Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 14 by fantaghiro fantaghiro

What's next?

making Sarah into Natalie

Tom's first night with Abby was incredible. He had forgotten how much he had cared for her in high school. Now as a successful, mature woman she was even more amazing! He felt a few pangs of guilt over cheating on Sarah. 'But how can it be cheating?' he told himself. 'Abby is my wife in this life.'

He spent the entire weekend enjoying being Abby's husband, leaving Sarah in 'Natalie mode'. He found he also liked having a daughter. Natalie was a sweet, affectionate girl who had a great relationship with her parents. But she WAS also Sarah, so he couldn't help but feel an attraction for her as well. Finally by the end of the weekend, he was ready to see Sarah again, so he waited until Abby was out running some errands and gave the command.

She was pissed off when he 'woke' her. "The whole weekend, Tom!" she shouted. "You promised you wouldn't leave me like that. And you turned me into her when I was ready to play around. If you're not going to use this time to BE with me, then we should just change back."

Tom wasn't ready to go back - not by a long shot. He could just leave Sarah in Natalie mode, but he DID want to have fun with Sarah as well. But he needed her to be more agreeable. He pulled out the coin while she glared. She nodded and commanded "go ahead!"

Tom silently wished 'I wish Sarah didn't mind when I made her Natalie - that in fact she enjoys being Natalie. And that she doesn't realize I made this wish.'

Her expression immediately softened. "Wait, Tom!" she pleaded. "I...I don't know why I was so upset. The whole point of this was to try something new - for both of us. I LIKE being Natalie. It's just that I don't like being so passive, with absolutely no control."

Tom thought a moment. Maybe he could get the best of both world. Abby as his wife and Sarah as his 'extra loving' daughter. 'I wish Sarah thought I made a wish to give her more control of Natalie. I wish over the next few days the Sarah and Natalie personalities would begin to merge, with Natalie becoming almost completely dominant and the Sarah part making Natalie love me as more than a father, wanting our relationship to be sexual as well. I wish the new Sarah/Natalie will feel no guilt or discomfort about being with her father that way."

Sarah brightened. "Thanks Tom for giving me some control. Let's try this life awhile longer."

Tom smiled.

What's next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)