Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 6 by Fitfully_Yours Fitfully_Yours

Who was Alex with?

Haley

Phil started in shock, realizing both his daughters were standing there naked, and Alex had quite clearly been licking Haley's shaved pussy. "Keep going," Phil said, closing the door behind him. "I want to see what your definition of nothing actually is."

Hesitantly, the two girls moved back together, Haley's legs spreading a bit, Alex's arms circling her as she pushed her face between her sister's legs. Haley's hands ran through her sister's hair as she pulled her head closer, trying to get more pressure behind the intimate kisses. As he watched, he started taking his clothes off. With her mouth locked on Haley's pussy, Alex couldn't see that, but Haley watched with interest as Phil's cock popped free. One hand left Alex's head to run over her small breast, pinching her nipple as she was driven to orgasm by her sister's tongue and the excitement of being watched by her own dad.

Haley looked down at Alex as Alex looked up at her, for a moment both girls forgetting Phil's presence. Alex's lower face was wet with her sister's juices, and looked proud of the fact that she caused her sister to look that way.

Phil cleared his throat, making both of his daughters jump. Haley had watched as Phil stripped, but now Alex got her first glimpse of her dad's cock, her face losing all color.

"We have a bit of a problem," Phil stated, taking a step forward. "You've gotten me all excited, so which of you is going to fix it?"

"But I'm a virgin," Alex protested. "I... I can't..."

"Well, I'm almost a virgin too," Haley said, "if not for Dylan I would be."

"That still doesn't change the fact that one of you is going to have to get me off."

Which daughter gets Phil off?

More fun
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)