Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 5 by staafje staafje

Where will you fuck her?

Ashley wanted you to fuck her in her tight ass! Your babysitters wish is your command, so .....!.

"But, there is one thing that nobody knows. I'm not using birthcontrol, I mean, ........"

"Ashley, what does that mean? Just say it!"

"I want you to fuck me in the ass, Dave. I want it so bad. Please, I promise you'll like it as much as I do, I mmpphhh..."

I cut her off in mid-sentence with a kiss. I kissed her hard, needing to show her how much I was not upset by what she had said. Inside I still had a part of me that was in joyful shock. I was about to do something I had almost talked myself out of wanting, and now she was asking me to do it. I lost myself in kissing her for a while, but finally she pulled away. "Dave, please. I need you. In the chair, my overnight bag. Please bring it here. Or just reach in, at the bottom you will find a little tube and ..."

"And this?" I said, pulling out a slim golden vibrator. "Don't have a lot of confidence in me, do you?" Even in the dim light I could see her blush.

"Please, it's not ... I mean, look, a smart girl is always prepared!"

"It's ok, I was just kidding. What do you want me to do?"

"Get up on the deck chair behind me, here let me move. Ok, give me goldie. Now take the lube ... oh Dave, I didn't even think. Are you ready?"

"Are you kidding Ashley? I've never been this hard in my life!"

"Ok, then get some of the lube out and rub it .... uh-huh, just like that, oh that feels good. Now put your cock in my pussy and get some of the lube on your thumb. Oh yeah, that's it Dave. Give me that hard cock in my pussy. Now slip your thumb in my ass. Go a little slow ... uh-huh ... push it in. Ummm, god that feels so good. Can you feel your cock in my pussy with your thumb? Push down and feel it. Feel it sliding in and out? Can you feel the ridge through the little wall?"

I could feel it. Could I ever! It felt like there was almost nothing between my thumb and my cock. My thumb was buried in Ashley's wonderful ass, and not only was I getting away with it, she was telling me what to do! I began to move my thumb in and out, timing the motion in unison with the movement of my cock in her pussy. Ashley began to move with me and she started the little gasps like she had done before, so I knew she was enjoying it even though she had stopped talking. We kept doing this for a couple of minutes before my babysitter started telling me the next thing she wanted.

"Ok, Dave, now ease your thumb out slowly and grab the lube again. Pull out of me and put some of it on you. Then put it ... Ohhh, yes right there, up against the hole, now go kinda slow ... uhnnhh, god oh yes, it's ok keep going, slide that big dick into my ass ..."

I worried for a second because it seemed to be hurting her, but when I slowed down more she immediately told me to keep going. As I eased in I felt a little ring of muscle gripping me and as the head of my cock passed it I felt the resistance lessen. At the same time it seemed as though Ashley relaxed a little. "Go ahead, Dave, push it deeper into my asshole. Oh god, that feels so good."

"Doesn't it hurt, Ashley? You always hear that it hurts ..."

"It hurts, but it feels good too. Ok, hold still for a second. Now start moving for me Dave, not too fast or too far ..."

I slowly moved forward as far as I dared and then began to slowly pull back. As I pulled back so that the head of my cock was in danger of being pushed out the feeling intensified and Ashley began to shudder. I could tell that the painful part was centered there, so I pushed back in, going a little deeper this time. "Unh-huh, ok Dave, yes put it all the way in, then slowly pull away, oh god, oh god, Mmmmm, not so fast, wait, wait ... ok now go, uh-huh a little faster ..." Ashley was beginning to move with me, as she seemed to be adjusting. I was lost in the new sensation and in the idea that I was really doing this, the one thing I would never have dared to bring up. "Oh Dave, ok now, don't hold back now, fuck me ... fuck my ass!"

I began to get into it now, just enjoying the feelings and looking down and watching my cock disappear into that gorgeous ass that I had been dreaming about. I put my hands on her cheeks and squeezed them while I moved in and out in an ever-increasing pace. As I watched I knew I could not hold back long. I started trying to think about practice that was coming up or mat problems or anything at all besides the fact that I was fucking Ashley in her tight ass and that she was enjoying it just as much as I was. Ashley began to really moan and breathe hard now and I tried more than ever to concentrate on anything except what I was feeling or the way it looked when I glanced down. I was moving faster now, my neighbor's daughter let her head fall and then I felt her fingers begin to play with both herself and me from underneath.

Just as I was beginning to think I was going to succeed in holding off I heard a buzzing sound and then I felt Ashley the little gold vibrator inside her pussy. As soon as I felt it humming against me through the thin wall of her pussy I knew I would not be able to hold back very much longer. Ashley's back pulsed with a wave of motion from her ass to her shoulders. As it crested over her she screamed. "Oh, fuck yes! Pound my fucking ass! Mmmmhmmm!" I buried my cock in her asshole, lightly at first and then harder as the convulsions and little screams of pleasure continued. I kept at it for a couple of minutes when suddenly she began to pump the vibrator in and out of her pussy and I knew my time was up.

I gave a wordless inarticulate voice to my pleasure as I came into her ass, shoving my cock as deep as it would go and collapsing on top of Ashley. We both fell over sideways and for several moments we just lay there, my last pulses pushing the very depths of my soul out into her. It was many hard deep breaths before I could find any strength to talk. "Oh my god, Ashley. I had no idea. Incredible. I'm sorry it didn't last so long. I couldn't help it, I just had to ..." A nervous rush of excuses and explanations, none of them needed.

"Shhh, be quiet. I'm fine, Dave. Just lay here for a minute. It was long enough. ........ We can spent the rest of the weekend together."

What happens next? First a sleep?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)