Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 10 by poison ink poison ink

What happens next?

Candy may be ditzy, but she's agile.

Finn stood at the opposite side of the lubed-up game mat from nearly-naked Candy, holding the spinner. "Okay.. Since there's only two of us, we'll have to spin for each other, and let's not use the two outer rows of dots. That'll leave four of each color dot and make sure that we don't stay on opposite sides of the mat. Sound good?"

"That makes sense to me," Candy said as she gave him a confident smile and rubbed her hands together in eagerness, the motion making her juicy young melons jiggle in her too-small bra. "Now let's get going, Finn! Spin the arrow!" In her mind, Candy was already making plans of how Andy and her would spend their evening after Finn went to bed early.

"Mmmkay. You're going first, since you're being so pushy," Finn teased as he enjoyed the sight of her jiggling cleavage. He barley glanced down as he spun the spinner arrow, just long looking long enough to stick out his thumb far enough to stop it on the spot he wanted. "Left Hand Red, Candy."

Candy had a little smirk as she stepped toward Finn, crossing around the mat to the red line of dots and bent over, placing her hand on the corner red dot of the four-by-four grid of dots. She knew she wouldn't be able to avoid stepping on the slippery oiled-up mat forever, but she wasn't going to do it any sooner than she had to. Her fingertips still touching the dot, she glanced up to the boy, smiling. "Not too bad of a starting move. You're going to have to better than that to take me down!"

From his position in front of his babysitter, Finn had a great view of her gorgeous bit tits threatening to spill out of her bra cups. His cock was already swelling in his baggy shorts as he grinned back at her. "We haven't even started yet! Just wait til we get to the hard stuff!" He gave the the spinner another flick and then stopped it with his thumb again. "I got Left Foot Green!"

*********************************************

Several spins later, Finn had arranged for himself to be in a prime situation, crouching with both feet on green line dots and his right hand on a yellow dot hand. On each side of his right hand were one of Candy's bare feet and as his gaze followed up the teen's long toned legs, her found that her pink panty-clad ass was just inches from his face. Staring intently at her plump ass cheeks as she adjusted her right hand on the slick, lubed mat, he ran his eyes along the crack of her ass til he saw the thinly covered mound between her thighs. 'Holy fuck,' he though to himself as she tried to make out any details through her panties. 'I've only known this girl for half and hour and I've already got her half-naked and wiggling her ass in my face!'

"Your turn."

Candy's voice roused Finn from his thoughts and he looked around her ass to see that Candy was doing her best to look back at him with an expectant expression. "Oh! Um.. yeah. Sorry!" He grabbed the spinner with his free hand and spun it again. "It's a.. Right Hand Blue!" Actually, the spinner had landed on Right Foot Red, but with Candy in her prone position, he knew she had no way of seeing the spinner. Picking up his hand from the yellow dot, the boy stood up straight and looked down Candy's bare back as she leaned forward. His fingers itched to grab a quick feel of her squeezable ass or maybe to unsnap her over-worked bra strap, but he was too close to winning the game. "Let's see," he said slowly as he moved his eyes from the babysitter's backside to the dots on the mat. "Right Hand.." Slowly reaching to the side of Candy, Finn pushed his hips slightly forward, enough to nudge the rock-hard bulge in his shorts against her thinly covered ass. "Blue..." Leaning forward, he pressed his cock bulge against Candy's peach of an ass more firmly, stifling a moan as he savored the sensation.

Candy's eyes went wide as she felt something thick and hard press to her butt and she tried to look back and see what Finn was pushing up against her. "Finn?" She saw his hand coming down along her side as he reached for the blue dot, and the bulge pushed harder against her soft ass. "You're.. um.." The dim blonde tried to think of a good way to tell him about the grinding bulge, but as she thought, she adjusted her foot and found it slipping along the slick plastic mat. Luckily for her, she found just enough traction to stop herself from falling and pushed her ass back instead, bumping back into Finn's bulge and knocking him off balance. From between her thighs, she could see the boy fall backward onto his butt with a look of shock on his face. "I did it! I won," Candy squealed with joy as she looked back at Finn.

"W-what?" Finn blinked in astonishment as he sat on the carpet, trying to put together what just happened to cause him to lose. "I lost?" He saw the blonde still grinning at him upside-down and then glanced up to her ass still hovering above him before returning to her face. "You pushed me! I was doing okay and you pushed me with your big butt!" He noticed Candy was staring at his lap and he followed her stare to the large tent in his shorts.

"Well.. You were poking me with that," the gorgeous babysitter said as she nodded toward his lap. "You almost made me fall, too!"

"That's not my fault! It always gets hard like that around pretty girls like you!" Finn did his best to keep up his 'innocent' act, as he tried to play on her sympathy. "It's only fair if we get a do-over! Or even best two-out-of-three!" the boy gave Candy a frowny pout as he waited for her answer.

Ass still high in the air, Candy nibbled her lip and tried to decide whether to give Finn another chance to win or tell him no and keep the favor that she had already won.

What happens next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)