Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 14

OMG! Who is it?

Amy's boyfriend

Oh my god! You look up and see it is Amy’s boyfriend, Joe, who has just walked in on the two of you fucking like there’s no tomorrow. He looks at you ass fucking his girlfriend but his face is blank, expressionless. You’re not sure what to do, so you just keep right on pounding Amy’s hot pussy. Then he smiles at you, then at Amy.

“Hey, Amy, just thought I’d drop by and see what you’re doing this afternoon. I was thinking maybe we could go get an ice cream or something.”

“Oh, I’d love to, Joe,” Amy answers between breaths as she keeps slamming her ass back against your groin as you plunge deeper and deeper into her depths. “But it’ll probably be a few minutes yet.” She looks over her shoulder at you and grins. “I wasn’t expecting him but John showed up and wanted to fuck me and I couldn’t turn down a chance to fuck him. But we should be done soon.”

Joe looks up at you like he’s noticing you for the first time. “Oh, hey, John,” he says casually. “How’s it been hanging, man?”

“Hey, Joe,” you reply between grunts. “Not too bad I guess, just hanging out, kinda bored since graduating I guess.” You pull your cock out of Amy’s pussy and slam it hard back into her asshole causing her to scream a little. “I just figured I’d come back and hang around campus for a bit, see some old friends and stuff. I was glad to find Amy was in her room, it’s been a while since I fucked her.”

“Yeah, I totally understand, man,” Joe replies, watching me fuck the shit out of his girlfriend as if it was totally normal. Which apparently it is now. “I mean, it was like we had basketball practice today, but then after that it was like what is there to do now, you know? I mean like this probably isn’t the most exciting school out there. So I figured I could at least do something with Amy, like go get some ice cream or something, you know?”

“Sure, Joe, I totally understand,” you grin as you move one hand off Amy’s ass to squeeze a tit. “This is kind of a boring town. And just imagine if you’re not in school any more. Man, I’ve been going crazy just playing video games and not fucking any girls. So I like just had to come out here today.”

You slap Amy’s ass hard and she screams and moans at the same time, if that’s possible. Then you take your other hand off her ass and reach up and grab a fistful of her hair and pull her head back. This causes he ass canal to squeeze even tighter around your pumping dick.

“Oh, god, yeah, Amy,” you roar. “That feels so fucking good. I’m going to cum in your ass, baby, are you ready for that?” You pull her hair harder until she is almost upright on her knees and maul her boobs with your free hand.

“Oh, fuck, John. Oh fuck, fuck, fuck,” she can hardly speak. “Oh yes, fuck my fucking ass, John! Fucking dump your cum in my fucking ass,” she pleads loudly.

“Oh you know I will, girlfriend,” you assure her as you let go of her hair and slam three fingers up her dripping cunt. I’m almost there, you ready too, girlfriend?”

“Oh fuck yes, John,” Amy practically screams. “I’m cumming, John, I’m cumming for you, baby!”

Her pussy clenches around your fingers in her vagina and her ass canal tightens around your cock. That’s all it takes for you to explode with a huge load deep inside her back door. You both thrash wildly against each other as you rock and roll through your simultaneous orgasms.

You realize as you start coming back to your senses that Joe is still talking to you. Does it get any weirder, you think?

“So anyway, I was planning to go Friday night and bring Amy with me too. You think you’re going to be there?”

Amy’s eyes have rolled all the way back into her head as she collapses on the bed beneath you. You try to recover your senses and make polite conversation like you’re apparently supposed to do.

“Friday?” you ask Joe, while you are pulled down on the bed on top of Amy, your cock locked in her asshole like dogs. “Um, yeah, I guess,” not quite sure what he’s talking about. “You mean the party?” you ask trying to ferret out the information.

“Yeah, dude, the party at Chris’ house, you know? It’s going to be a big one. I’m sure there’ll be a lot of hot chicks there for you to fuck.”

“Oh, yeah, sure,” you vaguely remember. “Sure, I’ll probably be there. So you and Amy going to be there too?”

“Oh yeah, we wouldn’t miss it,” Joe grins. “She’ll probably want to fuck you again anyway.”

“Yeah, Amy is really a great fuck, Joe,” you tell him while squeezing her naked body beneath you and kissing her on her cheeks trying to bring her back to earth. “I’m sure you must enjoy the hell out of her too.”

“What?” Joe acts incredulous. “Oh no, I’ve never fucked Amy, man. I mean, that just wouldn’t be right, you know? I mean, after all she is my girlfriend, you know?”

“Oh yeah, right,” you answer, still trying to comprehend your new reality. “Sure, man, that’s cool.”

Amy starts to move under you so you sit up and help her to a sitting position too. You both sit there and just look at Joe, both still glassy eyed. She leans over and gives you a kiss on the cheek.

“Oh god, John, that was fantastic,” she smiles at you. “It’s been a while since you fucked me that good. I sure am glad you decided to come by.”

“Any time, babe,” you smile back at her. “So I guess I’ll see you Friday night then, at least.”

She looks momentarily confused, then replies. “Oh yeah, the party. Sure, we’ll definitely be there. I’ll look for you. You better save some of that manjuice for me before you fuck all the other girls there, ok?”

“Sure, Amy, you know I will,” you assure her. “You know you’re one of my favorites.” You give her a big tight hug and stand back up. “Well, I better be moving on,” you say. “So you guys can go get your ice cream. It was sure was great hooking up with you again, Amy. Good to see you, Joe.”

Amy stands up too and you give her another tight hug then turn and shake Joe’s hand.

“Good to see you again, bud,” you slap his back. “See you Friday, I guess, ok?”

“Sure, man, Friday,” he smiles.

You head out of Amy’s room and into the hall, still a little dazed from the awesome sex with Amy while her boyfriend watched you. Yeah, this sure as hell was turning out to be a pretty good world, you think, smiling to yourself on the inside. You wonder what you can get into next, or rather, who you can get into.

So what’s your next adventure?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)