Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 35 by reaper13 reaper13

Do I dare take the risk?

It’s not worth it

Like I did yesterday and the day before, I ignore my dick and say, “We can’t, it’s too risky. But if you really need something inside you, maybe this will help.”

I then bring one hand between Athena’s legs and slide two fingers inside her pussy.

“Oh!” Athena moans. “Oh, yes Kyle! Fuck me!”

While I am fingering my cousin, Athena brings a hand to my dick and starts jacking me off. This makes me think back to the time I was standing outside her room masturbating listening to her moans while she was masturbating. I was having a fantasy of actually masturbating her while she was masturbating me. This is it! My fantasy is becoming reality!

While Athena and I are masturbating each other, I bring my mouth back to her chest. I lick her nipples and suck on them. Since I don’t know the best method of sucking on a girl’s nipples for her pleasure, I simply suck on them as if I were trying to get milk out of them. There won’t be any, of course. Athena is not pregnant. I just hope I can help her to orgasm this way.

A short time later, Athena starts orgasming. Having a pretty girl like her squirm and scream in pleasure beneath me, because of me, pushes me over the edge and I cum as well. I start unloading my balls and my sperm squirts from my dick to land on Athena’s belly.

When I’m done cumming on my cousin’s belly, I let myself roll off her. As I am catching my breath, I see her scoop up my sperm with her fingers and bring them to her mouth. Like before, she licks her fingers clean of my sperm.

“Mmm, you taste so good, Kyle.” Athena moans.

I take a moment to pat her head and says, “Tomorrow, I’ll be going after some condoms. Then I will fill your pussy with some real meat.”

Athena smiles at me and says, “I’m looking forward to it.”

Then we both pull the covers over ourselves and fall asleep in herbed.

What is in store for me next morning?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)