'On my stomach!' (in her ass)

"Cum on my stomach.....just don't cum inside me!" she commanded. I had a better idea. I pulled out, picked up her hips and rubbed my dick against her asshole.

"What are you...OH!!!" I plunged it in before she could finish. "Ow! Hey, don't just mm! shove your dick in my ah! ass suddenly! I've never had hf! one in there. rrf. I'm not your mom."

For a moment I felt bad for hurting her. She was still a woman. But I figured she'd been so rude to me and Shana over our high school careers, I could forgive myself for this. Plus, fuck her for talking about my mom! I continued to fuck her virgin ass, but a little gentler now. I held out longer than I thought I would. Soon, Jenna went from telling me to stop to begging me to keep going.

"Oh!! OH!!! YES!!! OH, IT FEELS SO GOOD!!! YEAH, FUCK ME!! FUCK ME IN MY TIGHT FUCKING ASS!!!"

I couldn't stand it anymore. I scrunched up my face and started cumming in her asshole.

I grabbed her tits tight as I shot load after load in her. It was so much better to cum in a woman than on a Kleenex! I shot the last of my sperm, and collapsed beside her. She looked over at me and smiled, then kissed me on the lips.

"That felt incredible! I mean, officially, I'm still pissed you did my butt without asking, but at least you didn't try to knock me up, so...I appreciate that." She sighed, closed her eyes and smiled in a way that I had to admit was actually really pretty. She looked peaceful and content and...not like a bitch. But of course, she cut that short by glaring at me like usual. "If you tell _anyone_ about this, anyone at school, anyone online, your fucking dog. If this leaves this room, I swear on my Usher shoe that I will fucking ruin you. If anyone mentions seeing me get into your car, you dropped me off at my house, I gave you your ten dollars and you left. End of story. Understood?"

"Why not," I asked, following it with a jokingly-shocked "Are you ashamed of it? Of me?"

"Oh, gee, of course not," she grumbled sarcastically. "Why would I, the heiress of the biggest fortune in the state that doesn't belong to a politician yet, be ashamed that I cheated on the guy who everyone in school knows is my boyfriend with some other guy because she fell for some line he stole from every porno? And who could possibly be ashamed that, not only did I let you do me in the ass, but that I screamed for you to keep going, came hard from it and now I have your cum sloshing around in my colon? Yeah, who wouldn't want to shout that from the fucking rooftops?"

"So why did you let me do that, if it's so awful?"

"Because you were the first guy I saw after finding out."

"That's it?"

"No, I'm in love with you," she said, rolling her eyes as hard as I'd ever seen eyes rolled. "You and your stupid haircut are my dream come true."

"So, if Harold Mertz had wandered into your field of vision at the right time, it would his sperm in you right n-?"

"Ew, no!" She wouldn't even let me finish putting the idea in her head. Poor Harold. Also, what was wrong with my haircut?

"So, I'm above Harold Mertz to you?"

"ugh. Yeah?"

"Then, you'd rather it had been me than some others."

"Are you working toward a point, or are you just fishing for compliments? Yes, you rank higher than dead last on my list of guys I'm willing to let fuck me. OK?"

"So, that must mean there's something you like about me." I put my hands on my cheeks and fidgeted like an embarrassed anime schoolgirl. I almost added 'kyaa~n!', but I figured she wouldn't know what I meant and I didn't want to have to explain it to her.

Jenna sighed. "you are such a prick."