Her ass

"Oh, I really want that pussy, but I have to try that ass first," Phil said, stepping closer, pushing the tip of his cock against Haley's sphincter. Haley looked over her shoulder.

"Dad, please be gentle. I've never... I mean, no one has ever..."

"Don't worry," he replied, pushing his cock head against her sphincter, pressing slowly until the tip, then the head popped into her ass. Haley hissed in pain, but Phil didn't stop until his entire cock slid into her ass. Jay turned Haley's head, pushing his own cock back into her mouth.

They moved in tandem, Haley's body being moved on both cocks until Phil cried out, his cock spasming inside Haley's ass, filling her colon with sperm and pushing Haley's mouth forward, Jay's cock popping into Haley's throat, where it spewed its own load of sperm down her throat.

They held that way, each man holding his cock inside her until they noticed Haley trying to pull her mouth off Jay's cock. Jay pulled his cock out of his granddaughter's mouth, allowing Haley to gasp for breath. Phil kept his hands on her hips, his cock in her ass as she used her hand to wipe the bits of cum off her lips as she panted for breath.

"Damn, that was good," Phil panted, reaching down, wrapping his arms around his daughter, pulling her up into his arms. "You have the tightest ass I've ever felt," he whispered into Haley's ear.

"We need to do that again," Jay said, sitting back on his heels.

"Yeah," Phil whispered so only Haley could hear, "or just you and me." His hands cupped Haley's small breasts, rubbing her sensitive nipples. "And next time, I'm going to fuck this tight little pussy," he said, his hand slipping between her legs to touch the lips of her shaved pussy, his fingertips touching her hard clit.

Haley shuddered in her father's arms, thinking of all the fun she would have in the future.