Constance Makes the Decision for Her

[This chapter was commissioned by brain66 as part of the Chapter Of Your Choice reward on Patreon. Thank you for your support!]

Her eyes still closed, Emily inched closer to Alice's damp folds, slightly tilting her head back and inhaling the mesmerizing scent.

It's so different... intense..., the squatting girl thought, comparing the heady fragrance with her own aroma which she had tasted a few hours ago.

"Go on! We don't have all day!" Constance sighed, grabbed the back of Emily's head and pushed her chin between Alice's thighs.

"Mmph!" the light blonde protested, moaning against the other girl's pussy and sending soft vibrations through it.

"Mmmh!" the teal-haired squealed, turned her inner thighs slightly outward and pushed her pelvis forward, lustfully rubbing her soaked labia against Emily's lips.

"Hurry up! Lick her!" Constance whispered into the squatting girl's ear, "Or you're not going to make her cum in time!"

Make her cum? Emily panicked with widened eyes and braced herself against Alice's thighs.

Wait... noo...! she wanted to protest but with her nose pressed against the other girl's pubic bone it rather sounded like a sensual, longing moan, "Mmh-nnh!"

Unable to breathe, the squatting girl pushed herself a half inch back and inhaled deeply through mouth and nose, taking in the intoxicating scent of Alice's pussy. Slightly distracted by the intense fragrance, Emily forgot about her resistance and suddenly found her face pressed against the naked crotch in front of her once again, involuntary kissing the other girl's dripping wet vagina with her half-open mouth.

"Nnnh!" Emily complained as she tasted Alice's pussy juice, and quickly closed her lips.

Sourer, less salty, and somewhat... sweet? the squatting girl was confused, Why doesn't she taste like me?

"Come on! Lick her slit!" Constance whispered in a low voice but the light blonde was too deep in thoughts to notice her.

It can't be sweet, can it? Emily doubted her gustatory sense.

Hesitantly, the light blonde pushed her tongue out, slid it between Alice's delicate pussy lips and traced them until she reached her hard clit.

"MMH!" the teal-haired girl squealed in delight and her body twitched from the intimate touch.

It's... it's sweet... that can't be! Emily couldn't believe it and tried it again, coaxing another longing moan from her classmate.

"Seems like that's not your first pussy," Constance giggled, "I never imagined you'd be queer!"

Suddenly aware of what she was doing, the light blonde broke away from Alice's crotch and hissed at the pale-faced girl, "I'm not a—"

Click! Constance's smartphone cut Emily short and left her staring open-mouthed into the camera lens.

"What...? Have... you...?" she looked like a deer in the headlights.

"Just a little, private memento...," the pale-faced goth smirked, "Don't worry, I won't show it to anyone..."

"Please... don't stop...," Alice whined, stroked Emily's head with trembling fingers and gently pushed her towards her naked crotch.

"Oh well, I might show it Rick...," Constance corrected herself and let out a low moan, "He'll fuck me senseless when I tell him what I made you do!"

"What? Noo!" the butt naked girl complained.

"This isn't a negotiation...," Constance chuckled before adding in a deadly serious tone, "But if you don't start right away, I'll make sure that everyone gets a copy of that."

"W-what...?" Emily gasped and visualized herself standing at her locker and getting hit on by a bull dyke while some cheerleaders point at her, giggling.

"Hm... who should be the first...?" the skinny goth girl murmured thoughtfully before an impish smile lit up her face, "Oh! Did you know that I gave Jason extra lessons in Chemistry? I'm sure I still have his number..."

Jason!!! Emily thought, her heart racing and her eyes popping open, He won't ever date me if he thinks I'm into girls!

"Hey... no... wait... I...," she gasped, cast a quick glance at Alice's glistening wet slit and whispered meekly, "I'll... I'll do it..."

"Um... what are you whispering about?" the teal-haired murmured sheepishly, looking down at the other girls and gently stroking Emily's blonde hair.

"Um... well... I...," the squatting girl hemmed and hawed before Constance helped her out.

"Nothing...," the goth girl waved dismissively, "She just told me that she's never tasted such a delicious pussy before."

"I... I haven't...," Emily wanted to put the statement straight, involuntarily glancing up to check Alice's reaction.

As their eyes met, both girls blushed a deep red and the light blonde didn't dare to speak out the truth, I haven't tasted any other pussy before...

"You can cuddle later! Now, lick her!" Constance whispered and pushed the squatting girl forward.

"Eek!" Emily squeaked but was even somewhat relieved as her hot face got buried in the other girl's crotch.

"Just imagine it's Jason's pu—" the skinny goth breathed but stopped mid-sentence and smirked, "Oh... I forgot..."

Hearing the name of her crush reminded Emily of the picture which would falsely out her as a lesbian and made her eyes pop open. Swallowing hard, she didn't hesitate, opened her mouth and started licking Alice's wet pussy.

"MH-mmh!" the teal-haired girl moaned and tensed up as the tip of Emily's tongue reached her hard clit.

"That's it!" Constance grinned amusedly, "Make her wet!"

Wet? the light blonde thought as her mouth and chin was already coated with pussy juice, She's fucking dripping!

"Mmh... oh Em...," Alice breathed, yearningly stroking Emily's smooth hair, "Suck me!"

Just let's get it over with quickly! the butt-naked, squatting teen thought, slightly intoxicated by the intense fragrance and taste of the teal-haired girl's sex.

Not having any experience in licking pussy, Emily tried to remember and imitate Alice's tongue and listened to the other girl's stifled moans and breathed instructions.

"Oh Em... right there... MH! Not so... oh-mmh...," the frenched girl gasped, slipped out of her shoe and tried to pull her foot out of her pants to give her lover more room between her thighs.

"Yes... suck her, Little Ms. Pussy Eater!" Constance smiled, her fingertips slowly tracing down the light blonde's spine and sending several shivers through the naked girl's body.

The skinny goth girl's scrawny finger slid along Emily's butt crack, stroked over the spread open asshole, and finally reached the squatting girl's wet snatch.

"You. Little. Slut! You're wet like a bitch in heat!" Constance teased before her fingertips found Emily's rock-hard clit.

"Nh-OUH!" the light blonde moaned into Alice's pussy, suddenly realizing that she was soaking wet, Why am I so fucking horny? I'm not into girls at all... am I?

"Oh, yes...!" the teal-haired gasped, pulling Emily's head tightly against her crotch.

Wait! No! Don't make me... don't make me...! the light blonde thought and let out a relieved sigh as Constance pulled her fingertip a half inch back, even though she pushed her long, sharp-nailed middle finger all the way into her dripping wet pussy.

"Holy shit! You're so wet!" the skinny goth gasped amusedly, slowly fucking the light blonde, "Do you even feel my finger?"

"Mmh!" Emily complained and even though she was unable to concentrate on pleasing Alice, the teal-haired still enjoyed the oral sex.

"Yeah-yeah, I thought so...," Constance sighed and pulled out slowly.

"And you really deserve to feel it...," she added, pushing her long fingernail into the squatting girl's exposed asshole.

WHAT? NO, NOT MY...! Emily panicked and shoved the teal-haired girl away.

"Stop! Stop that!" the light blonde gasped and grabbed Constance's wrist while Alice stumbled back and bumped into the wall.

"Don't be a bad loser or this little vid goes viral!" the skinny goth hissed, her smartphone camera still aiming at Emily's face.

"You... you have... recorded...," the light blonde whispered, her freckled face turning pale.

"Yeah! And if you don't make her cum before the bell, I'll make sure that everyone will get a copy of it!" Constance added in a low voice before turning to Alice, explaining Emily's sudden outburst, "Go sit on the toilet... Emily can't squat anymore or her legs go to sleep."

"Um... oh... sorry... oh-okay...," the pixie-cut girl gasped, her perky tits heaving with every word, and walked into one of the bathroom stalls.

"And you...," Constance whispered to the squatting girl beside her, "Get down on all fours and crawl after her."

I... I can't... I..., Emily was at a loss, her heart pounding in her chest.

Damn, Ashley! Is this what you wanted? the light blonde swallowed her tears and got on her hands and knees, Your sister, butt-naked on all fours, licking a girl's pussy while another girl treats her like a cheap whore!

"Yeah! Shake your ass!" Constance grinned and recorded Emily's swaying ass and exposed snatch until they reached Alice who sat on the toilet, hastily freeing her legs from the remaining clothes.

"And don't forget...," the skinny goth girl smirked and bent down to whisper into Emily's ear, "If she doesn't cum before the bell, Rick won't be the only one who gets to see what a good pussy licker you are!"