How about a different game?

"Ok," you say. "I'm really bad at this game, as you can see. How about we play a different game?"

"Like what?" asks Allison, with a little smile. You are feeling pretty horny now and have an idea. "How about truth or dare?"

She looks like she expected it. "Ha!" she says, "Don't be a wimp! We're just playing dare!" With a grin, you sit down on the bed and she sits across from you. You let her go first.

"Hmmm..." she mumbles. She pauses. "I want you to take off everything except your boxers." You hadn't expected her to be this forward but she continues. "I just want to see if you get turned on by this, you aren't going to be hiding anything from me."

You pull your T-shirt over your head and slip off your shorts. Your dick isn't sticking out badly at all.