Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 57 by grimbous grimbous

What's next?

Zoey's Solution

“Shit!”

One arm circles around your stomach and another around your chest as Fiona wrests you back and away from Zoey. It is all blur to you in your orgasmic bliss.

“AHH!” Zoey yelps as your huge spurting hog slips from her still climaxing cream filled cunny. You shoot a parting shot across her slit as you are pulled away.

“Fiona!” Elsie gasps in horror. “You…you did that on purpose!”

“No!” Fiona insists. “No El, I swear I didn’t.”

Coming down from your dizzying high you are helplessly moaning and quaking, still impaled on Fiona’s cock, as your sisters talk.

“It’s okay Elsie.” Zoey coos as she melts into a human puddle on the floor, her blue eyes staring up at the ceiling and a huge grin on her face. “Ohhhh wow.”

“It is not okay. Fiona tricked us.” El was on the verge of tears. “I forgave you!”

“El!” Fiona’s voice sounded anxious, even a bit scared. “El no. After today I wouldn’t. After what we talked about. Baby, no. You have to believe me. I didn’t know. How could I?”

“You held him in there!”

“His ass was full on cumming hard. I went as deep as I could and stayed there to let him ride it out. If his ass really is like a pussy, and it sure seems to be, you know how tender things can get after cumming.” She says. She wasn’t wrong. Your whole body, especially your stuffed asshole, was all tingly and sensitive right now. “I didn’t realize he was about to pop. He never warned me.”

“That’s…true.” Elsie says softly.

“Fuck El, you know my feelings around this, but I wouldn’t do this to you baby. Not like this. I swear I wouldn’t.” She then whispers. “I don’t want to lose you again El. Please.”

There is a long tense pause…before El finally nods. “I believe you. This time.”

You could feel your big sister’s body relax behind you as she lets out a breath of relief. You hug Fiona’s arms to your body, showing your love for her, and she hugs you hard back. Fiona was twisted but her love for you and Elsie could not be doubted. Elsie believed her and so did you.

Laying there with a big goofy grin on her pretty face El’s blond bff presses her legs together and squirms. “Ooohhh…my foo foo!” She looks to you. “So much! I’m all gooey inside. He he he! Mmmmm.”

El crawls over to cuddle up beside her friend. “You okay?”

“Okay?” Zoey sighs as she runs her hands up and down her nude body. “Ohhhhh El. Last night and this morning…I’ve never cum so good and so much in my life. I love this family!”

All four of you chuckle. What happened was an accident. What was done was done. There was no use in stressing about it now.

“You on the pill perchance?” Fiona asks. “Any sort of birth control?”

“Nope.” Zoey admits as her eyes shift to Elsie and an even deeper blush colors her already flushed face. “But…”

“But?” El asks.

“I know a solution.”

“Oh?” El says.

“If you’re worried about me being knocked up…” She bites her bottom lip excitedly. “…you could…you could suck it out.” She covers her face then after a second for El to process the request separates her fingers to peek out again. “Wanna suck my creamie coochie? Wanna eat your brother’s creampie Elsie? He he he!”

“Zoey Beckett!” Elsie guffaws in amused surprise.

Zoey’s fingers snap closed again as she shields her face from embarrassment. “I’m so bad!” She titters.

“You are going to fit right in around here darlin.” Fiona chuckles.

Out she peeks once more, this time more sheepishly. “If you eat me out…if you suck it all out quick…then I won’t get pregnant.”

“Then you won’t…?” El looks at her sweet hearted though ditsy friend in giggling disbelief. “Zoey, where did you ever hear that? That’s not true!”

“It isn’t!?” She pulls her hands away and looks down at her cum filled pussy. “Oh.”

“Not that I’m unwilling.” The kinky glint was back in Elsie’s dark eyes as she shifts to begin kissing down Zoey’s soft body. “Mmmm.”

“Oooo!” Zoey says brightly. “Be gentle down there, he really stretched me out.”

You flinch as a Fiona nips the edge of your ear with a sharp nibble. “You want me to be gentle too Jesse?”

Shaking your head vigorously you say. “Hell no!”

"Didn't think so." With impressive strength Fiona holds you tight and rises up to her feet, the impaled rock hard schlong in your ass doing as much work at lifting you as her arms and legs.

“Nnnnnngh!” You groan at the strain, feeling helpless and powerful all at the same time in your big sister’s strong arms.

“He he he.” Without warning Fiona spins you. Grabbing your hair in one hand and the side of your hip with the other she slams your upper body down onto the table, pinning your head in such a way that **** you to watch Zoey and Elsie do their thing. You were all Fiona’s now. There were no others to slow her down or hold her back and she had you all warmed up now. You were at her mercy.

“Ohhh fuuuck!” You mewl elatedly.

What's next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)