Both, switch Lindsey to the midnight movie

You want them both. This may run you into trouble, but you want to go out with both girls. You decide to switch Lindsey to the midnight movie. You look it up on the web and see that there is a midnight showing of Rocky Horror, complete with stage show. You dial Lindsey on your cell.

"Hello, Jack," she answers. Caller ID, obviously.

"Hi. Sorry about this, but my mom KOed the movie because I have to babysit my little brother. How about we catch the midnight movie at the Riverview? It's Rocky Horror, complete with the stage show." How easy the lie comes surprises you.

"Oooo, that sounds great! Why don't you come by as soon as you're done babysitting? I'll be here all night." She sounds upbeat.

"That's great. They should be back in time for me to be over around 10:30 or so." Just enough time to make out or more.

"Cool. I'll see you then."

"Great. Bye."

You hang up. Then you finish getting ready and head over to Amy's house.