An Unconvincing Answer

"....please put it in me," Sue says, "Just don't put it in Ann."
"Do you really want it," I ask, "Or do you just not want me to put it up her ass."
"Just put it in me please."
"Should I put it up your ass?"
"...put it in my pussy please."

A take a look over at Ann. She is visibly biting her lip as this whole thing goes on. She can't muster the strength to stand up to me. To test her, I walk over towards her and tap her on the head to get her attention.

"Do you have something to say?"
".....y-yes," Ann mutters.
"Oh, you do? What is it?"
"...please put it in me, not Sue."
"No," Sue shouts, "I can take it. Don't do that."
"I want it. Really!"

I put the voice changer to my lips and laugh very loudly. Loud enough to bother them.

"I can't believe what I'm hearing. When I came in, you were begging me to let you out. Now, you're fighting over who gets this dildo that has been in your friend's mouth. You really are whores, aren't you?"
"No, we're not," says Sue
"Actions speak louder than words, slut. I mean," I pause to take a few steps to the side, so I can see her lower half clearly, "You're the one that's all wet. Your little friend had all the dildos in her, so you don't have that as an excuse."
"...it's...not what you think," Ann says in her friend's defense, "We didn't get like this on purpose. We were tricked by our friends Heather and Amanda."

I say nothing to test her resolve.

"Honest," she continues, "It was a really mean prank they played on us."
"How did your friend 'accidentally' lay down with her face in front of her pussy" Or the other one get spread eagle in the nude?"
"It's...a long story..."
"I don't see you going anywhere right now. And I locked the doors from the inside. Your call sounded suspicious, so I covered my ass just in case."

She hesitates and gives her cuffs a little pull just in case. Quickly, Ann gives in and begins to speak again.

"Well....we were drunk. It turns out that we were the only three who were actually drinking ****. This whole thing was part of a setup to embarrass us."
"Your friends are clearly quite good at what they do," I say with sarcasm.
"Don't you even...," Sue starts to say.

Seeing that some of her training has been forgotten, I give another firm slap on her ass cheeks.

"Do that again and your asshole will be quite full."

For added effect, I slap the wet dildo lightly against her cheeks.

"Continue," I say to Ann.
"....Anyways, they got us loose and started to play some dirty games with us. Jen wasn't with me and Sue at the time. They got to her first," she says.
"Don't be shy, Jen. Tell me what happened to you. Unless you want your 'mouthpiece' back."
"I...I've had a crush on Heather for a while. In my **** state, she started to make some passes at me. She led me up here and told me how sexy she thought I was. She convinced me to...model for her...in the nude."
"And she got you onto the bed with just her words?"
"....well, she did kiss me too..."

She stops talking for a while and lowers her head in shame just a little.

"Jen, you're lying her nude handcuffed to a bed. Not one, but TWO dildos are in your private parts," I say with a very direct tone, "And we can't forget the chain going from your nipple rings to the bed-frame. So don't stop now."
"....She got me to lay spread-eagle and started to tell me about a fantasy of hers," Jen continues, "She said I'd be even sexier if I let her handcuff me to the bed. That way...she could play with me and I couldn't...resist."
"And that excited you, I bet."
"...Very much. I was fully immobilized when Sue and Ann came in with some other girls from the party, including Amanda."
"Why did you two come up? with an audience, no less."

Their shyness struck them like it did to Jen. To push them, I took the still-wet dildo and tapped it against Ann's face.

"Open up or it goes in your ass," I tell her harshly.

As meek as she was, she complied and I put the phallus into her mouth. Reaching into my bag, I pulled out some tape and put some over her lips to keep it in.

"Your friend can't talk now," I told Sue, "You continue the story. Unless you want me to use one of the other dildos that Jen has. Your ass is inviting."