He chooses Amy

Amy had offered. It only made sense that he give her the treat.

"I choose Amy," he said.

Amy clapped her hands. "Yay!" She was under the table before Karen could do more than make an ugly expression at him. Clearly she'd been hoping to be chosen. Well, he could understand that. Amy had already given him a blowjob and he'd cum in his mom twice. Karen was the only one who had been left out.

Still, he wasn't thinking about that now with Amy fumbling with his zipper.

He unzipped for her, dragged out his dick, and popped it in her mouth then turned back to enjoy the conversation with his family.

"Glad we got our homework done earlier," Karen said. "It's been a long day."

"Yeah."

"You two are talking like there's nothing going on," their mother protested.

"It's just another blowjob," Karen said. "Not like the real fucking you gave your son. Now that was something special."

"I wish you'd use other language."

"Like passionate incestuous lovemaking?"

"And would forget that word."

"And... here's your pizza." April looked cheery and held a gigantic pizza. "What happened to that other girl. She always seems to disappear."

Karen beckoned her with one finger. "Don't let on that you know but take a peek under the table."

"Oh. Oh!"

"Shhh."

She punched Matt in the arm. "You are a complete dog. And doing it with your mom there, too."

Matt nodded. "Guilty as charged."

"I'll bet I'm better than she is. I'll bet I'm better than Tanya, too."

"Big talk," Matt said. "Go out with me on Friday night and we can... discuss it further."

"Maybe. Call me."