Betty

That's a face you weren't expecting!

Last time you saw her, she was **** and getting fucked by you.
What a Birthday Present!

"Come in," she says, "My folks are out at a B&B."

You don't catch a glance between Annie and Betty after you pass.

They make small talk together and you all discuss School.

You get more and more nervous around her, knowing that you did stuff to her when she was out.
You didn't know the reason why she was like that at the time.

Finally, Annie speaks up.

"I think he's suffered enough," she says, "Tell him the truth."
You gulp.
"I know you fucked me," Betty explains, "I wasn't ****. I saw them take Maggie away **** and I knew that the story would spread.
When I got you and it was a present, well, I got a bit kinky."

Wait- what?!?

"So you weren't?"
"No."
"And you didn't?"
"No."
"And I just..."
"Yep. Great job, by the way. I was curious how you would handle it."

You don't know where this is going.