Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 5 by Varlance Varlance

What's next?

Bad End 1 - Team Player

"He let the whole team down," Zach says, "so he should make it up to every one of us."

"Fuck yeah!" Ricky hoots. "But who gets to go first?"

The team looks to their captain. Adam grins. "Sure, it might as well be me I guess." You struggle weakly against the ropes, but hogtied as you are, there's really nothing you can do. The guys cheer Adam on as he peels his swimming trunks down to expose his cock, which is already hard. He scoots forward on the pool float, then grabs you by the hips and pulls you towards him. You grunt into the duct tape wrapped around your mouth. Someone hands Adam a bottle of lube and he uses his fingers to work a generous amount of it into your hole. "Relax, Will," Adam says. Once you're lubed up, Adam eases his cock into your arse, and starts a slow, deep fucking. As you look up into his blue eyes, you wonder if this is how your captain has sex with his boyfriend.

"Oh, yeah, you feel so good wrapped around my dick," Adam says as he continues to pump his cock into you. "So- fucking- good..." You wish he would grab your cock and jerk you off while he fucks you, but Adam seems more interested in his own pleasure. You notice that the lights have been turned down, and someone's started playing music over the PA system. Then Adam steps up his thrusting, and you start moaning through your gag as he rapidly approaches his climax. "Fuck..." You feel his dick swell as he shoots his load inside you, your own dick totally rock-hard and waving to and fro, untouched, needy...

Adam pulls out of your hole, and nods to Fenris, who has been watching the two of you all through Adam's fuck. The Greek right driver blushes and his eyes follow Adam's body all the way back to the poolside, before Fenris takes his place where Adam was. He pushes into you, his entrance facilitated by the load that Adam shot into your arse. He looks at you briefly, before starting to fuck you, but you see his gaze frequently wander over towards where Adam is standing chatting to the others. Fenris doesn't take as long as Adam did, and when he's ready to cum, he pulls out and finishes himself off with his hand, letting his thick, heavy load splash over your crotch and belly. He wipes his hand on your thigh before sliding into the pool.

You lie on the pool float for a few minutes, feeling Fenris's cum drying on your body, until Leo climbs onto the pool float. "How's it going, Wilson?" He gives your exposed cock a few teasing strokes. "Haha, I knew you'd like this." You try to grunt a 'Fuck you' through your gag, but it's hardly worthwhile. "Shame I didn't get to be your first. Oh well. At least I have you all to myself for now." He leans forward, his pale chest warm against yours, his piercing blue eyes inches from yours. For all his bravado, he actually fucks you surprisingly tenderly, his arms caressing your body, stroking your shaft, running through your hair... He moans your name as he releases his load inside you. "Oh fuck, Will..." You almost cum at the same time, but the twine he tied around your dick is still so tight around your cock, and you simply moan in frustration, thrusting your throbbing dick against Leo's firm stomach but unable to stimulate yourself to orgasm.

Sebastian is next, followed by his brother Ricky, then the birthday boy Zach, and finally Steve. Once each of your team-mates has cum in or on you at least once, they finally take pity on you and release you from your bindings. Sebastian and Leo take their time untying you and removing your gag, and then, after you've had some of the party food and a few drinks, the team decides that anyone who wants 'seconds' can ask if you're up for it.

Of course, you agree to everyone's requests. You are, after all, a team player.

THE END

What's next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)