Forget the toys, claim your prize!

The sight before you is simply too tempting. Kneeling behind Tibby, you pull her dress up to her lower back and get your hands on her ass. You squeeze her round cheeks with delight, grabbing them and moving your hands to make them jiggle slightly. Annabelle and Ashley both grin as they watch you play, and Annabelle imitates your movements to shake Ashley's tits at you.

The only person who hasn't reacted to your mischief is Tibby herself, but that's soon to change. Spreading her cheeks apart, you take in the sight of her glistening slit before you take a hand off her butt. When your finger makes contact with her wet pussy Tibby tries to turn her head to look at you, but Ashley holds her in place by squeezing her legs closed.

Trapped between Ashley's thighs, your kitty has **** but to keep licking while you tease her lower lips. Your finger traces up one side and down the other, circling around her clit at the midway point. Then it pushes inside, feeling how wet she is.

You're more than ready yourself, so you put your hands back on Tibby's cheeks and stick your dick between them. Hotdogging your sausage in her crack, you slide it up and down a couple of times. You make sure the base of your cock rubs against her clitoris. After a while you pull back and bump into it with the tip of your dick.

Impatient, Tibby jerks her hips down and manages to lodge the tip between her lips. Just as impatiently, your hips surge forward in response. Your penis slips inside, penetrating several inches before you regain control. You pull back slightly, but then give her a deeper thrust.

Tibby yowls, only to be silenced when Ashley pushes the cat's head deeper into her crotch. Still kneading Ashley's boobs, Annabelle grins at you. "Is this still part of her punishment?"

"Of course," you tell her. "So you better not slack off in front, Tibs."

"She isn't!" Ashley moans with delight.

Laughing, you give Tibby a little 'good job' pat on the bum. Then you get down to the business of fucking her. Your hands on her hips, you push forward until your stomach touches her ass, burying yourself in her hot snatch. You saw back and forth like that, withdrawing halfway and then pounding right back into her. Despite the sudden stimulation the quality of her cunnilingus doesn't suffer. Ashley sure isn't complaining, her moans reaching a fever pitch. Aided by Annabelle pinching away at her stiff nipples, her hands buried in Tibby's hair, Ashley soon reaches her climax. She screams out, pulling Tibby roughly against her before relaxing totally.

After a few more licks, Tibby slips out of her grip and raises her head. "This is... Mmh! a great punishment. Keep it in mind if I ever cause any real trouble?"

Your thrusts don't slow, but you dial back their intensity so you can answer her. "You wish. If you cause trouble you're getting a spanking. Once you've learned your lesson we can talk about repeating this punishment."

"Good enough for me." She laughs. "Now keep fucking me, John!"

You oblige her, really railing her now. Meanwhile, Ashley tries to back away from the action. Of course Annabelle is still behind her, but they've soon rearranged themselves so they can watch what you're doing together.

Deciding you could use more of a show yourself, you pull out of Tibby just long enough to flip her onto her back. Then you're back inside her pussy, her legs wrapped around your lower back and her hands on your shoulders. Now you can see her smiling face, messy with two women's vaginal juices, which you lean in to lick off her lips before kissing her. Tibby's hands move up to your neck, and her tongue enters your mouth. You meet it with your own, filling your mouth with Ashley's flavor before your head comes up again.

Tibby is **** to let go, stealing another kiss before her hands drop back to your shoulders and let you up. This lets you thrust into her properly, and this time your crotch grinds against her clitoris at the deepest point of every penetration. Soon Tibby is crying out, her vagina clenching around your shaft.

You cum together, filling Tibby with your cream while she holds you tight.

When Tibby lets go of you, you slowly raise your body off of hers. On your way up, you plant a kiss on her nose. "Your crimes are forgiven, little mutineer."

"Thanks, Captain! Permission to rejoin your crew?"

"Granted."

"That was fun," Annabelle tells you once everyone has gotten dressed and moved to her kitchen. "I didn't think that roleplay would get so intense so quickly."

"I did warn you that we're animals." Ashley sticks her tongue out. "And now that we've had a taste you'll never get rid of us."

"You mean I can have crazy, no-strings-attached, roleplaying foursome fun with my favorite pets and their handsome owner whenever I want? Have mercy, what a frightful thought!"

"Yeah, we're a scary bunch," you laugh. "But we don't have to be this wild every time. We should probably get out of your hair before we lose our costumes again."

"Who says that'd be a bad thing?" Annabelle asks. "Just come back soon, you hear?"

Standing up, she leads your rag-tag crew to the apartment's hallway door. Everyone gets a hug and a goodbye grope in, then you're outside and on the way back to your apartment.