Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)
Chapter 36 by daregirls21
heads or tails X2
? heads
Blindfolded, and to the best of her knowledge, alone, Tanya waited for her fate. She could sense the peanut butter in her ass crack starting to melt. She wanted to scream "there is peanut butter in my ass crack"
Instead she just felt the sticky substance sit there and wondered if anyone was looking at her naked body.
What must they think of her? They all thought that she was just playing a semi-**** game of truth or dare.
In reality, she had never played much truth or dare with her friends, but she had always assumed that the naked dares were meant to flirt, or get the attention of some guy.
But this had just turned into who could think of something else strange for Tanya to do.
In the distance she could here laughter and joking, but as near as she could tell she was alone. She crossed her arms to cover her breasts and wished that she could see.
The blindfold did it's job though, and it was the approach of footsteps that let her know she was no longer alone.
"Here is your pizza" said Shelly, sounding satisfied.
She knew it was pizza then. It either had Shelly's pee, or Kyle's urine on it. But she would not know which until she tasted it.
Tanya reached out, uncovering her right breast which she felt jiggle slightly. The pizza in her hand, she took a bite....
And it tasted fine.
Everyone burst out snickering around her.
Maybe it had all been a joke. They didn't put anything on it just to see what it would be like....
The second bite tasted nastier than anything she could imagine. It was acidic, and putrid.
The crowd of drunken teenagers around her were in hysterics. Clearly this was the best party they had had in awhile.
If she could have spit it out, she would have. But the spell would not let her.
Still she hesitated before the next bite.
"Eat it eat it eat it" chanted the boys. Shelly's voice was nowhere to be heard, but Tanya knew better than to be relieved. Nothing was crueler than a woman scorned.
She swallowed the rest of the pizza as quickly as she could. After the first bite, the shock was over, although it was far from unpleasant.
Shelly's Dare
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)
"Yes"
A girl cannot refuse any request made of her
Updated on Jun 19, 2026
by madmaniac
Created on Mar 20, 2006
by madmaniac
- 9,415 Likes
- 5,900,874 Views
- 2,283 Favorites
- 1,636 Bookmarks
- 640 Chapters
- 86 Chapters Deep
Comments moved below the chapter.
Jump to comments
Comments