Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 44 by wrent

What's next?

Farther than he meant to go.

Sean watched his wife let the dildo drop from her hand, then slide to the floor and slowly crawl toward Magnus, swaying her hips back and forth. Everyone watched as she finished her sexy crawl licked him from root to tip. After minute Allie joined back in as they both slurped and licked like their favorite popsicle was melting too fast. Sean felt himself stiffen watching then. Magnus look over, saw his erection and gave him a grin, then said, "Allie, do you think Sean could fuck your ass?" When she looked up at Magnus Sean caught a glimpse of her rolling her eyes and muttering something like, "I don't know, can he?" Magnus gave her a slightly exasperated look and she relented, "fine." She turned over her shoulder and wriggled her ass at Sean, giving him a lascivious smile while still stroking Magnus.

Sean was uncertain, knowing Chloe might be jealous. They'd never had anal sex after all. He looked to her for approval, but she just smiled and nodded at him to go ahead. Sean grinned at the thought of getting to pound Allie's round and toned golden-brown ass. This was going to be fun.

Sean approached Allie's ass, rock hard seeing the darker brown skin crinkling around her rear hole and at the thought of how tight she'd be. He lusted for the feel of pounding against those warm, firm cheeks. He started rubbing his dick around on her, then spit to try and prepare her for entry. Allie reached down and rubbed her pussy for a second, then reached up and smeared some of her wetness on Sean, laughing as she said, "Magnus, you make girls so wet they make their own anal lube." Just as Sean was trying to poke his penis into her bottom, Chloe spoke up, "Allie, have you ever been double penetrated?"

Everyone paused for a second as Allie answered, "Well, no." For the first time she actually sounded a little unsure of herself.

"Oh you're going to love it girl. Sean, lay down on your back right here." She pointed to a spot on the rug in front of the sofa. "Allie, you come sit on top of him, but reverse cowgirl. Drop your ass on that dick!"

Allie did just that, squatting low and rubbing her ass back and forth as Sean poked his mushroom head into her. He had a somewhat large head for his overall size, so when it finally went in there was a distinct 'pop' sensation as the head got through. Then he went a little deeper. It was tight. Tighter than any pussy he'd ever felt, but not nearly as wet. And while it felt pretty good, it didn't squeeze him in all the right places, or feel as alive and responsive as Chloe's pussy. Hmm he thought to himself, It's good, but not great. I guess I kind of miss Chloe...

Chloe was still talking, "Alright Magnus, now nice and easy." She laughed and said, "this might be the one time her pussy is going to feel fuller than her ass during a DP." She took hold of his shaft and started feeding it into Allie, who quickly began to moan and writhe, which felt great to Sean. But right as Magnus's head was inside Allie, Sean felt a massive push on his shaft, and then a squeezing pressure that moved slowly toward the the tip. He could feel Magnus so distinctly he actually wasn't sure their dicks weren't rubbing together. He felt a little squeamish, like he might want to chicken out, but then Magnus pulled back and thrust forward again. Fuck that feels good he thought, gasping a little. Magnus made another long stroke, and Sean made a little cry at the sensation. It was almost as though he wasn't so much fucking Allie as he was getting fucked by Magnus.

The pace of thrusts started to increase. After 5 thrusts Sean was totally focused on the sensations. After 10 he couldn't have told you if Allie was enjoying herself, or what Chloe was doing at the moment. After 15 he barely remembered his name as he started cumming uncontrollably. Magnus's large knob was running down the length of him and squeezing out every drop. The pleasure was indescribable.

And then he came back to the world of the living, and Magnus was fucking Allie as Sean's dick soften in her dark tunnel, and Chloe was kissing Magnus while looking at Sean, a grin splitting her face.

The thing was, Magnus kept fucking Allie. Sean was trapped underneath, his face full of her long dark hair, his lower back feeling rug-burned. His hips were getting sore where they supported the weight of two people fucking on top of him. Magnus was relentless. Sean's penis had long since grown flaccid, just the head still inside her tight rosebud, the floppy shaft getting yanked around as she moaned and humped back to match Magnus thrust for thrust. Her sweaty ass was rubbing all over Sean's lower abdomen.

Finally, Allie came, screaming out Magnus's name as she did. But Magnus kept going. Unable to bear it any longer, Sean spoke up in a weak voice, "Do you guys want to switch?" Everyone stopped for a second, then Chloe spoke up first, "Sure babe! I thought you'd never ask!" Sean felt Allie get off of him and his dick pop free and slap limply on his belly. He felt relieved, and was about to get up when suddenly Chloe sat down in Allie's place. "Wha.." He began, but she looked back over her shoulder at him and slid her ass back and forth over his shaft. "Don't worry baby, I'll get you hard and then you can have my ass." She started to smile at him sweetly, but it turned into an open-mouth moan as Magnus's face came into to view. Sean couldn't feel it this time, but he was sure his friend had just penetrated his wife.

He'd wanted to fuck Chloe's ass for so long, so he focused on getting hard. It actually was easier than he expected. First there were Chloe's moans and her clear enjoyment of his friend. Then he flexed his dick and pressed it against her ass, and there was so much slippery sweat and cum on him, and her ass was moving around so much from the work Magnus was putting in, that he actually got his erection back quite quickly. Now he just had to ask Chloe to help him get it in. He couldn't lift her and aim it the way she was lying on top of him. He tried to say something, but just got a mouthful of hair. He decided to waited for a break, but it didn't seem like it was going to happen any time soon.

He was surprised when Chloe started to sit up off of his chest. Finally he thought, reaching for his shaft so he could be ready to slide it into his wife. He opened his mouth to say something, and right at that moment Allie's pussy dropped on top of his face. She was straddling his head, cradling Chloe's shoulders and supporting her as she was railed by Magnus. All the while Sean's dick was caught under her firm cheeks, sliding this way and that.

Sean did what any reasonable man would, and ate Allie out with abandon while his dick throbbed under his wife. Allie's pussy was sopping and open from recently being filled by Magnus, and Sean pushed his tongue as deep as it would go. Allie responded by grinding down harder and tilting her hips, giving him access to her clit. It didn't take long before she started to orgasm.

Magnus was now using short fast strokes on Chloe, and both seemed to be caught in a breathless crescendo. Sean's dick was getting pumped by the valley of Chloe's ass and he finally succumbed to the sensations, spraying yet another load over his own belly. Seconds later Chloe moaned in her own orgasm and Magnus roared as he tried to (very respectfully) pull out, but he was just a second too late. He grasped his cock as the first ropey blast of cum hit Chloe all over her gaping pussy, then his next one went lower and Sean felt a warm gush splatter against his balls. Then another blast went higher, across Chloe's flat belly, hitting her the underside of her breasts and running down her abs. His final blast went higher still, actually catching Chloe's face, running from her cheek and across her lips. She laughed with pure joy as Magnus's huge spurts subsided into a slowing stream and everyone breathed for a second.

They all started getting untangled, catching their breath and laughing. Sean just lay still for a second. Allie and Magnus went to the kitchen for something to drink, and Sean felt Chloe kneel next to him. "Whew! That was so hot babe. I'm sure you'll be able to get hard next time and try my ass."

Sean looked at her, "but I was hard... I thought you were going to stop so we could..."

Chloe looked aghast, "Oh no babe, I'm so sorry! I couldn't feel it, and after earlier I just thought you were having trouble. I didn't want to call attention to it! You should've said something." Her voice was full of regret.

She looked so genuinely sad, he couldn't bring himself to be mad at her. "No love, it's fine, I still had lots of fun."

"Well I'm still sorry. I'm glad you had fun. I think we all did." She said with a smile. "Let me go get the guest room together for our friends, and then I think time for bed?" Chloe looked down at him, then let out a little laugh. "You are a total mess!"

Sean looked at himself. Allie had cum on his face. Chloe had been dripping on him. He'd cum on his own belly. And there was a LOT of cum from Magnus all over his balls and thighs.

She leaned over and kissed him gently on the mouth. Then pulled away and said, "you need a shower," then left toward the kitchen.

As he made his way to his bedroom Sean tasted a slight salty tang on his lips, and he thought he knew what it was...

Who does he wake up next to in the night?

Comments

      More fun
      Want to support CHYOA?
      Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)