Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 14 by SmutWriter SmutWriter

What is the fantasy?

Dana’s Birthday Betrayal

In the harsh lamplight of Dana’s bedroom, the air was thick with sweat, lavender, and the raw musk of sex, Alex’s cock still pulsing from the orgasm that had flooded Dana’s tight, scorching pussy moments ago. Her body lay beneath him, slick and trembling, dark ponytail splayed across the sheets, small breasts heaving, dark nipples stiff, brown eyes gleaming with intense, enigmatic hunger. Her torn black thong lay discarded, soaked with their juices, her pussy leaking his cum, thighs glistening in the stark light. Anna was passed out in her room, snores faint, oblivious, while Bella and Chloe remained **** downstairs, their silver and red dresses askew on the couch, the living room a chaotic mess of shot glasses and vodka. Dana’s kink—degrading Anna’s sexual prowess—had driven her wild, her pussy clenching as she begged him to call Anna “pathetic,” their bodies collapsing in a sweaty, breathless heap. Her earlier question—“Wanna keep this, Alex? Fuck behind Anna’s back?”—lingered unanswered, his hesitation a weight, but her promise of a “wild fantasy” sparked a fire, her cruel smirk a lure in the dimness.

Dana propped herself up on an elbow, her small breasts swaying, eyes locked on his with a fierce gleam. “That fantasy I mentioned,” she murmured, her voice a low, seductive hiss, fingers tracing his neck, grazing his sweat-slick skin, her pussy still dripping his load, lavender scent mingling with their musk. “I’m telling you now, Alex, every twisted detail, because I need you to feel how much better I am than Anna.” Her words hooked him, his cock stirring despite the ache, the promise pulling him deeper into her web. “Tell me,” he growled, voice rough with desire, sitting up, his eyes tracing her toned curves, her pussy glistening, thighs slick with their cum. She crawled closer, her movements taut and deliberate, straddling his lap, thighs spreading wide over his, her pussy’s heat brushing his semi-hard cock, a sharp moan escaping her lips, hands resting on his chest, nails grazing lightly, igniting sparks.

“Picture this,” Dana began, her voice low and cruel, grinding softly, her pussy lips teasing his cock, sending electric jolts through his body. “It’s Anna’s birthday, right here in the house, a big party, balloons floating, cake on the table, presents stacked high, Anna beaming, thinking she’s the star of the night. Bella and Chloe are toasting her, friends laughing, music pulsing, everyone caught up in the celebration, completely clueless. You and I sneak upstairs to Anna’s bedroom, her bed covered in her favorite quilt, her pillows soft, her scent lingering in the air. I’m naked, spread wide on her bed, my pussy dripping for you, so much better than Anna’s pathetic attempts at pleasing you. You call her useless, a terrible lover who can’t satisfy you, while you fuck me, your cock slamming into me, my pussy gripping you tight, Anna downstairs cutting her birthday cake, no idea you’re fucking me in her bed, on her special day, her trust a fucking mockery.”

Alex’s cock hardened swiftly, her sadistic fantasy stoking a fire in his gut, his hands gripping her hips, pulling her closer, her pussy grinding harder, her moan sharper, her words weaving a poisonous spell. “Fuck, Dana,” he rasped, his voice thick with arousal, “that’s… so cruel.” She smirked, her eyes wild with excitement, leaning in, her small breasts pressing against his chest, lips grazing his ear, her grinding relentless, her pussy soaking his lap through the thin barrier of their skin. “It gets worse,” she hissed, her voice a cruel purr, her breath hot against his skin, making his cock throb painfully. “You fuck me hard, spank my ass on her bed, say Anna’s pathetic in bed, make me cum while she’s blowing out her candles, her birthday ruined without her knowing. I’m screaming, biting her pillow to stay quiet, your cock so deep it’s stretching me, and then you cum, your hot load flooding my pussy, dripping onto her sheets, staining her quilt, no one suspecting a thing. I leave my cum-soaked thong under her pillow, a little gift she’ll find later, confused, while you watch, knowing I’m better, fucking me in her sacred space, her trust shattered.”

His cock ached, precum leaking into his briefs, her fantasy so vicious it drove him wild, his hands sliding under her sports bra, squeezing her small breasts, thumbs flicking her nipples, her moan sharp and needy, her pussy grinding faster, her eyes locked on his, a silent challenge. “Keep going,” he growled, his fingers digging into her skin, her breasts bouncing with each roll of her hips, her words searing into his mind like a brand. “You fuck me raw,” Dana continued, her voice intense with desire, grinding faster, her pussy sliding along his cock, coating him in her wetness. “You pinch my nipples on her bed, call her useless, make me cum again while Bella sings happy birthday downstairs, no idea I’m better, taking your cock. We’re so close to getting caught, Anna’s voice carrying up the stairs, but you keep fucking, your cum filling me, dripping onto her mattress, staining it, me smirking at her party later, your load still warm inside me, her never knowing.”

Alex’s cock ached, the fantasy pushing him to the brink, his hands yanking her up, positioning her so her pussy hovered over his cock, dripping, ready, her juices glistening in the lamplight. “Fuck, Dana, you’re killing me,” he groaned, his voice rough with need, pulling her down, his cock sliding into her tight, wet pussy, her scream muffled against his shoulder, her small breasts bouncing, nails raking his back with a **** edge. “Ride me, better than Anna,” he snarled, hands gripping her ass, guiding her movements, her pussy clenching, juices soaking his lap, her moans cruel as she rode him, her fantasy still spilling from her swollen lips. “You’ll fuck me there, Alex, call her pathetic, cum in me while Anna’s celebrating her birthday downstairs,” she gasped, her hips slamming down, pussy gripping his cock with every thrust, her eyes wild, her kink driving her to the edge.

The fantasy, her pussy, her kink overwhelmed him, the image—her pussy milking him, Anna celebrating below—sealing his resolve. “I’ll do it,” he growled, his voice rough with determination, hands squeezing her small breasts, thumbs flicking her nipples, “I’ll fuck you behind Anna’s back, make that fantasy real, better than her.” Her moan was triumphant, her pussy pulsing, riding him harder, breasts bouncing wildly, nails digging into his shoulders, leaving red marks that stung. “Yes, fuck me, make me cum,” she begged, her hips slamming down, pussy gushing, her orgasm building fast. He thrust up, meeting her rhythm, his cock slamming deep, snarling, “Cum for me, better than Anna,” fingers diving to her clit, rubbing furiously, her scream choked, pussy squirting, soaking his lap, her orgasm shattering through her, body convulsing, thighs trembling.

Her pussy milked his cock, her kink ablaze, moans **** as she rode through her climax. “Cum in me, Alex, prove I’m better,” she gasped, hips grinding, body shaking with need. His orgasm surged, cock erupting, flooding her pussy with thick, hot cum, his groan low and guttural, her cunt clenching to drain every drop. They collapsed, sweat-slick, her pussy leaking his load, breaths ragged, her smirk intense, eyes gleaming with satisfaction, her fantasy now a shared promise.

“That birthday… we’ll make it real,” Alex panted, his cock still twitching, mind reeling from the intensity of her fantasy, Anna’s degradation a cruel thrill that had pushed him to agree. He stood, pulling on his jeans, heart thundering, the weight of his betrayal heavy, but his promise firm. “I’ll fulfill it, Dana,” he rasped, zipping up, his eyes lingering on her glistening body, her pussy still dripping his cum. She stretched languidly, her smile intense, fingers trailing over her thighs. “Good, Alex. Keep me as the better lover.” He nodded, throat tight, and slipped out, crossing the silent hallway to Anna’s room. Her snores were faint, her bed empty in the dimness, the sheets cool. He lay down, her scent faint, his mind a turbulent swirl of guilt, lust, and the searing image of Dana’s fantasy, his cock already craving more.

What next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)