Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 5 by claustrophobia claustrophobia

What's next?

Amy gets double teamed for the first time

After that, all hell breaks loose. The best kind of hell.

Your hands are all over her, caressing her sexy, firm ass, rubbing her tits, sliding down her flat stomach. So are his, and your sweet, demure girlfriend moans loudly as her hot body is mauled by both of you. She is kissing you and then she is kissing him and when your fingers find her pussy, it is warm and sticky. She cries out when you push a finger up inside of her and you know, in spite of her hesitations and concerns, that she is very turned on.

You make eye contact with the man who is feeling up Amy with you. When you speak, it is to him, but your words are really meant for her.

"I think my girlfriend should suck both our cocks now."

He nods. "Yes, that sounds like a good idea."

The two of you sit on the couch next to each other. He starts to unzip his pants but you say, "No, let her do it." You stare up into her eyes, intently holding her gaze.

She trembles slightly, standing naked in front of both of you. Then she lowers herself to her knees. You can see the hesitation on her face, the uncertainty, but she reaches out her hands to your zipper.

"Him first," you say, the words coming out harsh. Her hands shake but she moves to the man sitting next to you and unzips him, reaches inside, and extracts his cock from his underwear. She gulps hard when it juts out of his pants. You watch, seeing your pretty girlfriend holding another man's cock, her face inches away from it. She looks up at you and holds your gaze as she begins to lick his head.

"Oh, fuck yes," he groans, leaning back, closing his eyes. Her tongue slides all over his cockhead, down his shaft, but she keeps her eyes on you. As you watch, she opens her mouth and takes him inside. He groans louder, opens his eyes to look at the sexy girl sucking him, and reaches out his hands to hold her hair. She blows him in a slow, even motion, sliding her face up and down, watching you the entire time. Then she takes him out of her mouth, his cock all shiny wet with her spit, and rubs him against her pretty face.

"Is this what you want?" she asks you in a whisper, as she smears his wet cock against her cheeks. "You want me to be a whore like this?"

You nod, saying nothing, your eyes blazing, your cock aching. The older man laughs, gives you a brotherly punch on the shoulder. "Damn, you got a good girl here, man."

Amy lets go of him and he casually strokes himself as she moves her wet fingers to your crotch, unzipping, reaching in, tugging your erect cock out. She puts you in her mouth and you hold her head as she bobs up and down, wet squelching noises filling the room as she works you deeper and deeper. After several minutes, she comes up for air and he reaches for her face, pulling it down on his cock.

Back and forth she goes, sucking him then sucking you, on her knees in front of you both. Like a ****, you think, a toy. Your very own fucktoy. You close your eyes the next time her mouth is on you and imagine a long line of men waiting to get at her mouth.

When she comes up for air the next time, her drool coating her chin and dribbling onto her tits, she reaches her hands out to stroke both your cocks, jerking them slowly. Her eyes are wild and you can smell her cunt. She may be hating this, but she is also enjoying it, very, very much.

He glances over at you, understanding fully that you are in charge here. "Can I fuck her?"

"Of course," you say, still looking into her face. "Isn't that right, Amy?"

"Yes," she says, her voice breathy. "I am a whore who needs to be fucked."

Jesus, that turns you on to hear. The man too, judging from how quickly he hops off the couch and gets behind her. He yanks down his pants and briefs and steps out of them, which seems like a good idea. You pull yours down enough to give Amy access to your swollen balls. She was never all that keen on sucking on them before, but what she enjoys or doesn't enjoy is no longer of concern to you.

Amy's face scrunches together as he thrusts up inside of her and you are treated for the first time to the sight of another man fucking your girlfriend. He grabs her hair and holds it like reins, which you like to see, pulling her head back as he begins to move in and out of her. She is gasping with each thrust. He isn't being exactly gentle with her, but he's not being rough either.

You say to him, "You can fuck her as hard as you want. She's a gangbang whore, she can handle it. Isn't that right, Amy?"

She gives you a look of pure hatred, then catches herself and softens her features. She knows she has to do whatever it takes to keep you.

"Yes," she cries out as he rams up into her. "Fuck this little whore so hard!"

Her eyes tear up as he yanks on her hair, as he drives himself deeper into her, as he pummels her pussy with punishing strokes. She stares at you with her wet, blue eyes and you stare back. Then you lurch up off the couch and press your erection against her face. She opens her mouth passively and lets you push yourself inside, lets you fuck her face as he's fucking her cunt.

Amy keeps herself propped up on knees and elbows as you and him ride her. She maintains her balance and you both do all the rest, using her body, fucking her holes, making her yours. He yanks her hair and you hold her face, as he slams himself in and out of her pussy and you **** yourself down her throat.

You pull out and she gasps breathlessly, spilling a throatful of saliva all over herself and the carpet. As he continues to hammer away at her, you rub your balls in her mouth and order her to suck on them. She whines a little but does as you command her, licking and sucking them. It feels heavenly and you know you are very close to cumming. Then you hear him, his grunting getting faster and higher pitched. As he buries himself deep inside of your girlfriend with a cry that signals his orgasm, you jerk your cock and spew your load in her face.

What's next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)