A lot!

Saturday dawned bright and blue over the teenage lovers.

{if Cheat with Abigail=true}

Abigail wanted for Matt to wake up with her hand on his chest, the gentle rise and fall of his breathing the only sound. He woke with a start, shaking himself awake in the cool autumn morning.

“Good morning, Matthew,” she said, kissing his jaw.

“Good morning,” he whispered.

They locked into a kiss, tender and sweet, for a long moment.

“I’d ask for round two but you did a number on me,” Abigail whispered with delight.

“I’m sure we can think of something,” Matt said softly.

Abigail wanted him, of course, though her body was giving her a resounding ‘no.’

“What do you have in mind?”

“Let me go down—“ Matt started.

Abigail stopped him. “I am still pretty full of you, so unless you just want a mouthful of that...”

Matt winced playfully. “Okay, maybe not.”

They embraced and another long kiss followed.

“Eventually I’ll be more used to you,” Abigail smiled, “and we can do it all day.”

That made Matt grin.

{endif}

{if In love with Abigail=true}

“You know,” he said, “last time we could do it twice.”

Abigail poked him playfully. “You’re getting greedy, Matthew.”

He flipped her onto her back and lay atop her, pinning her arms above her head.

“You’re naughty, Matthew,” she whimpered, voice cracking with desire.

“You’re not fighting it,” he teased, kissing her neck.

“Be careful, please,” Abigail whispered.

Her resistance fell and he fucked her with long slow strokes. She stared into Matt’s eyes, moaning softly with each soft thrust into her soaking pussy. Her tits rocked as more and more of his immense erection stretched her hole.

“Ma- Matthew!” Abigail muttered as he stroked himself with her tight cunt.

“Abigail,” he growled.

Her sensitive pussy gushed and her first orgasm washed over her body slowly. Abigail’s eyes fluttered, body writhing. It crashed and rolled with each of Matt’s thrust, his massive cock bulging deep inside her petite body.

“Oh god Matthew...” she moaned.

He leaned in and kissed her with desperate heat, bucking his hips into her. The short, shallow thrusts teased the depths of her passage until his finished, groaning into her lips and blasting another thick load inside Abigail. She returned his kiss meekly, energy spent after the many orgasms Matt had gifted to her. As he dumped his seed into her once again she moaned, accepting him eagerly.

“You’re insatiable,” she whispered as he slumped against her well-fucked figure.

“Only because I love you so much,” he whispered back.

{endif}

{if Cheat with Abigail=true}

For a long moment they lay together, a peaceful silence descending onto them. It wouldn’t last. Matt had a date.

Abigail begrudgingly let him go, but not without one last attempt to keep him. It failed and she watched him leave from the front door, her happiness of the night before giving way to a deep sadness that she had to see him leave, made worse by the reason he left at all.

{endif}

{if Chose Lucy}

The morning was cold and Lucy shivered so hard she woke her boyfriend.

“Whoa, good morning,” he said.

“Don’t go anywhere!” she pulled him closer, “It’s freezing.”

“I have to pee!” Matt exclaimed.

“Fine, but don’t take too long, I have some... things to do in there.”

Matt cocked his head playfully, “Oh? What could that be?”

“You put it all there!” She teased. “Now, go pee.”

Matt kissed her and slipped out of the bed, grabbing his pants and his phone on the way out.

—

Matt sat on the toilet and opened his messages.

{if In love with Emily=true}

Emily had sent him several, declarations of love, mostly.

Matt: “Still awake?”

Emily: “Barely :)”

Matt: “How was work?”

Emily: “Blah. I missed you.”

Matt: “I missed you.”

Emily: “I’m looking forward to tomorrow morning, though ;)”

Matt’s eyes shifted. He still wasn’t sure how he would swing that.

Matt: “So am I. It’s been so long :(“

Emily: “I’ll make it worth your while”

Matt: “I know you will”

Emily: “I wanna talk but I’m so tired. I’ll be home around 8 tomorrow, I love you!!”

Matt: “I love you!!”

{endif}

{if In love with Abigail=true}

Abigail had sent him several sad messages. She missed him. She wanted to be his first choice. Matt could read between the lines: he was running out of time to make a choice. Abigail wouldn’t let this happen forever.

He apologized, promising that he loved her and that he would get everything taken care of.

{endif}

Matt returned and Lucy quickly dashed out. He waited for minutes on her bed, rubbing the back of his neck. Dating multiple women wasn’t exactly a cake walk.

Lucy returned with a kiss.

“When does our date start?” she asked.

“Tonight. I need to run home first, get some stuff ready.”

Lucy grinned. “I’m surprised you aren’t trying to fuck me before you go.”

“Would it work?” Matt said, kissing her gently.

“If you were persuasive enough.”

They were interrupted by a knock at the door.

“Lucy! Can you wake up, please? I have things for you to do today,” the teens heard Lucy’s mother call.

“That’s unfortunate,” Lucy said with a smile.

{endif}

—

Matt took a shower as soon as he got home. He still hadn’t really planned his date with Lucy but he would think about that later. He continued to refuse to really consider the implications of his situation.

“A picnic!” Matt said suddenly as he scrubbed his armpits.

It was perfect. He knew a park he could take Lucy for a picnic. He’d prepare the food before he picked her up and then after they’d... hm. He wanted to have her all night, but where would they stay? He pondered a hotel room, but he wasn’t sure he could afford one. It might be worth the cost, though, if he and Lucy could have total privacy.

He jumped from the shower to dry off. He noticed Lucy had messaged him.

Lucy: “Were you planning on us spending the night tonight?”

Matt: “Obviously lol”

Lucy: “Then I had bad news :(

Matt: “What’s up?”

Lucy: “I have a curfew tonight D:”

Matt: “Since when??”

Lucy: “Apparently I’ve been abusing my privileges”

Matt: “That’s stupid. How late?”

Lucy: “Only midnight >:(“

Matt groaned, but at least it didn’t mess up his plan too much. And it might have saved him some money.

Matt: “Wow, lame”

Lucy: “I know. I’m sorry baby”

Matt: “It’s okay! We’ll just have to condense a little. Nbd”

Lucy: “I love you, see you tonight”

—

It was almost time to pick up Lucy. Matt had a basket packed with a number of different sandwiches and some water. He also had time to make a little chocolate cake and, with some spare icing he found in the kitchen, he had crafted a rustic looking treat for dessert. As he packed it carefully in the basket his phone buzzed and he opened it instinctively.

Lucy: “I’m mad at my parents so how slutty can I dress tonight?”

Matt laughed.

Matt: “We’ll be outside lmao”

Lucy: “Bring a blanket, then, I’m already dressed.”

Matt: “Then why even ask? Lmao see you soon, sexy”

—

Matt pulled up to Lucy’s house and she came bounding down the driveway.

Her outfit caught his attention immediately. She wore a long gray coat to her knees that she left unzipped. Beneath was a knitted lace tube top that barely covered her chest and left her stomach completely bare. Even from here he could see there wasn’t a bra beneath it. A short skirt completed the outfit, thin enough to nearly be translucent. Her legs were bare and her feet were wrapped in warm looking brown boots.

Lucy jumped in the car and Matt saw her nipples poking out from her top.

“You weren’t kidding,” he chuckled.

“I have to squeeze a night of sluttiness into one evening,” she said with a hint of frustration.

He kissed her and pulled back into the street. Lucy saw the basket and squealed.

“A picnic!”

Matt nodded to confirm. Lucy threw her arms around his neck and kissed his cheek.

“That’s so fun! Where are we going?”

“Now, now, just wait and see,” Matt said with a grin.

Lucy beamed all the way to the park with her hand in Matt’s. Her good attitude continued outside the car all the way to the small grassy hill that overlooked a pair of tiny ponds surrounded by tall grasses. In between them were a handful of trees and shrubs that disguised the true location of the waterlines. Matt sat them down and opened the basket.

Sandwiches abounded of all kinds and the two teens got right to eat.

“This was a cute idea,” Lucy said in between bites.

“It just came to me,” Matt replied.

Lucy scooted closer to her boyfriend and rested her head on his shoulder. The ate and silently watched the park come alive with kids and pets.

“That could be us, someday,” Lucy said, pointing to a young couple walking a pair of twins.

“You think so?”

Lucy nodded quietly. These thoughts kept filling her head. She hadn’t really been interested in that kind of life until recently.

“Or, that could be us,” Matt pointed to a couple old enough to be their parents shoving each other playfully.

“Let’s get started now,” Lucy teased. She pushed Matt over onto his side.

Matt tumbled with a laugh into the grass and then shot back up as returned the favor, knocking Lucy halfway down the small hill. Matt nearly fell over laughing. She sat up and paused, slowly getting back to her feet.

“I’m not dressed for this!” she shouted.

Before Matt could say anything Lucy was charging back up the hill. She launched herself at Matt, who caught her, and they tumbled backwards. Lucy ended up on top of Matt and used this opportunity to kiss him. He returned it eagerly, holding her on his chest.

“You are dressed for this,” he teased.

“You like it,” Lucy replies, lips lingering against his.

Matt nodded and sat, planting Lucy in his lap.

“Someone’s getting frisky,” Lucy said quietly, “and I like it.”

Matt quipped back, “This is rated PG, the real stuff happens later.”

“Don’t want some stranger’s kids watching?”

Matt shook his head and he let Lucy kiss him again.

“Oh, I have a surprise,” he said suddenly.

Lucy rolled off his lap and Matt dug in the basket. He pulled out the cake and a wide smile appeared on Lucy’s face.

“Did you make that?”

Matt nodded and Lucy exclaimed, “That looks so good!”

Lucy’s smile faded when Matt also pulled a huge chef’s knife from the basket.

“It’s all I could find!” Matt said meekly when Lucy’s face turned.

“You’re going to hurt yourself.”

Matt shook his head dismissively. “You worry too much.”

Except Lucy had worried exactly the right amount. Matt, in his hormonal haze, couldn’t look away from his girlfriend. Her coat was open and her stiff nipples called to him from underneath her top. He could hardly focus on other tasks, like slicing into the cake with the far-too-large knife. He raised his eyebrows as if to say “I got this” but Lucy suddenly gasped, recoiling. That was the moment Matt felt a shooting pain up his arm as the knife bit his finger.

—

The trip to the hospital was eventful. Lucy scooped up the basket and pulled Matt toward the car. He did an okay job of stopping the blood with his shirt but his reassurances didn’t stop Lucy from taking over. There was a delay when Matt tried to drive but Lucy wouldn’t have it. Lucy was a maniacal driver any time but it was worse when her boyfriend was bleeding everywhere in the passenger seat. She pulled into the ER parking lot with squealing tires.

“You’re so stupid,” she muttered as they made their way inside.

“It’s not really bleeding anymore...” he offered.

The waiting game began, made all the more frustrating by Lucy’s curfew hanging over the teens like a cloud. The cut had been bandaged, at least, but unfortunately other patients needed to be seen first.

Eventually, when the sun had long gone down, Matt was given a room.

“Maybe you should have worried?” Lucy asked.

Matt nodded slowly. “Yeah, I’m sorry, I didn’t mean to ruin it like that.”

Lucy took a seat next to him and leaned her head against him. “It’ll be all right.”

Matt, “I think we’d both feel better if you unzipped your coat.”

Lucy giggled. “You hush.”

A knock on the door averted their attention and Lucy’s head released from her boyfriend’s shoulder. It opened and through the door came a familiar face.

“Emily?” Matt blurted.

—

“You know her?” Lucy asked.

“Yeah, she works at the school,” he said.

“Isn’t this a surprise?” Emily said, letting the door swing behind her.

{if In love with Emily=true}

Matt’s heart pounded in his chest. This couldn’t end well. He saw Emily’s gaze linger on Lucy, trying to figure out what the petite teen was doing here.

{endif}

{if In love with Abigail=true}

Emily worked at a hospital, too? Matt was happy to see her again, but this wasn’t a great time. Any fantasy about Emily would be immediately ruined by his girlfriend sitting right next to him.

{endif}

“I didn’t think I’d see you here,” Emily said, sitting at the computer near the empty bed. She pointed to it, “Hop in, please.”

“All right, I’ll just get some vitals real fast and you need to be in a gown.”

Matt had to strip almost naked and he quickly huddled into the blankets. The gown was so thin he was practically freezing. Emily set up an IV and then she was gone with a promise the doctor would return.

Lucy scrolled on her phone idly and then stood, “I’m going to find a vending machine. Will you be okay?”

Matt nodded and she kissed him quick before quietly leaving.

{if In love with Emily=true}

A moment later Emily was back.

“Who’s that?” she demanded.

Matt stared at the busty blonde, shellshocked.

“Oh, that’s my friend. Lucy.”

“Friend?” Emily asked.

“Yeah. She was there when I cut myself.”

Matt tried to look casual and hoped Lucy would take her time coming back.

Emily tapped her foot. Her arms were crossed under her breasts which only made them look larger and make Matt more uncomfortable.

“How many girls are you seeing?” Emily said.

“Just you,” Matt lied.

Emily searched Matt’s eyes. They held the silence for a while.

“Is she going to leave?”

“She has a curfew at midnight.”

“So you won’t tell her to go?” Emil asked.

“That seems rude...” Matt’s voice trailed off.

Emily shrugged, “Yeah, okay, you’re right. Sorry, I... got a little jealous, I guess.”

Matt was thankful Lucy had zipped her coat or this would have been a lot worse.

“Don’t be sorry, I get it. Out of curiosity, how long will I be here?”

“Couple hours, maybe more depending on how serious your cut is,” Emily answered, “But I can stall if you want her out of here.”

Matt considered. “Okay, I’ll think about it.”

Emily turned to go, “I wish you were alone so I could come in here and mess with you.”

Matt smiled, “Me too.”

“Does your friend go to your school?” Emily asked. When Matt nodded she frowned. “Well, shit. Okay. I have other patients but I’ll be back.”

She blew him a kiss and left.

{endif}

{if In love with Abigail=true}

Matt was left by himself, shivering in the cold. Alone with his thoughts wasn’t always a place he liked to be, especially recently. He thought of Abigail and Lucy, of course, but tonight he couldn’t get Emily out of his mind. He figured this must be because she isn’t like the other women in his life. Emily isn’t petite or brunette... or even his age. He could tell she had big breasts but he wanted to see how big they really were. Emily was older, so she must be experienced, right? Someone who knew what felt good and what she wanted.

As Matt went down the mental rabbit hole of fantasies involving Emily the inevitable happened. He felt the familiar surge of heat between his legs and in moments the entire bed was tented with the massive length of Matt’s dick.

“Of course,” he said aloud to no one in particular.

The blanket had fallen up across his chest from the extreme angle so that only the gown remained. It hovered over him, the tie straining behind his neck. Eventually the gown slipped, too, and Matt stared awkwardly at his own monstrous erection.

There was a knock on the door and Matt’s head whirled with horror as Emily walked in.

Emily stopped in her tracks and did a double take, not believing what her eyes reported to her brain. She stammered, searching for a response. The door slowly swung shut as the two froze.

“That’s not real,” she said with a stutter.

Matt didn’t know how to react. His mind was blank.

“Holy... holy shit,” Emily said, swallowing. Matt thought he saw a familiar look in her eye but he couldn’t be sure.

Emily was astounded. She looked at the impossibly huge cock between Matt’s legs, then at Matt. Her jaw hung open and she knew she had to... she had to have it.

“That’s... wow...”

“Sorry,” Matt muttered, “it just kinda... happened.”

“What are you... doing tomorrow?”

“Why...?” Matt asked.

“Just answer me,” Emily demanded.

“Nothing that I can think of.”

Emily wasn’t always easy. She could afford to be picky with men. This, however, was a once in a lifetime opportunity.

“I get off at seven and...” Emily said.

Matt perked up at that. This would be easy! In fact, he thought, if this was all he needed to do to pick up women then life might be pretty good. Of course, he thought of Lucy. Lucy... who was still in the building.

“I...” he sighed, “kind of have plans...”

“The girl with you? Is she your girlfriend?” the blonde nurse asked.

“No,” Matt lied, “just a friend. She was there when this happened.” He held up his bandaged hand.

“Can’t ask her to leave?”

“Seems a little rude, I think...” Matt’s voice trailed off. “Although she has a curfew at midnight.”

Emily grinned. “I could stall and keep you here long enough that she’d have to go?”

It was a good idea, but Matt wasn’t sure if he’d go that far to cheat on his girlfriend... again.

“Can I think about it?”

“Sure,” Emily said, sliding out of the door, “I’ll be back later, anyway.”

As she left Matt looked at his dick. It was slowly shrinking and he couldn’t think about anything sexy right now or it would stand right back up again.

What would he do?

{endif}

—

Lucy was lost. The hospital hallways made no sense and the signs, as plentiful as they were, only helped if she already knew what she was doing. Meyer Wing? Sears-Bach Center? What was that supposed to mean?

When she did find a vending machine and finally acquire a snack it was by accident. And now she has no idea how to get back to the ER. The entire series of detours gave the trip to the hospital a foreboding vibe and she started to suspect something was wrong. She couldn’t identify it, but it was there.

She made it back to Matt’s room his nurse was in there with him.

“Hey, where have you been?” Matt said.

“I got lost.”

The nurse nodded, “It’s such a maze isn’t it?”

Lucy agreed. “So what’s going on? Did I miss something?”

The nurse launched into an explanation but Lucy eyes glazed over. The nurse noticed and tried something else.

“There’s been a lot of high priority patients so the doctors are pretty busy. Unfortunately, Matt might be here a while.”

Lucy turned to Matt, “It’s getting late...”

Matt nodded with a sad smile. “Yeah, that curfew...”

Lucy turned to the nurse, “Is there any chance it’ll be faster?”

“I can try and encourage the process.”

Lucy looked to Matt. “Well, I guess it’s up to you anyway...”

Matt glanced between both women, unsure what to do. He swallowed and said...