I'll play along

When I pause for just a second before plunging into my bound tenant, she smiles tentatively.

“I could help you, Sir.” Alison whispers earnestly, “I could help find the prettiest virgins on the campus. I could help you snatch them.” She bites her lower lip nervously and spreads her legs a little wider in a clear invitation. “You can even take me if you like, just don't send me to Gor.”

It's a damn good thing she doesn't plan of keeping my cock out of her pussy, because after this week, there is no chance of that happening. With a grunt of satisfaction I push hard into her slick passage and smile as she gasps in surprise and pleasure.

“You like this, huh?” I growl in her ear, “You like having your slutty little kitty filled by a real man.” She doesn't say anything, but judging by the way she is jerking against me each time I thrust into her I'm pretty sure I'm doing something right. “I hope you don't think you can play me.”

“No, Sir!” Alison is able gasp out between her moans, “I'll do it, I swear, but you have to promise to leave Mandy alone. OK?” Seeing as none of this is real anyways, it doesn't seem like too much of a sacrifice to make.

“Deal.” I pause long enough to meet her wild-eyed gaze, “But these girls you're going to get for me, they have to pretty.”

“They are, Mister, I can show you.” Well, not for a little bit because I started fucking the tied-up coed even harder and even then, it took a few minutes to reach the point where I couldn't hold back any longer. It was another minute or two to untie her and then another ten or so as I let her scroll through all her social media accounts and pull up pictures on her phone. I was right there with her, rejecting the ones that were just too plain looking and pointing out possible candidates.

Finally, we narrowed it down to six of the best.

“There's no way these women haven't been fucked yet.” I tell Alison as I look over the girls in question. “That Asian cutey looks like a model - and check out the blonde.”

“That's Gabby, she's one of my best friends.” Alison smiles up at me conspiratorially, “all the guys she dates think they're going to get lucky, but none of them ever do.”

Alison briefs me again on all the girls so I can keep them straight.

The Redhead is Molly O'Conner, from a devout Irish Catholic family in South Boston, she has a steady boyfriend back home, but she's saving herself for her wedding night. It's hard to tell from Alison's pictures because this Molly seems to always wear shapeless clothes that conceal her figure, but Alison is pretty sure that under the bulky sweaters and skirts that she has a nice curvy body.

Danielle Williams, it turns out is from is from Richmond, Virginia and is the only daughter of one of the states most prominent families. She is the secretary of the 'Promise Club' that promotes chastity on campus. I sense a little tension when Alison talks about her, but I'm not sure what her story is.

The hot looking blonde is Gabrielle Harris from Indiana. Out of all the girls, she's the one with the most experience with boys, but according to Alison at least, she's a tease that leaves a lot of guys frustrated at the end of the date. Of all the candidates, she looks the most like Alison, with midsized breasts, a toned body and a great ass.

The light-skinned black girl is Tasha Brown, from NYC and one of Alison's classmates from Dr. Lark's Women's Studies class. Alison thinks she might be a lesbian, but she's not sure about that; maybe she's just shy around men. Tasha is the most athletic of the group and played field hockey, basketball and softball in high school. She walked-on for the basket try-outs at Wesleyan, but at only five foot four, was too short to make the team.

The brunette with the glasses is Sarah Goldberg a Jewish girl from Chicago who Alison also knows from Dr. Lark's class, but not as well as she knows Tasha. In her picture, she looks a little chubby but I don't mind that especially because Alison assures me that she has the biggest tits of any of them.

Mei-lin Lee is an exchange student from China studying electrical engineering. According to Alison she's one of the smartest girls in the whole college but is a little clueless when it comes to guys. She may be a touch thin for my tastes with small breasts and not much of an ass ... still there's something about a hot Asian school girl.

“Just imagine what it would be like, Mr. P.” Alison licks her lips slowly, “I could find some way to get them alone and then you could snatch them.” She hands me her phone so I can look over the pictures one more time. “Which of these six would you want to harvest first?”