You can and you will!

You really want to earn her mysterious prize, so you decide to give her the fucking of a lifetime! She's fucking you softly now. Once she's used to your girth, you're going to pound that pussy.

"So good," she says, "Give it to me."

That's your cue, so you start to pump your hips. You catch her coming down on one of her thrusts and drive yourself into her hard. She grunts as you fill her up. On the next thrust, you do the same.

"Oh yeah- fuck me hard," Shelly cries out.

You somewhat worry about her waking up Ellen, as it may be hard to explain why you're fucking one of her fellow students so soon after hooking up with her and Amy. You have more pressing concerns at the moment though.

You keep fucking her in this same manner, the two of you having worked out a good rhythm by now.

While you can't see her right now, Amy is staring right into Shelly's eyes and rubbing her own pussy. Whether she's aware that this is real or a dream, she loves it!

You have nearly driven her to another orgasm out of her, so you try to finish her off. You reach around the front of her and begin to rub her pussy.

"That's it. I'm cumming! I'm cum-ming," Shelly exclaims as she orgasms.

Amy masturbates even harder as she watches the normally-subdued co-ed cum like a crazed animal. This must be the best dream ever!

Shelly's orgasm finally subsides and she rests against your legs, her cunt still filled up with your dick. It took all of your restraint- aided by your own recent orgasm- to hold out.

"You won first prize," she says, "You get to fuck my ass. How about it?"

"Only a fool would say 'no' to that offer," you reply.

"Ugh...Amy, what's going on?"

You all look over and see Ellen stirring from her spot on the floor. Amy looks at Shelly, who isn't sure what to do.