chuckle.

You lay back and relax, closing your eyes. Katie crawls up next to you and does the same. Ali snuggles up behind Katie, pressing her chubby body against Katie’s athletic one. Karen cuddles in behind you, throwing her arm over you, gently teasing Katie’s chest.

“Best birthday ever.” you mumble before drifting off still hoping it wasn’t a dream.

Wake up?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)