If that's what she wants...

You are a little weary at her request, but you want to please her tonight, and if this is what she wants, this is what you'll give her. You give her a few more quick thrusts, then pull out slowly, her juices coating your cock. Melody groans softly at the loss of your erection inside her, but hums enticingly as your hands massage her ass cheeks gently. Not even your nymphomaniac girlfriend Gia allowed you in her ass, so this is new territory for you. You pray to God you don't hurt your best friend here.

You pull her ass cheeks apart slowly, revealing her puckered hole. The cool air hitting it causes Melody to gasp slightly. Not wanting to just intrude right in, you use the thumb of your left hand to massage the hold gently, rubbing light circles around it.

"Oooo." She coos at your touch. "I knew you'd be gentle with me."

"I try." You say weakly.

"But I need you now. I want you inside my...inside me." She says, her words still slightly nuffled by the pillow. "Go ahead. You won't hurt me. I promise."

"I..uh...okay." You say, wishing you sounded a bit more confident. You reposition yourself so the tip of your cock is at her asshole. Melody stickes her ass out as high as she can, keeping her face buried in the pillow. She takes a deep breath and wiggles her rear a bit, as if to intice you forward. You grip her hips and push forward. You are actually suprised how easily you slide into her, your moist and slick cock pushing into her ass easily.

"Oh, God!" Melody cries out. "Oh, yes! That feels wonderful!" You feel a little more bold now and push the rest of the way into her until your entire cock is deep in her ass and your balls hit against her pussy. "Aaaah!" She screams into the pillow, her hand tightly gripping the edges.

"Are you okay?" You ask quickly. Her ass is so much tighter than her pussy, you can hardly stand it. It's still as warm and moist, just so much tighter.

"Y-yes." She responds after a second. "Sorry...Keith is the only other guy I've let do this and you...you're quite a bit...I mean you have more..." You wish you could see her face as she is most likely blushing right now. "You're big." She finishes lamely.

"I'm not hurting you, am I?" You ask, returning to your earlier ego trip.

"No, no. Not at all. You feel amazing." She assures you. "Just give me a second to...adjust before you start fucking me."

You nod. "Okay." You're enjoying just being inside her, so it's alright for you. After a few moments, she speaks up.

"Y-you can move now."

"All right." You say and pull yourself out slowly before pushing back in.

"Ohmygod." Melody breaths out as one word. You like the way that sounded and go again. She moans deeply and her moans only get louder as you speed up your thrusts. It takes all of your willpower not to shoot your load right then and there inside her, she feels so good.

"Yes. Yes, yes yes." She whispers into the pillow, her body shaking from your movements. "Jack! You're driving me crazy!"

"You like that, huh?" You smile, pulling her hips back against your body.

"Yes!" She cries out. "Spank me, Jack!" You grin and give her ass cheeks a few playful slaps. She moans slightly. "No, no. Harder." You grin drops a bit and you slap her ass a little harder. "Harder!" She cries out. "Leave a red mark!"

You feel very awkward about this...something isn't quite right. But if this is what she wants...You lift your hand and hit her ass. Hard. It's sure to sting and leave a mark. "Ow! Oh, God! Again!" You felt bad enough the first time, but the second was worse. You give her what she asks for, but this time you feel like you're abusing her.

"Mmm!" She groans. "I am such a slut!"

"W-what?" You ask in surprise.

"I'm a complete slut. I'm your slut." She moans into the pillow. You slow down in surprise. "No! Don't stop!" She exclaims and you go back to fucking her ass. "Yes...say it. Say I'm your slut."

"Melody, I don't really feel comfortable..."

"Say it, please!" She exclaims.

"Okay! Okay! You're my slut."

"Like you mean it!" She yells back. You don't think you could ever really mean it, but give it a shot.

"You're my slut." You growl a little more intensely. You feel like a jackass, but keep going. "You're my personal little slut, aren't you?"

"Y-y-yes." She whimpers and you can suddenly tell Melody is now crying; she's sobbing right into her pillow. Dammit! You knew something was wrong!

"Melody?" You ask wearily, hoping this is part of her game.

"I'm sorry...I'm so sorry..." She sobs, burying her face deep into the pillow. You erection has fully died down, although your cock is still buried in her ass.