Bob

You decide that the thief and sorcerer will complement each other well in staying low key but the paladin will need some help. While Bob plays a very low key paladin, more concerned with doing the right thing than with punishing others for minor transgressions, he doesn't have any skills or abilities that lend themselves to the quiet way. You loan him your hat of disguise, an item you got by default for being cursed to only recreate female forms, and you two come up with a cover story about being traveling companions seeking shelter after a long journey (he likes the story because it is true). The thief and sorc find blending in simple because they have the skills for it and at your level that means they pretty much auto succeed. You find an inn (well, you knew where it was because you have been here before) and purchase a room, reminiscing that when you first got here the silver piece per bed and room seemed excessive but now you can afford to buy the entire inn. Before you can buy 4 private rooms Bob steps in and asks for 2, 2 bedroom rooms and asks about food. It takes you a minute but you realize how good his plan is. Theron will be looking for 4 well off adventurers if you were to return. This way you seem to be 4, 2 men and 2 women.