Alicia

Erica reluctantly let go of my dick and looked at me in disappointment. “Sorry Erica. Alicia was my date today so she gets to go first.”

Erica pouted but nodded in understanding and I knelt down to kiss Alicia. Alicia responded with enthusiasm but I could feel a bit of hesitation.

“This’ll only hurt in the beginning I promise,” I told her. She wrapped her hands around my back and propped her legs up on either side of me. She bit her hip and nodded.

I gripped my member and slid it up and down her slit, making her gasp. Slowly, my cockhead parted her fold and entered. I watched her face scrunch up in pain as I stretched her walls. When I hit her hymen, I gave her a brief moment to adjust and then pushed, breaking it and making her scream. I quickly silenced her with a kiss and held it until she calmed down. When I pulled back, tears were beginning to form in her eyes.

“In a few strokes, the pain will disappear and your vagina will stretch to fit me perfectly,” I told her.

Upon hearing that, I felt her relax around me and I started pumping slowly giving her time to adjust. True to my word, in a few strokes, the pain vanished from her eyes and she willingly began humping against me, urging me to push further in.

“Go ahead John, fuck me,” she breathed.

“When I push in all the way, you’re going to orgasm hard.”

“God I hope so,” she replied eagerly. Taking my time to enjoy her tight pussy, I pumped into her a few times before plunging all the way in. She eyes immediately rolled back and she tightened her arms around me. Her legs were raised in the air and were shaking as she screamed silently in bliss.

“Watching her orgasm made you so hot,” I told Erica, appreciatively eying her rub her pussy with her hand.

“Oh fuck- that was- Christ John! That was the best orgasm I’ve ever had,” Alicia panted once she calmed down. I gave her a smug grin and brought my head down to grab her tit in my mouth even ay my hands moved down to tightly grab her delicious ass. I started moving and gradually picked up speed, my mouth working to suck her nipples in.

When I said her pussy would fit me perfectly, I didn’t actually think it’d literally be perfect. It was just so damn tight. I moaned on her nipple as I pumped into her incredible cunt. Even as she grunted and moaned in pleasure, I felt a hand on my hair and looked up to see Erica, looking like she was fighting the urge to pull me off Alicia and take me for herself. Well that wouldn’t do.

“It’s unfair to leave you out of the fun isn’t it,” I asked her and stood up on my knees. Alicia let go of my neck and whimpered at the loss of contact. I started thrusting faster to compensate. “Why don’t you kiss Alica while I fuck her?”

Erica bit her lip and looked down at Alica’s face and both of them held eye contact for a few seconds. I held up Alicia’s legs and appreciated her breasts jiggle and rotate with every thrust. Erica seriously looked like she was going to do it before she lifted her eyes to look at me and shook her head.

“I don’t want to do that,” she said, sounding truly apologetic.

“Why,” I asked, freely twisting their sexuality. “Don’t think that I don’t know that you two are bisexual. You’ve always wanted to try fooling around with each other haven’t you?”

Erica’s eyes widened. “Nothing gets past you does it?”

Alicia, who was having trouble forming coherent sentences, simply grabbed Erica by the hair and pulled her down, forcefully locking lips with her. The incredibly erotic sight of their tongues was almost too much for me.

“Are you gonna cum,” Alicia asked me, breaking away from the kiss for a moment. I grit my teeth in frustration. It was too soon. I wanted this to last longer, for her to have one more orgasm at least.

“I’ll cum only when I want to cum,” I sneered. To my amazement, the orgasm I felt building up receded. Oh this was awesome. I was basically the world’s best stud right now.

“Though I can’t believe you two are cumming right now just from kissing.”

Once again, I felt Alicia’s tighten to almost painful levels around me. With their mouths free, both of them let out a primal cry that resounded off the walls. The blonde haired beauty collapsed on top of the girl I was still thrusting into.

I grinned as Alicia went limp under me, having lost all strength with the last orgasm. I gently pulled Erica off her and bent down, placing both my hands on either side of Alicia. Licking my lips at the sight of her exhausted face twitching in pleasure, I picked up my pace and started pumping into her with reckless abandon.

“Jesus- mmm- John stop- oh FUCK! I’m still sensitive!”

“I know,” I told her with a smug smile and continued, not even slowing down a bit. Alica had no choice but to hold on to me for dear life as I crushed her body with mine. The bed creaked violently due to my powerful thrusts and all I could hear from her near my head was ‘Ugh! Ugh! Ugh!’ timed with every creak.

A couple minutes later, Alicia was a sobbing mess as she buried her head in my shoulder to contain her moans. Satisfied with the torment I put her through, I gently bit her ear and spoke.

“I’m- Oh fuck, you’re so tight Alcia- I’m gonna cum now! And you’re gonna come with me! It’s gonna be your biggest one yet!”

With a animalistic grunt, I gave one last thrust and held my dick deep inside her, releasing my first orgasm of the day into her womb. Alicia bit into the base of my neck as a powerful orgasm wracked her body. I barely registered the pain, solely focusing on enjoying the feel of her pussy contracting around my dick as I painted her insides white.

A few seconds later, I pulled out and lied down next to her. Both of us were panting hard and I was content with basking in the afterglow of sex.

I couldn’t believe it. I had just lost my virginity to one of the hottest girls I knew. Even better, she was someone I eagerly lusted after for a long time.

“I guess that’s it for tonight huh?” I heard my other companion say.