Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 40 by Zingiber Zingiber

How does their second figure proceed?

Bernie and Peggy sit their asses down on Samuel and Gary

Gary lay flat on his back as Peggy straddled him. Peggy's face tightened with concentration as she reached a hand back, steadying Gary's cock on target to her anal ring. "Okay, don't do anything. This time I've got it."

It felt nice for Gary having his cock between Peggy's buttocks. Peggy didn't have the curves that Bernie did, but she had plenty of butt, a little round belly, and nice but not super-big breasts. Where Bernie was golden, Peggy was pink, with freckles and tan on her shoulders, arms, and cheeks.

Next to them, Bernie had had an easier time taking Samuel's slim cock. She straddled Samuel, slowly rocking, letting his cock slide in and out of her ass. She moaned gently as she thrust her butt down at Samuel's cock.

Gary smiled. Get it, Bernie. He'd worried it would be hard to watch her with another guy, but it felt so good seeing her pleasure. Take it up your ass. Bernie had taken at least three cocks up her ass -- her cousin Ben's, then Gary's, and now Samuel's. Not to mention a couple of girlfriends' strap-ons, and even her mother Joyce's fingers. Up your ass, Bernie, yeah.

"Okay, got it," Peggy said. She closed her eyes. "Mmmngh!" she groaned. She pressed back at Gary's cock, straining to open her ass, and finally took him in with a fart. "You're big," she said.

"Yeah," Gary said. "You're hot." Peggy's hot insides clasped round the head of his cock. He looked up at Peggy. Sandy's big sister, who had gotten her going at the sex parties before Sandy met Peter. Peggy, free spirit, airbrush artist, tattoo designer, and sex party regular -- at the same parties Gary's mom and dad went to.

While Bernie rocked up and down on Samuel's long brown cock, both of them moaning as Bernie ran the assfuck, Peggy breathed slowly and deeply, relaxing. "Ohhhhh," Peggy sighed, taking Gary deeper. "Whoa." She smiled. "I like it up there, but you are a stretch."

"Can I use my fingers?" Gary asked. Peggy's vulva, waxed smooth from mound down her labia, pouted with pink and swollen lips.

"Please," Peggy said. "Hold out your hand." Peggy checked out his fingernails. "Ha ha, good," she said. "Smooth, short, and clean. Okay." She squirted lube onto his fingertips. "Dig in."

Gary used the advice Bernie and Joyce had given him about getting to know a woman's vulva, how to touch gently, look for her responses, ask if you weren't sure if her sound or motion meant "Good!" or "Nope!"

Gary concentrated on stroking Peggy's vulva, stretching her lips, rolling his thumb over her clit, and feeling her ass tighten on his cock when he made a good stroke. Bit by bit he got Peggy sighing, humming, and starting to rock her pelvis at his touches. He'd almost forgotten the couple next to them.

Until Bernie reached lift-off. Sitting down on Samuel's cock, taking him deep up her ass while she worked her hips round and round, diddling her clit, Bernie tensed up, throwing her head back and screaming her climax out loud.

"Yeah, get it, get it, get it, girl!" Samuel urged. "Oh babe, squeeze that ass, you make me, ahh, FUCK! OHHHH!" Samuel followed her up and over the top, thrusting up at her, his cock shooting deep inside her ass.

Gary kept touching Peggy lightly and steadily, keeping her warm while Samuel and Bernie got off together. In a little bit they settled down. Bernie dismounted and lay on her side. Samuel got up to clean up. Gary got back to business.

There was something timeless about Peggy's snug anal ring around Gary's shaft, her hot ass round his cock head, her gentle rocking and soft moans. He could feel how swollen her lips were, how aroused. Her own moisture came down, making it easy to keep his fingers wet and slippery for her. He worked his way toward concentrating on her clit, taking her higher and higher, while she moaned and rocked. Her brow was damp, the scents of her sweat and her aroused wetness strong in Gary's nostrils. As her ass squeezed on his cock, his cock swelled back, responding.

Peggy squeezed her eyes and mouth closed. Her breath came through her nostrils in quick little pants. "Mmnnmnhh!" she groaned. Her shoulders tensed and her head tilted down, then back. "OH!" she cried out. She rocked her ass up and down on Gary's cock, fucking down on him now. "Oh oh oh oh oh OHHHH!" A pop-pop-sst! of wind escaped her backside.

Gary lay back, his cock throbbing inside Peggy's hot ass as she took her pleasure. Finally she collapsed atop him, her breasts hot and damp against his chest. He circled his arms around her as she lay on him, the aftershocks of her orgasm slowly receding.

A few minutes later, Gary, the last man standing, received his happy ending with the other three each doing their part. Peggy sucked his cock, Samuel lent his own half-hard cock for Gary to suck on, and Bernie tongued Gary's ass. When Bernie sensed Gary was close, she stiffened her tongue, penetrating inside and triggering him to shoot into Peggy's mouth. Peggy hummed happily and Samuel chuckled. "That's my man, Gary, give my lady what she wants."

Do Bernie and Gary find any other regulars? How does their relationship develop?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)