Anal, with a bit of deception

"Do you trust me?" I ask.

"Yeah."

"Stay there."

Tommy nods as I walk off to my bedroom. There, I grab my bottle of lube and a butt plug, before returning to Tommy. His eyes light up upon seeing what I'm holding. As I walk forward, I try my best to hide my smile. Poor guy doesn't even know what he's in for, but then again, I doubt he'll be complaining too much once he finds out.

Now in front of him, I go down on my knees and tell him "Spread your legs."

As I lick my lips, he says "I thought you weren't going to rim me?"

"Maybe I've changed my mind."

"You're the best." He rolls his hips back, giving me easy access to his hole.

"Even better than Morgan, Sugar?"

"Only one way to find out."

Out of his view, I pour some lube onto the plug. Then I move it towards his entrance, to which he says "What are you doing?"

Smiling, I reply "You trust me Sugar?"

"You're not gonna put that in?"

"What's wrong with that? It'll feel real good. Trust me Sugar."

"O-okay."

As I press the toy against his entrance, I say "You're not worried about this being gay, are you?"

"No it's just... I've never done anything like this."

"Mhmm, you know I'll make it feel good Sugar."

I continue to swirl the toy around his hole, to which he purrs, betraying his enjoyment.

"Plus, I'll let you fuck my ass again, Sugar."

"Guess I can't say no to that."

"You sure can't, Sugar."

That's when I finally press the plug inside of his ass, to which jolts whilst letting out a moan. His hands dig into my couch as the toy rubs against his prostate. Immediately, he knows he's made the right choice, rolling his eyes as he looks to the roof.

"Ohh fuck." He moans, right as the toy makes it all the way inside of him.

"Told ya it'd feel good, Sugar."

With a smile, he looks down to me. "Oh it feels so fucking good."

"Mhmm. Now how about you come with me to the bedroom?"