Willow's a bit of a Size Queen Now

Xander had a sudden very painful charlie horse in his thigh which you would have thought would have aided his efforts to stave off his climax and not be the first person in this impromptu celebratory orgy to blow his load. That wasn't the case and as he shook out his leg and gyrated against Anya's well rounded buttocks, he spewed his jizz inside of her all the while howling in combination pain and pleasure. Thankfully the muscle spasm relented along with his orgasm and he fell to the side of his girlfriend, slumping onto his back with a grateful sigh.

His peaceful relaxation was somewhat marred by Anya complaining, “Xaaander! I hadn't cum yet! Get back on right now!”

Stifling a grumble he pushed himself and brought one hand sliding around the curve of her ass while the other rested on the small of her back. He started to stroke and play with the lips of her very wet pussy thanks to his recent deposit. Anya curled back with a scowl that revealed one lovely shaped breast jiggling with the movement, “No! Your manly rod Xander! That's what I want-what I need! Plus I totally don't feeel pregnant yet!”

Xander dropped the gentle teasing to thrust two fingers deep inside, “Uh An, I don't think you get preggo instantly. Even if you did, I don't think you can just feel it.”

It took a moment for her to respond as her head bent low and she rolled her hips back against his hand, “What do you know?! You're a man and I have my womanly intuition and its saying I'm not pregnant yet!” She turned her head to look at Willow who was sitting nearby, “Willow! Back me up here. I'm right, aren't I?”

Some part of Xander freaked out a little at the reminder that there were other people-his friends-Buffy!-Giles!- having sex here too. But the rest of him just sort of went with it and he didn't even try to cover his flaccid Xander bits from Willow as she got up and moved closer with an odd expression on her face.

“Actually, it does take some time. Xander's sperm cells have to find and penetrate your ovum-er egg provided that there is one to be fertilized. And here let me help you guys out here...” Xander hadn't been paying much attention to either his girlfriend or Willow, his fingers slowing and pumping into Anya only absently as he stared in open mouthed captivation at Buffy and Cordelia having sex. So given that he was focused so intently upon the frankly disgusting but also kind of hot demonic prick driving up into the former cheerleader over and over again, he was not at all prepared for a warm wet mouth to close around his soft member.

Turning to look, he'd expected Anya's blonde head bobbing not.....not Willow's red. But it most certainly was Willow and the things she was doing! His long time friend was sucking and licking, stroking, and fondling with a confidence and familiarity that was down right scary. And his dick was responding with a similar enthusiasm. He groaned and called out, “Oh god! Oh Willow!”

She had a wicked smile as she slid him out of her mouth and held him straight up so that she could press her face down and suck on his balls with loud eager slurps. Xander managed to look up to see how his girlfriend was taking this. She was no longer on her hands and knees having turned to face them both and it looked like she'd been about to say something before she'd been terminally distracted by the vigorous Buffy-Cordelia sexathon going on nearby. She quietly muttered, “...bigger than a Fyarl...” and he would have been slightly perturbed if not for Willow taking his now fully hardened dick back into her mouth. She took all six inches of him with surprising ease and he could even feel her throat tickling his tip.

Anya was becoming increasingly captivated by Buffy and Cordelia, the brunette's loud and demanding, “Come on! Fuck me like Cavegirl Buffy! Come on! I won't break!” and Xander was similarly distracted by Willow's seemingly expert oral talents. So it should come as no surprise that when Willow asked him if he wouldn't mind impregnating her, that his answer was a swift unhesitating yes.

Soon enough he was shuffling between a very naked and alluring Willow's legs.

Xander studied Willow's pussy briefly, finding it quite different from Anya's. The only way he could think to describe it was that it was more... open. Somehow more of her folds and inner pink flesh was on display without her legs being particularly widely spread. He found it pretty alluring and was confident he'd have no trouble inserting himself, wouldn't have to hear her go, “Lower..ah no, higher.” as frequently occurred with Anya.

He looked into her eyes and asked, “Are you ready?”

She nodded with no hesitation and a warm smile and he shuffled forward with his prick in hand. He pressed his tip to her wet slit and slipped inside with ease just as he'd surmised. Her pussy swallowed him fully to the hilt and he gasped at the silky warmth surrounding him.

Willow enjoyed the feeling of him inside, even though she couldn't help but be fully cognizant of how much smaller he was than Buffy. The first cock that she'd taken inside of her, the one that had taken her virginity had been larger, both in length and width. And it only gotten longer and thicker over time. Each time they'd had sex it had seemed like Buffy's cock was just a bit bigger than the time before. The Slayer's completely human size was nearly twelve inches now and Willow's vaginal passage was quite capable of taking the entire thing thanks to countless hours spent wrapped around the growing monster.

Still, these sorts of comparisons weren't fair and certainly not the thoughts she should be having when having sex with Xander. So she put them aside and focused fully on her first best friend as he started to pump his hips. She wrapped her legs around his back and helped guide his thrusts as she thought about which positions would get him the deepest inside of her.