Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 11 by carb21 carb21

What happens next? Does Rachel tell you her secret or do you say she already knows? If Rachel spills the beans, do you act surprised or tell her everything you've done?

Both reveal their secrets

"All right, I'll give you a chance. But please don't hate me for it. Even if you change your mind about wanting to date me, I hope we can continue to be friends." Rachel said, then closed her eyes, sighed a little and told you "I have a dick, a big one."

You tried to make a surprised face, but apparently it wasn't convincing enough.

"You don't believe me, do you? But I told you the truth, see for yourself." Rachel said and got up, unbuttoned her pants and pulled them down along with her panties, then stood in front of her with her flaccid cock fully exposed. The expression on her face made it clear that she was very embarrassed.

You looked at her, but after what you'd already done, seeing her dick felt natural enough for you to be unable to act surprised enough to fool her. It was then that you decided to tell everything. You bowed down in front of her and started to beg her forgiveness.

"You do not need to apologize. I already expected that you would change your mind after knowing my secret." Rachel said

"It's not that, in fact I also have a secret and it's much worse than yours, and you're involved in it. Turns out I already knew about your dick." you said

"You already knew? But how? I was pretty sure I was hiding it right." Rachel said

"Well, do you remember that first night we watched and you had a little too much to drink? The next day you asked what happened and I said did you go to your room alone? Turns out I lied. The truth is, you slept in the living room and I carried you to your bedroom. After leaving you in bed I lay there for a while admiring you while you slept and I noticed a bulge growing in your pants, curiosity got the best of me and I pulled your pants down, discovering your secret, and you were already hard. It was a shock at first, but I ended up really interested and ended up touching your cock enough to make you come." you said

"So I was naked why did you undress me? I can't believe you did this to me." Rachel said, shocked and with tears forming in her eyes.

"I know, and I wanted to tell you the truth, but you looked so scared that I couldn't. Turns out I did something worse that is weighing heavily on my conscience. You're going to be mad at me and I think it's perfectly natural to hate me for it, but I can't keep this secret from you any longer. It turns out that I was more attracted to you after learning that you have a dick, but instead of opening up to you I took advantage of your heavy sleep. Every night for the last two months I've broken into your room and sucked your cock while you slept, and to leave no evidence I'd swallow all of your cum when you came." you said

Rachel stared at you with a shocked look, tears already streaming down her face. She reached out and grabbed the first thing she could reach, which happened to be a pillow, and used it to repeatedly hit you with all her might as she said "You... are... the... worst. You... discovered.... my... secret... and... then.... made.... me.... your.... toy.... while.... I.... was.... helpless. I.... hate.... you...., I... never.... want... to... see.... you.... in... front.... of... me.... again." So she threw the pillow with everything already with several torn spots on you and ran to her room, leaving her pants and panties behind.

As much as you expected this kind of reaction from Rachel, you felt terrible afterward. You sat in your seat for a while longer before getting up, picking up the clothes Rachel left behind, and taking slow steps upstairs. The feeling that filled you the most was anger at yourself, for being the only one to blame for this situation. You stopped in front of Rachel's bedroom door, but you could hear that she was crying and you didn't have the courage to go in, so you left her clothes by the door and went to your room.

In your bed, you couldn't remember having a worse night than this one. You were feeling so low that you had a sleepless night. You remembered that what you did was a crime, and you were sure that Rachel would report you to the police, which would guarantee you a good time in jail.

"Serves you right, you deserve to be arrested after what you did to Rachel." you thought to yourself


In the morning you went to breakfast. You had no appetite and just **** food in. While you were eating, you saw Rachel coming down the stairs and called out to her, but she didn't even look at you, she just left quickly through the front door carrying only her shoulder bag.

Without heart, you went to the living room, sat on the sofa and just waited, because soon the police would arrive and take you to jail. However, nobody came.

For three whole days, you had no sign of Rachel when she finally came home, but she was completely avoiding you. She spent very little time at home now, and while she was there, she acted like you didn't exist.

You wanted to be able to get along with Rachel again, but you didn't know how to make it possible. This situation made you barely able to sleep, and the few nights you could sleep were heavy and you had nightmares.

How does the situation evolve? Do you take the initiative to reconnect with ? Does Rachel take the initiative? Is there outside interference?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)