Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 10 by Iliketurtle Iliketurtle

What does Tyler choose?

Diane's Breasts

The plan crystallized by the third red light. Diane's tits first. Not just a glance—ownership. He'd turn those pillowy udders into his personal playground, inch by inch, until Kyle could smell him on her skin. The specifics came easy: He'd start with the left one. Always the left. Less predictable. That way, when Diane absentmindedly cupped herself later—and she would—her fingers would brush Tyler's fingerprints first.

Tyler didn't knock - he was the man in Diane's life now. The door swung open, no key needed. "Naive Diane" Tyler chuckled to himself. He found her sprawled on a lounger by the pool in a bikini top. From underneath her bra, her tits swayed gently with each breath while she scrolled Instagram obliviously. Tyler crouched beside her, the scent of sunscreen and sweat thick in the humid air. He pressed his thumb against her cleavage enough to dent the soft flesh. Diane gasped, phone clattering onto concrete. "Ty—what—"

"Mosquito," Tyler lied smoothly, dragging his fingertip lower. Her skin flushed where he touched. Diane blinked up at him, the bikini straps digging into her shoulders as she sat up. "Oh! You're sweet." She patted his cheek, never noticing how his other hand lingered near her hip. Tyler's pulse hammered.

Diane suddenly frowned, glancing down at her own cleavage. "I shouldn't be lounging around half-naked like some college girl," she muttered, tugging at the flimsy fabric. The movement made her tits wobble dangerously. Tyler's mouth watered. Diane stood abruptly—too fast—and the bikini top slipped, exposing one pink nipple before she caught it. Tyler memorized the shape. "Let me just..." Diane gestured toward the house, already backing away.

Please log in to view the image

Tyler smiled, identifying the perfect moment, "Diane, you should clean that off before you go." Diane paused, confused, glancing down at her bikini top, "Clean what?" Tyler stepped forward, "Right there." He pointed casually toward the nonexistent sunscreen streak on her bra —close enough that his knuckles brushed the swell of her breast. Diane frowned, lifting her hands to inspect herself, inadvertently pulling the bikini taut and emphasizing her cleavage. Tyler bit back a smirk as her fingers fumbled over the spot he'd indicated. "I don't see—"

Tyler pointed at the center of her left breast, "There. it's a smudge or something."

Diane huffed, exasperated. "You young men and your sharp eyes." She plucked at the fabric, twisting it sideways to inspect it—unknowingly tugging her bikini top dangerously low. "Is it here?" She began to rub the top of her bra, over her nipple, which grew more prominent from under the top, hardening. Tyler swallowed hard, his pulse erratic as he watched her fingers drag back and forth across her own flesh.

"No—higher." His voice came out rough. Diane obediently slid her fingertips upward, grazing the underside of her breast. The movement made her tit bounce slightly, the weight of it shifting in the flimsy fabric. Tyler's cock twitched. "Pinch it," he instructed casually, as if advising her on a stain. "Between your fingers. Harder."

Diane complied, pinching the stretched fabric—and her own nipple along with it—between her thumb and forefinger. She winced but didn't protest, too preoccupied with her imaginary task. "Like this?" She twisted the fabric tighter, her nipple now visibly tenting the material. Tyler had to adjust his stance, subtly pressing his erection against the lounger's edge. "Perfect," he lied. "Now rub in circles. The stain needs to go."

Kyle's voice sliced through the thick air like a rusty blade. "Jesus Christ." Tyler turned slowly, grinning at the sight of Kyle frozen in the patio doorway, his face twisted in disgusted disbelief. Diane, still dutifully massaging her breast, blinked up at Kyle. "Oh! Kyle, sweetie, did you need something?" Her fingers kept moving—small, rhythmic circles—as she spoke. Kyle’s jaw worked soundlessly. Tyler watched with vicious satisfaction as Kyle’s gaze flicked between Diane’s hands and her oblivious expression.

The bikini top had slipped further, the damp fabric clinging obscenely to her erect nipple. Kyle's throat bobbed. "What the fuck are you—"

"Kyle! Please be respectful in front of our guest." Diane exclaimed, before innocently explaining, "Tyler was just helping me with sunscreen—it's stained me!" Her fingers never stopped kneading her own flesh, the wet fabric now thin where it stretched over her nipple. She turned back to Tyler with a grateful smile. "You're always so attentive, sweetie." Tyler smirked, watching Kyle's face darken as Diane plucked at her bikini top again. "See? Right here—" She pinched her own areola through the fabric, rolling it between her fingers like she was demonstrating a technique. "Tyler said I had to really work it off."

Diane turned back to Tyler. "Is it off?"

"Almost," Tyler murmured, stepping closer. He reached out—slowly, deliberately—and tapped the center of her left breast. "Right here. Needs more... attention." Diane nodded eagerly, pressing two fingers against the exact spot, rubbing harder now. The bikini strap slipped further down her shoulder, revealing the upper swell of her breast. Kyle's fists clenched at his sides, his nostrils flaring as Diane whimpered softly from the rough treatment of her own nipple.

Tyler knew that it was time: "Diane, it doesn't seem to be coming off any more." Diane looked scared. Tyler continued, "Y'know what? I think the stain might actually be under your bra." Kyle looked at Tyler in surprise. Surely Kyle's mom wasn't dumb enough to believe that. Diane paused and looked down at her chest, then back up at Tyler. "Do you think?" Tyler nodded slowly, never breaking eye contact with Kyle. Diane sighed, "Oh for goodness sake..." Her fingers reached behind her back and unhooked the bikini top in one smooth motion. The fabric fell away, her tits bouncing free—full, heavy, nipples already stiff from her earlier ministrations.

Please log in to view the image

Diane cupped her breasts, lifting them slightly as she inspected the underside. "I don't see anything," she murmured, twisting to catch the sunlight. Tyler swallowed hard, watching her fingers press into the soft flesh. Kyle made a strangled noise, but Diane didn't notice, too focused on her task. "Here, let me help," Tyler said, stepping closer. He placed his hands over hers, guiding them in slow circles. Diane sighed gratefully. "You're always so selfless, Tyler," she murmured, oblivious to the way his thumbs brushed her nipples with each rotation. "Most boys your age wouldn't help a woman with something like this."

Kyle lurched forward, grabbing Tyler's shoulder. "This is fucking insane—" Tyler shook him off smoothly. "It's just common courtesy," he said, never breaking rhythm with Diane's hands. "Right, Diane? A real man steps up when a lady needs help." Diane beamed, her tits jiggling as she nodded enthusiastically. "Exactly! Kyle's father used to—" Her breath hitched when Tyler's fingers dipped lower, tracing the crease beneath her breast. "Oh! That tickles," she giggled, arching into the touch. Kyle looked ready to vomit.

Tyler seized the moment. "See?" He pressed Diane's palm flush against her own tit, kneading it obscenely through her fingers. "Right here—feel how deep the stain goes." Diane's brow furrowed in concentration as she squeezed herself, her nipple poking between her own knuckles. "Hmm... maybe it's more toward the—" Tyler guided her other hand to her opposite breast, spreading her fingers wide. "Check underneath properly," he murmured, watching Kyle's face twist as Diane lifted both tits with her palms, exposing the soft undersides to the sunlight. Her thumbs brushed her own nipples in the process, making her gasp softly.

Kyle lunged again—this time for Diane's wrists—but Tyler pivoted, blocking him with his shoulder. "Careful," Tyler warned low, never pausing the circular motion he was imprinting onto Diane's hands. "Wouldn't want to *interrupt.*" Diane blinked up at them, blissfully unaware. "Boys, no fighting! Kyle, honey, Tyler's just being thorough." She demonstrated by groping herself harder, fingers sinking into the pliant flesh. "Like this, see?" Her tits jiggled with the motion, nipples pebbling tighter. Kyle's jaw clenched so hard Tyler heard teeth grind.

Diane sighed, releasing her breasts to wipe her forehead with the back of her hand. They swayed heavily, still flushed from her self-examination. "Maybe what I *really* need," she mused, turning to Tyler with a sheepish smile, "is a strong man's hands to properly check?" Kyle made a noise like a stepped-on dog. Tyler didn't bother hiding his grin. "You're right," he agreed solemnly, flexing his fingers. "Amateur fingers—like yours—might miss the *deep* stains." Diane nodded eagerly, presenting her chest like an offering.

Kyle grabbed Tyler's arm, hissing through clenched teeth, "You psychotic—" Tyler shook him off effortlessly, stepping into Diane's space. His palms engulfed her tits before Kyle could blink—firm, possessive squeezes that made Diane gasp and arch. "See?" Tyler murmured, rolling her nipples between his knuckles. "A man's grip gets *underneath* the problem." Diane whimpered agreement, her thighs pressing together as Tyler's thumbs circled her stiff peaks. Kyle stood frozen, his pulse hammering in his throat as Tyler worked Diane over with practiced cruelty, his fingers leaving faint red marks on her pale skin.

"Mmm. So thorough," Diane slurred, her hands fluttering uselessly at her sides. Tyler squeezed harder, watching her nipples bulge between his fingers like ripe cherries. He twisted—just shy of pain—and felt her knees buckle against his thigh. Diane exhaled sharply through her nose, drooping against his chest. Tyler threw Kyle a smirk over her shoulder. "See how she *needs* this?"

What's next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)