Her shoulders and ass still need attention

You lay Bethany on your bed next to an eager looking Renee. "Mmmm, doesn't she look happy," says Renee, tail flicking from side to side lazily.

"Yeah," Bethany says. Her voice is muffled since she's nuzzling into your chest.

You sit down, still cradling her, and continue to stroke her fur. Renee joins you and Beth purrs contentedly. What brings her out of her reverie is the sound of quick footsteps and then the door opening. There's an eager looking Alice standing there and she asks, "What can I do? What's left from the list?"

That causes Beth's tail to start batting back and forth and Alice grins. "Guess I didn't miss the best parts, huh?"

"We're down to shoulder massages and... something new," you tell her. "Although maybe that's too much for Bethany right now." To Bethany you say, "I'm not going to **** you," as gently as you can.

You're kind of expecting her to nod and save the idea for later, but despite a hot blush you feel through her fur Bethany just curls up against you. As embarrassed as she is by the idea of anal it seems she's just as excited by it.

"Who made that suggestion anyway?" you ask.

"Oh, if it's what I think it is, then that would be me," Renee tells you. "She has asked Helena and I about it more than once." She gets close to Bethany and rubs her ear. "And it is something I enjoy from time to time, something different, something naughty, so I gave her a little encouragement."

Bethany isn't saying anything, but she's frozen up and tensed a bit. Her toes have curled up too.

"Well if you suggested taking the plunge then I guess Lessia is the one who suggested a nice, firm shoulder massage. I think I should start there." You don't bother waiting for confirmation, you just dig your fingers into Beth's shoulders and back, kneading her muscles and drawing a joyous mewl from her.

Soon enough Bethany has gone limp, her body is draped across you like a warm fur blanket. She's so relaxed you almost worry she'll forget to breathe.

As you massage her, Doe and Yvonne come back into the room to watch the fun. And you notice the door stays a crack open after Yvonne comes in. There's an eye that belongs to a naughty princess looking through the gap, watching you as you care for the wife she first grew close to. Now it's time to see if Bethany enjoys taking your cock in her tail side.

Of all your wives it's little Helena who's most into anal. While you wouldn't say she enjoys it more than normal sex it's an itch she needs scratched pretty frequently. Doe and Renee both allow you to fill their bottoms once in a while - if they're horny enough they occasionally even suggest it for a change of pace. But you wouldn't call it their favorite activity. For some reason Doe liked taking it in her ass even more when she was about halfway through her pregnancy. You don't know why.

Sandra and Harmony must both remember it from their old lives, though you haven't yet had the chance to test Harmony out. Sandra seems to love anal, that or she knows what an effect it has on men. She look back over her shoulder as you take her, licking her lips and purring in delight as you enjoy her body in a way the church wouldn't approve of.

The bums of Yvonne, Kyelle, Alice and Lessia all remain untouched so far. Yvonne has stubbornly refused Sandra's suggestions to give it a shot, Alice seemed unsure each time it came up and distracted you with a blowjob or by hopping into your lap and grinding her pussy against your shaft. And for Kyelle you simply haven't had the chance to go there, so you have no idea what her feelings might be.

As a princess you would have once assumed Lessia would be the last person in the world to be open to the idea, but then again she's turned out to be quite the kinky girl. Which makes Bethany's first time doubly important - you know that if Beth ends up well satisfied then there's a better chance that someday your cock will part the firm bottom of the catgirl princess. It may also give Yvonne another reason to think she might be missing out on something. And like a cat looking at a squirrel through a glass window there's nothing that drives Yvonne crazier than thinking she's missing out.

So as you roll Bethany onto her tummy you have high hopes. She's still limp, but you lean down close to her face and one green eye opens slowly. You press one hand against the cheek of her firm bum and ask, "What do you want to do now?"

Bethany lets out a soft purr. It sounds positive, but it's not really an answer.

You kneed her cheek and then grip the base of her tail, working your thumb in circles over the spot where it joins her back, a hot spot on the body of many catgirls, Beth included. "I said I wasn't going to **** you," you remind her. "So could you tell me what you want to do?"

Bethany screws her one open eye shut and tries to bury her face in the sheets. She whispers, "Don't make me say it."

"Ah, still so shy," you say, rubbing her ear with one hand and the root of her tail with the other, "What about if I ask you? Can you give me a nod?"

She nods.

Quite a lot louder you say, "Bethany, my lovely wife, you've already shared your precious pussy and your delightful mouth with me - on this wonderful morning would you like to share your bottom with me as well?"

Bethany's ear is almost glowing hot under your touch. But she does give a jerky nod.

Next to her Renee is grinning. As soon as you change position Renee moves closer, gently kissing her shy, embarrassed wife.

Bethany lower half is still almost unmoving. She lets you get between her thighs, the only 'comment' from her body is the increasing pace of tail flicking from side to side. When you're in the right spot you lift her hips. She lets you manhandle her body into a good kitty style position, her muscles providing just enough support to hold her bum in the air. She wants to be like putty in your hands, offering no resistance at all.

Only when your fingers work to spread open her ass for the first time does she squirm. Renee keeps kissing her, excited to share in Beth's first time. You take your time preparing her. Each time you do something new, like applying lube to her ass for the first time, or testing her with a finger, she tenses a little and you loosen her back up with extensive massages of her tail.

When you decide the time is right you slide inside her ass and are rewarded with a sexy, somewhat **** mewl. Her bottom clenches on the invader and you have to stop where you are for quite a long time. But finally her muscles give up and you press further until that triggers a second round of squeezing as her ass tries to **** you back out. Again and again it happens, but you slowly batter down her defenses until you've sunk all the way in.

As your pelvis presses up against her bum Bethany lets out a proper, "Meow!" - something you've only seen catgirls do when they're excited. She breaks her kiss with Renee to look back at you. Those deep green eyes of hers are pools of lust.

And here you thought that every inch you gained was a trial because it felt so unnatural to her. But looking at her now you realize that Bethany has taken to anal sex. She may have been scared, or too shy to suggest it herself, but whatever fears or worries she had have all rolled together to make this an event for her. From the look of it, Bethany is already enjoying herself so much that she was trying to hide it.

You draw back and gently push in once more. Again her body fights back, but this time her tail also rocks from side to side, which feels amazing to your cock. The bundle of muscles that drives her tail is just above your shaft, so it's like she's rolling your cock in the opposite direction each time that tail moves from side to side. You didn't mean for catgirls to have such an edge in terms of anal, but you're not complaining.

Doe joins you, snuggling up behind Bethany and wrapping her arm around the writhing catgirl so she can grope Bethany's breast. "Quite the feeling, isn't it?"

Bethany bites her lip and nods hard enough that she almost headbutts Renee.

Doe laughs and says, "Wow, I think you like this as much as Helena. Renee and I had to try it a few times before it really felt good."

Bethany mewls and tries to bury her head again. Perhaps she didn't want your other wives to recognize what pleasure she's getting from this. But you're not going to allow that, not when her ass is doing such wonderful things to your cock. No, you want to make your wife mewl in pleasure. And so you set to work, using everything you've learned from taking Doe's, Renee's, Helena's and Sandra's asses to make this good for Bethany.

When you trigger her G-spot she sucks in a deep breath and lets out a moan worthy of a succubus. Her body shakes and her legs give out, leaving your hands and cock as the only things supporting her hips. As for her tail, it has a life of its own, flailing and smacking against you, against the bed to either side, then smacking you, then the bed, again and again.

It's a very loud and showy orgasm for a girl who's normally so reserved. And it's plain to see that all your other wives notice that too. Alice is getting herself off, Yvonne is smiling and both Doe and Renee are holding Bethany as she recovers.

When Beth starts to come back to her senses you start moving again, causing her to arch her back and try to get her knees back under her again. But now that she's warmed up you move a little faster, a little more forcefully, and soon she's a mess once again. Legs askew, she's in no position to resist the pleasure you're giving her. At last you cum, pressing yourself to the root inside her ass.

Bethany is panting like she ran a race. She looks back at you now that you've stopped and asks, "Did you? You cum?" And then her eyes roll and her mouth hangs open. You're not even moving, so it has to be the very thought that you just creamed her ass that drives her over the edge once again.

She actually doesn't pass out - but she does lie there, soaking in bliss, like nothing else in the world matters. After you clean her and yourself up Bethany crawls into your arms and cuddles. You end up spending hours like that, with your wives all coming by to check up on you. And while Bethany is still deeply embarrassed about it, when Renee, Sandra and Alice ask if she enjoyed it she does smile and very quietly say, 'Yes'.