“Let’s have a seat and watch the others.”

You gently pull Carrie to an easy chair and sit down. Sitting her down on your lap, you watch Courtney and the redhead open the cabinet and sift through the toys in it. Calling out, you have them toss you a tube of lubricant, which you use on your (still pretty soft) penis.

After a few minutes of stalling and giggling, you finally instruct them to kneel just in front of you on the floor and start kissing. After a few false starts, they lean in close and touch lips. Your eyes roam over their smooth bodies and your hands roam over Carrie’s breasts and thighs. Once you’re fully erect, you whisper your intention in her ear, and are relieved to hear her agree.

As the two other girls try to hold each other close, even though they both have breasts getting in the way, Carrie positions your cock against her anus and slowly lowers herself. At the first inch, she’s moaning happily. Second inch, she’s panting heavily (she’s very tight). Third inch, she stops. “Maybe…” she says, “…maybe I can’t do this… Oh God, oh, it feels so good though.”

You firmly hold her in place and slowly and steadily continue pushing up into her until you’re all the way in her. You begin massaging her breasts and kissing her neck, deliberately avoiding her pussy. “How do you feel?” you ask.

“I feel… oh god, it feels so nice, so wonderful, but so unnatural. But it also feels so… so right. Like this was meant to be. It does… fit rather nicely, doesn’t it?”

“Indeed it does, Carrie, indeed it does.”

“My… pussy? Please?”

“Of course.”