Try Another Strategy

"I... don't want to get cum inside me again otherwise I might not be able to return to normal. Can you stick your fingers in my ass, Steph?" I ask turning back to her as she rubs her cum along my backside.

"Gladly for a cutie with an ass like yours," she says as she licks her lips and gives me a big slobbery kiss. Damn! She is a sexy nymph... a nymph with a huge cock. With no warning, her fingers push into my asshole and starts to thrust inside me.

"Oh shit!" I yell as she fits her knuckles inside me without too much ****. Did she really stretch me that much? It feels good to be filled again, even if it isn't by her wonderful cock. Shit! I've never thought about another cock but my own before. Somehow it looks sexy, dripping with cum. It feels even better than her tiny fist in my ass.

"Is it hard again?" asks Lindsey, looking disappointed.

It is, but Lindsey's pussy feels so loose with my shrinking cock. "Yeah, maybe I can finger you as well..."

"I can finger myself, but I want to be fucked too. Stephanie, why don't you help him? You can DP my pussy."

"...but what about my ass?" I ask as Steph pulls her fist out of me and my cock starts to shrink again. Before I can complain too much Stephanie grabs my wrists and maneuvers my hand around to my asshole. I moan as she pushes my fingers into my cum-soaked gaping asshole.

"Perfect! You got it sexy ass. Just push your digits in a little more and you'll be moaning and spraying your little clitty in no time." With no resistance, Steph flops down beside my girlfriend on the bed and picks her up lining her pussy up with her mammoth member. She looks like a toy doll next to that thing. Lindsey pushes down on the tip, which stretches her out like I never have. Her legs are shaking before she has even taken half of it.

"Oh fuck! Your cock is stretching me out so far. It's so big compared to yours baby." Moans Lindsey "I don't know if I can even take any more." To prove that she can, Steph grabs her hips and spears her down on her rod. "Fuck! I'm cumming!" Lindsey is a shaking mess as she moans and screams, just from hilting Steph's massive fuck stick. I try to stick my cock into Lindsey's pussy as she is cumming to get at the cure, but the seal is too tight and my cock isn't hard enough yet. I start thrusting my fingers into my asshole to get me going as I prod at the connection between the two in front of me.

It feels so good to stuff my hand in my asshole. Something about Stephanie's cum must have me feeling horny and more sensitive, or maybe that's just the changes to my body. I feel tingles shutter through me as I finger my prostate. I get harder and harder as I finger fuck my asshole, but I still can't fit inside Lindsey with Stephanie's huge cock in the way. As Lindsey finally comes down from her orgasm I see an entry and finally stick my cock inside her pussy as well, rubbing up against Steph's destroyer of a penis. I'm only in for a second before I burst my puny load inside her as well, just from finger my own asshole. Only little dribbles of jizz stream out.

"Fuck! Did I get in in time?" I ask as Lindsey starts to bounce ever so slightly on Stephanie's dick. I can tell I am an afterthought.