Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 19 by Funtimes Funtimes

What's next?

A big step forward in our lives

That night, Sarah and I lie in bed, our bodies still tangled together, the sheets damp beneath us. The afternoon's intensity has mellowed into something deeper, more profound. Her head rests on my chest, my fingers idly tracing patterns on her back.

"I've never felt this way before," I murmur into her hair. "What we have... it's like we've discovered something no one else knows about."

Sarah tilts her face up to mine, her eyes shining in the dim light of our bedroom. "I know. It's like we found a secret door in a house we thought we knew every inch of."

"I can't imagine my life without this," I say, my voice dropping to a whisper. "Without you."

She shifts, propping herself up on one elbow to look at me properly. "I can't either. Everything before you feels like a prelude."

Something swells in my chest, overwhelming and perfect. The words form on my lips before I've even fully processed the thought.

"Let's get married."

The moment hangs between us, suspended in the quiet of our bedroom. I feel suddenly ****, exposed in a way that has nothing to do with our nakedness. But then Sarah's face transforms, lighting up with a joy so pure it takes my breath away.

"Yes!" she exclaims, throwing herself against my chest. "Yes, Liam, yes!"

I wrap my arms around her, relief and happiness flooding through me. "Really? You mean it?"

She pulls back, cupping my face in her hands. "I've never meant anything more in my life."

We kiss, deep and slow, the taste of her mingling with the salt of tears I hadn't realized were falling from my eyes. When we break apart, Sarah's expression shifts slightly, a familiar mischievous glint appearing.

"I can't wait to tell Wiley in our special way..." she says, her voice taking on that sultry edge I've come to recognize.

A complex emotion twists in my gut—jealousy and arousal tangled together like barbed wire. The thought of Sarah sharing our news with Wiley, perhaps while she's naked in his bed, sends conflicting signals through my body.

"You want him to know?" I ask, my voice rougher than I intended.

Sarah traces a finger down my chest. "I want him to know he can have my body sometimes when it fits us, but he'll never have my heart they way you do." She leans closer, her breath warm against my ear. "It belongs to you. It's always belonged to you."

The possessiveness I feel is tempered by something else—a strange, **** recognition that Wiley has become part of our story, whether I like it or not. Our relationship has evolved into something I never could have imagined, with rules and boundaries only we understand.

"Okay," I say finally, pulling her closer. "So how are you going to tell him."

She smiles “I’m our own new special way… How else do you think I’ll tell him.”

We both laugh as a picture her walking naked up to his door wearing nothing but an engagement ring.

Throughout the week, we shop for rings, settling on a simple band with a modest diamond that catches the light just right. It's not flashy or extravagant, but when I slide it onto Sarah's finger in the jewelry store, her eyes well up with tears.

"It's perfect," she whispers, turning her hand to watch the stone sparkle. "Absolutely perfect."

That evening, as we lie in bed planning our announcement to Wiley, Sarah's phone buzzes with a text. She glances at it, then shows me the screen with a raised eyebrow.

"Thinking about you," Wiley has written. "When can I see you again?"

Sarah looks at me, waiting for my reaction. I take a deep breath, the jealousy now familiar, almost comfortable in its discomfort.

"Tell him you will be over on Friday," I say, surprising myself with how steady my voice sounds.

Sarah's smile is radiant as she types the response. When she sets the phone down, she holds up her hand, the engagement ring catching the light.

"To us," she says softly. "To our unconventional ever after."

I pull her close, marveling at the strange path that brought us here. "To us," I echo, knowing that whatever comes next, we'll face it together—on our terms, by our rules.

And somehow, that feels like the most honest vow I could ever make.

What's next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)