Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 4 by namenotfound namenotfound

Which do you choose?

Cum in her ass

As much as you were loving the blow job, the thought of cumming in her ass is overwhelmingly intriguing. Amy makes your decision even easier as you watch her spread her ass cheeks apart, fully exposing her hole.

“Yes please.” You say, the words just pop out of your mouth.

“Oh! so polite.” Amy says with a giggle. “Now keep being a nice boy and fuck me in the ass!”

You don’t need any more convincing. You quickly move in, placing one hand on her hip and lining up your cock with the other. You press the tip gently against her hole and start lightly wedging it in.

“Don’t worry, I’m not fragile. Shove it in me!” Amy says.

You get the feeling Amy is just as horny as you are, so you’re happy to follow her orders. With one strong thrust of your hips, you’re soon deep inside of her.

“Oooh!” Amy moans as you feel your balls smack against her cage.

You begin pulling back, fully feeling the tightness around your cock as it slowly slides out, the feeling is amazing. You pull far enough back that you are almost out, so you immediately slam back in.

“Oh God!”Amy gasps. You place your other hand on her side, holding her firmly. She moves her hands in front of her and bends even more, her hands now on the ground. You’re impressed by her flexibility.

You use this position as an opportunity to pick up the pace. With control of her hips you begin rhythmically thrusting in and out of her. You feel her clenching harder on your cock each time you pull back, this drives your crazy.

“Oooh!” a moan escapes your lips.

“Yeah, baby!” Amy shouts “Don’t hold back, cum in my ass!”

You start wildly thrusting, slamming deeper and faster into her. You feel yourself getting closer and closer. You notice Amy’s moans and screams getting louder. With one more thrust in, you feel yourself explode.

“OOOOh!” You groan, as you feel your cock spewing inside of her.

“Yeah, baby. Fill me!” Amy says as she wriggles her ass around your cock.

Amy clenches, making it harder to pull out, but you eventually do, exiting with a wet sounding pop!

“How was that?” Amy ask as she stands up, allowing her skirt to fall back down. You watch as a small amount of cum trickles down her leg, this doesn’t seem to bother her.

“Amazing!” You say, unable to think of any other words.

“Excellent!” Amy says gleefully. She suddenly wraps around you, embracing you in a kiss. The two of you begin aggressively making out as Amy begins to step back, eventually pulling the both of you on to the couch. After some shifting you end up on your back, with her on top of you. The two of you go back to making out as she begins to lightly grind against you.

“You’re going to make me ready to go again.” You say as you feel your cock twitching already.

“That’s the plan!” She says as she begins kissing your neck. You quickly start understanding her eagerness.

“You didn’t cum, did you?.” You ask. Amy stops kissing and looks at you sweetly.

“So close, but no.” She answers “But it’s okay, I’ll get there next time.” With that she moves her hand down to your limp cock and begins lightly stroking it.

“You’re so sweet to care though.” She says smiling warmly. “You know, you kind of remind me of me.”

“Oh yeah? Why is that?” You ask, You’re shocked by how quickly you’re getting hard again.

“Just that you’re nice, and eager, and excited to try new things.” Amy says, griping on to you tightly. “I guess Olivia has a type.”

You’re fully hard again, you didn’t know it was possible to bounce back so quickly. Her words, however, suddenly hit you.

“What do you mean?” You ask. You’re intrigued by the conversation but the feeling in your crotch is fighting for your attention.

“I used to be Olivia’s boyfriend, before she helped me become Amy.” She says, speeding up her stroking. “You seem ready again, want to go back into my ass?”

You have questions about what she just said, but you also really do want to dive back in.

Do you ask follow up questions or go back to fucking?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)